News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by alistproducer2 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @10:09AM (#11159329)
IMO, A large part of the problem is people of different political views don't talk, face to face, enough. Like in war, it's easier to kill a "gook" or "haji" than a person.

The Internet makes it easy to dehumanize the other side; they're just avatars and words on your screen. It's a lot harder to hate an actual person, especially just for having a different opinion than you.

[Edited]

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by sanderjd on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:23PM (#11161039)
I agree, but anecdotally, as someone who spends a lot of face-to-face time around people on both sides of the typical left-right division, neither of which represent my views, it is very frustrating for me, and I suspect rather pointless for them. I've never left a political conversation like this feeling like I made a dent in anyone's ideology; they just leave thinking I'm a weirdo.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:50PM (#11161253)
I think the same, and I'd go a step further. I don't particularly _want_ to get along with people who have no problem with abortion, nor with people who have no problem with torture. Why should I see being de-polarizing as something desirable? (And where can I move to?)
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by sanderjd on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @02:02PM (#11161372)
I think the article makes lots of good arguments for why being de-polarizing is a desirable thing, so I'm not going to attempt to make better ones.

But I think your comment is a really good example in and of itself. You've done the binary thinking thing that the article discussed in detail! I've never met anyone who has no problem with abortion, or anyone who has no problem with torture, but I've met people who think the trade-offs justify limited use of one or the other, which I agree or disagree with to varying degrees. It seems likely to me that you're either not talking to people that think these things, and instead building straw-men to knock down, or you're not really hearing the people you're talking to. (Or, I'll admit, it's possible you know a lot more extreme people than I do.)

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:48PM (#11162625)
In the case of abortion, I'll grudgingly admit that reasonable people can differ, at least in cases of rape or incest; in life-of-the-mother cases (pregnancy in the Fallopian tube), the other side might even be right.

But on torture? I'm not willing to make any concession to people who think that hanging a Japanese general for waterboarding US soldiers is fine, while leaving a US president entirely unpunished for waterboarding actual and suspected terrorists is not fine. Either we owe the Axis (and especially that general's heirs) some enormous apologies, or we need a few trials of a certain past political administration.

I tend be a fan of bright lines in general. If you don't know that some things are wrong (and, therefore, that any line of reasoning that leads to them has a problem with it somewhere), how do you know when you've gone astray?

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by tamana on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @01:31PM (#11168992)
Your post specifically opened with an example of how important issues don't have bright lines. When the population is split on an issue, it's unlikely that one and only one half are evil/idiots. Life is complicated.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @09:15PM (#11171927)
Abortion gets murky in a narrow range of cases, but torture is never murky. War crimes are war crimes, and they're off limits for everyone, under all circumstances, by definition.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by whitegrape on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:38PM (#11162117)
I find if you can get anyone to consider the tradeoffs of things they believe, that alone makes it possible and worthwhile to have a conversation. But those people are rare. (I think Rich Hickey noted this is even a problem in programming language flamewars...)
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:52PM (#11163937)
That's certainly true -- although I can hardly say that I have a gift for it. More often, I've found that discussing almost any issue results in me making concessions and the other person not doing so; I'm trying to lean the other way and hopefully reach a suitable balance.

This article left me more ticked-off than it should have; I think it's because I got the sense that the author valued consensus and national cohesion more than he valued any ideological question. If the article had said, "we're at war, but remember that chivalry is a good thing," I would have simply agreed; instead, he quoted Lincoln.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by cookiecaper on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @02:58PM (#11161802)
Spend more time with real people and you'll see why it's worthwhile to have relationships with persons who have differing political or social philosophies. Variety in personal judgment and alternative worldviews are really beneficial to be able to access; you can learn a lot that way, and your own perspectives and arguments will be improved.

You don't have to agree, but people are still worth something and still have valuable information no matter how vehemently you disagree with them.

Also note that the vehemence of disagreement is usually heavily exaggerated, for propaganda purposes. Very few people, in the global sense, are sufficiently different from each other that they're actually totally incapable of getting along. If we make a basic effort to keep an open mind, I think we could fix a lot of our contemporary issues.

A total breakdown in communication and dismissal of people on the other side is not a win. It's a massive loss, one that means that the parent society is on thin ice. We need to maintain basic levels of respect for each other.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by m_fayer on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:29PM (#11162054)
I happen to know a few people who have grown up stewing in a sometimes-violent sometimes-cold conflict. They are openly and honestly essentialist racists, and if given the red genocide button would likely push it, or so they say. They are on the borderline about compatriots who question them, making dark jokes about traitors. I've never truly tried to engage with them, hampered by internal disquiet that kept me mostly quiet. I would say the value of knowing them lies in the knowledge of where complete breakdown of the peace leads. But I am disturbed by the way I see them, as lost causes and human writeoffs.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:48PM (#11163914)
I upvoted both you and cookiecaper; I agree with you both.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by bovermyer on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:56PM (#11161308)
I think the idea is to apply "depolarization" generally, rather than specifically. You call out two specific issues; it's fine to not get on with people who have different (and strong) opinions on those positions, but it's entirely different to label an entire broad category of people ("conservatives" or "liberals" in the context of the article) as Evil and Not Worth My Time.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by nikdaheratik on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @10:15PM (#11172132)
I don't think there are very many people who actually have "no problem" with torture, and even fewer who have "no qualms" about abortion. It's just a question of whether they should be legal or not (I'm "no exceptions" for torture, but not abortion, FYI).

And the reason why we should be less polarized, politically, is because there are a large number of important issues that can be solved, and need to be solved, even if we can never come to agreement on others. The way politics is being managed in the U.S. is basically an "all or nothing" grab bag on every single issue, with no chance for compromise, and that just leads to hours of pointless rhetoric and gridlock while the problems just get worse.

IMO, one of the parties is a worse offender than the other, but it really only takes one side being intractable to ensure nothing gets done the way the U.S. government is set up.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by alistproducer2 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @02:12PM (#11161462)
A person as you describe, complete devoid of nuance, would not likely be a very agreeable one. Luckily most people think in varying shades of grey. Lots of us are more "grey" than we think, but you'd never know it unless you talk to people away from the Internet.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:16PM (#11162399)
I'm not sure how many people have "no problem" with either abortion or torture. The people who support them after having thought about it generally do so because they see the alternative as worse, similar to people who want to see hard drugs legalized to ensure people don't have to deal with black markets, criminal gangs, and dangerous substitute chemicals.

(disclosure: I'd ban torture, but for both abortion and most drugs I'd legalise them and try via other methods to reduce the amount that actually occured e.g. better sex-ed and provision of contraception, or better addiction treatment and channeling people towards less harmful (though still currently illegal) drugs.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by kordless on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @12:48PM (#11160732)
As crazy as it sounds (by definition), there's a hypothesis that we get infected with viruses of the mind: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viruses_of_the_Mind

There's also a video explaining it in terms of funny cat video production: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by yoha on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:28PM (#11161065)
Note: this is a CGP Grey video, and a good one!

Another take on this, from Scott Alexander: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/12/17/the-toxoplasma-of-rage/ .

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by oh_sigh on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:24PM (#11162451)
See also: Snowcrash
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by maxxxxx on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @02:12PM (#11161459)
The problem is that they didn't develop their views by really thinking about the issues. They got some focus-group tested soundbite that sounds good to them but they don't really understand it. It's hard to discuss then.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by wolfgke on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @10:34AM (#11159555)
Couldn't it be that it is much better that persons of very different political views don't talk so much, face to face?

I can imagine quite well that this would easily in yelling at each other etc. Also at least me I even get more hate to views someone says if I talk to him/her personally than when I only have to see his/her arguments in the internet.

In other words: That people of very different views don't talk much to each other is in my opinion both a "self-protection" and quite plausibly rather prevents spreading even more hate.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by alistproducer2 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @10:49AM (#11159664)
I disagree. People generally have to work themselves up to a place of such strong opinions. This usually happens when people cocoon themselves in echo chambers.

If you spend 4 hours a day on zerohedge or infowars, you will reach a point where differing opinions piss you off to the point of yelling. If, however, you were getting different perspectives from other human beings on a regular basis, you would likely be less fervent in your views.

It's a lot harder to dismiss actual human beings as "libtards" or "rethugs" or whatever pejorative. You might still disagree, but you usually won't outright dismiss them like you would an article with a "heretical" viewpoint relative to your personal echo chamber.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:52PM (#11161273)
I think that when the stakes are high enough, you have to work to wind yourself down -- not to wind yourself up. And at this point, between Roe v. Wade and Guantanamo Bay (I oppose both, if you're curious), the stakes are definitely high enough.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by a_c_s on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @12:21PM (#11160481)
Looking at how quickly (in societal terms) the gay rights movement in the USA has progressed: the number one thing that changed people's minds was individuals coming out to their friends & family. It is easy to demonize people you've ever met as perverse deviants: very different to hold on to those demonizations when you learn that somebody you've been close to your whole life is a member of this group.

On the other hand, racial minorities can't really do this: prejudices that exist prior to getting to know somebody have a much easier time both preventing people from interacting as well as having a greater likelihood of persisting during interpersonal interactions.

This is a large portion why the gay rights movement has been progressing at a faster rate than either women's rights or civil rights have in this country.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by tat45 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @10:42AM (#11159608)
Speaking from personal experience only, I work with people who are on the other side of the fence from me politically. We manage to have conversations on political matters without it boiling over into contempt and dislike. Probably the fact that it is a workplace and we all want to keep our jobs serves to keep a lid on it.

I find it far easier to depersonalize someone who I don't see in the flesh on a daily basis.

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by tomjen3 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @12:46PM (#11160720)
Are you sure about the contempt and dislike? When I hear somebody say something stupid at work I won't necessarily say anything, or say what I think, but I will change my like/dislike of that person.
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by kbutler on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:25PM (#11162461)
Like, for instance, if they make a comment that sounds like anyone who disagrees with them politically is stupid?

If your only interaction with them is the disagreement, it's far easier to assume they "are stupid" rather than just "have a different opinion."

Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by clock_tower on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @01:52PM (#11161280)
I think he's explicitly saying _expressed_ contempt and dislike: "Probably the fact that it is a workplace and we all want to keep our jobs serves to keep a lid on it."
Re:The Seven Habits of Highly Depolarizing People by the_cat_kittles on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:52PM (#11162235)
the polarization of the american congress (in the 90's) happened in large part because the amount of time congress members spent in each other's company went way down. this is at least the explanation i've gotten from people who worked in the congress. so, it seems like that is at least one data point that supports your argument.