News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by wilsonfiifi on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:30AM (#11157397)
Really pleased to see this, I hope it works out and attracts more foreign tech sector investment into Wales. For anyone visiting the UK for the first time don’t forget to put Cardiff on your list of places to explore! Go Cymru!
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by strongai on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:46AM (#11157462)
I have always wondered why there isn't more tech sector investment in (South) Wales. Low cost of living, good transport links, a fantastic outdoors scene (e.g. world class mountain biking) and strong links with academia. I would choose it in heartbeat over London.

Edit: One of the reasons may be that the politicians' focus is on sponsoring large-scale industrial opportunities to create prospects for thousands of low-skilled unemployed people.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by pjc50 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:44AM (#11157720)
The tech scene loves to cluster, that's why Silicon Valley is so expensive. And there are already tech clusters in London, Cambridge, Edinburgh, Dundee, Liverpool ..

(I'd also question the "good transport links"! The M4? The overpriced railway?)

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by madaxe_again on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:31AM (#11158399)
We manage in Bristol and Bath - and don't forget the canal.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by pjc50 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:15AM (#11158609)
Truly a transport system for the modern age! :)

(Joking aside, Bristol does seem to be doing OK for tech jobs)

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by madaxe_again on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @11:40AM (#11160108)
You kid, but I sometimes stand there, stare at the thing, and think about just-in-time predictive freight for eCommerce - it doesn't have to be fast if it's always on the move.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by awjr on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:12AM (#11158591)
Well the canal is about to be dug up and resurfaced ;)
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by wilsonfiifi on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:04AM (#11157803)
I think there’s probably not enough effort put into retaining graduates in Wales but then again that’s probably due to the lack of tech sector jobs compared to London so it’s a catch 22. Maybe the Welsh Gov needs to be more aggressive in attracting tech companies, startups and investors. But as @ch215 pointed out, traditional sectors that can absorb the readily available semi-skilled work force will most likely be a greater area of focus.

Also the Universities in Wales probably need to attract more lecturers who are pioneers in the field who would normally choose to go other universities such as Bristol, Imperial, etc... (we had Professor R.A. Falconer at Cardiff Uni for instance).

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by junto on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:03AM (#11157533)
There is a tech scene in Cardiff. Small but growing.

Here's one such company who is specialising in helping clients automate all the things - Focus on devops: https://www.devopsguys.com/

There are actually some great opportunities for tech startups in south Wales. Lots of grant money available if you know where to look and can persevere through the paperwork.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by _xenonx_ on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:32AM (#11157664)
http://indycube.cymru/ is help facilitate the tech scene in south wales. Great for co-working.

I have worked and lived in Cardiff, Bristol and London in tech startups and hands down Cardiff is the best for so many reasons. Cheap & lovely people. Welsh tech companies can get loads of grants and trade missions, especially if anywhere outside the Vale of Glamorgan.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by deepvibrations on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:47AM (#11158488)
Me too, though I actually prefer Bristol- I will accept there's a chance that the people in Cardiff may be a little more friendly, but the music scene and street art here is just unbeatable for the size and due to it's position, it's easy to travel elsewhere in the UK. The tech scene is growing at a crazy rate too - I've noticed the number of people at the JS meetups has easily doubled compared to a year ago. One thing we can definitely agree on is that the SouthWest kicks London's ass for general quality of life!
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by ch215 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:59AM (#11157514)
That's right. The Welsh Government gives millions to big business. A few years back, for example, they handed Ford £10 million to keep one of its factories open. Taxpayers' money is also spent on subsidising low pay in the private sector through Jobs Growth Wales. It's unsustainable and the money could be better invested.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by Brakenshire on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:39AM (#11158451)
Isn't that state aid?
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by dTal on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:57AM (#11157995)
As a North Wales-ian who thinks the (robust) tech scene up here is not given its due, this comment thread is annoying (in a ha ha only serious way).

Maybe it's because we like to make Serious Things like airplanes and space telescopes instead of websites.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by Wintamute on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:13AM (#11158055)
I grew up in North Wales and have been working in London in the tech sector for the last 10 years. Considering a move back to the mountains, genuinely interested in what the tech scene is like there now? Can you name some companies?
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by dTal on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:55PM (#11163030)
Cool! I'm no expert, but optics, aerospace, and defense mainly that I'm aware of. Airbus has a huge wing manufacturing plant in Broughton which I'm sure helps anchor the industry, they have massive tie-ins with the local universities through apprenticeships. Prototype mirror segments for the E-ELT project are also being built here[1] (last I checked; there's been some budget problems). I don't know everything that goes on of course, but my own job searches have turned up both interesting-looking embedded work and more run-of-the-mill web stuff, despite my earlier comment. I've seen lots of datacentre/hosting type companies kicking about as well.

It's no Silicon Valley - Wrexham, the population centre, isn't quite (though very nearly) big enough to hold the interest of the intellectually curious - but it's a lot more vibrant than you hear about. Here is the business directory of the business park in St Asaph where they're building the mirror segments:[2]

[1] http://www.glyndwrinnovations.co.uk/articles/latest_news/the... [2] http://www.stasaphbusinesspark.org.uk/directory/

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by wilsonfiifi on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:42AM (#11158177)
other than this link: http://www.itv.com/news/wales/technology/ could you point us to news or tech portals that talk more about "serious" and "non-serious" :-) tech happenings in Wales, genuinely interested!

Edit: seems there's this article [0] as well but its a bit dated.

[0] http://www.dailypost.co.uk/business/business-news/north-wale...

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by chimprich on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:05AM (#11158272)
I can't understand it either, but the situation is changing. I work in Cardiff and there's a growing number of enlightened companies that have recognised what you're saying. It's an exciting time. The Welsh Assembly try to attract tech jobs and have helped a few places but I'm not sure they've got much of an overall strategy.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by VeejayRampay on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:30AM (#11157916)
And surprisingly (at least it was for me, I'm French and stereotype for Welsh people is that they "should be" introverted/rugged), Wales is an extremely welcoming place. I've found the Welsh to be warm, proud of their land and willing to give it a good name to the outside world.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by jarmitage on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:28AM (#11158669)
On the topic of sustainable tech coming out of Wales, check out the Centre for Alternative Technology. They've been going for a few decades and have some great projects. It's also a fun family day out.

http://www.cat.org.uk/index.html

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by cenal on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:29AM (#11157393)
I think Hydrogen Fuel Cells are the future of the automotive world. No range limitations exist once the infrastructure for refueling is in place. It's going to be interesting to see how the next 20-30 years of automotive technology plays out between these alternative fuels and the autonomous driving technologies.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by _ph_ on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:53AM (#11157754)
There are several reasons why I doubt the future of hydrogen fuel cell cars. The biggest problem is, where the hydrogen does come from:

- currently almost all hydrogen is produced from natural gas, releasing CO2 in the process.

- creating hydrogen via electrolysis is possible, but very energy intensive, using up much more electricity than it releases in the fuel cell

- in any case, there is further energy used for compressing the hydrogen.

So, in total a pure electrical car easily drives 3 times as far as a hydrogen fuel cell car with the same amount of input energy. This is going to put hydrogen cars at a big disadvantage to electrical cars.

On the other side, electrical cars are getting to the point where the advantages of hydrogen cars are getting moot. The range is pretty close, and with fast charging the "refuel" does not take much longer as with hydrogen cars - but you normally can charge them overnight and not have to recharge them on the road in day-to-day business.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by gambiting on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:45AM (#11157961)
And don't forget that you need a 70kg lead cylinder to store just 1 kilogram of hydrogen. And hydrogen, being the smallest particle, escapes from literally any container, no matter what it's made from. Usually a whole tank will leak out naturally within 2-3 weeks. That's really not ideal, not to mention dangerous if your car is parked in a closed garage.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by ars on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:01AM (#11157519)
> I think Hydrogen Fuel Cells are the future of the automotive world.

It's unlikely.

Hydrogen makes a poor fuel because it's very hard to store. It leaks through almost anything, and embrittles most metal.

It's possible to store, but it's expensive. It's also not very dense, so you need a lot of pressure, which just makes the storage/leakage problem worse.

I think Methane might be the fuel (not energy source) of the future. It has almost all the advantages of hydrogen, with much fewer problems.

The energy source can be something else, so the CO2 emissions of methane are not relevant.

Unrelated, but if we could store mono-atomic hydrogen, that would be something! There is more energy available in hydrogen bonding with itself than with oxygen.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by jacquesm on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:46AM (#11158485)
And finally, hydrogen tends to go 'foom'.

Compared to all the other ways in which you could propel a car hydrogen is a very dangerous one and that alone is reason enough why it probably will never happen. Compared to LPG for instance hydrogen is much harder on the system and much more dangerous to handle. I don't see it happening any time soon.

Keep in mind that a lot of inner city parking space is indoors / underground.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by vlehto on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:56AM (#11157503)
I think Vegetable Oil Fuel Cells are the future of the automotive world. No range limitations exist now. Adapting infra is like adapting new grade of gasoline. Now chronic fuel leakage exists now. Filling the tank is not rocket science. No volumetric energy density problems for the fuel. No fishy "we make this fuel out of natural gas, but don't talk about it" shit about it. No need for high pressure containers. And it comes with all the good things that you get from fuel cells, but you can also use it with traditional diesel motors.

The problems: Some C02 comes out of the exhaust. But it's carbon neutral. Hydrogen has the "water out of tailpipe!" hype about it, but it's only really clean if that hydrogen is made with electricity that comes from nuclear or renewable (and clean) sources. Most hydrogen is produced from natural gas at the moment.

The other problem is that we have limited capability to produce vegetable oil. But we also have limited capability to produce hydrogen. With hydrogen you could go with massive increase of nuclear power, and you got it. But currently there is also research for oils produced by seaweeds that looks quite promising.

Edit: Seems like Fuel Cell technology would be great, but it's held back by hydrogen hype. And hydrogen hype seems to be destined as hype, because hydrogen is freakishly difficult substance to deal with.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by _ph_ on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:05AM (#11157808)
We should use anything edible for feeding people, not burn it for driving cars. Solar cells are far more energy efficient per area (about 10x) than any agriculture. And, while "grown" fuel might be CO2 neutral, it still produces the same poisonous combustion byproducts as fossil fuel (NOx, fine particles).
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by JupiterMoon on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:56AM (#11158236)
The OP suggested fuel cells. This would replace IC engines and should result in complete conversion to CO2+H2O (with the whole process being carbon neutral because the CO2 came from the air originally). I.e no NOx, fine particles etc.

I agree on feeding people however e.g. algae produced bio oil could be very space conservative -- and could be used to e.g. clean waste water.

NB use of could and should rather than would throughout this post. Algae produced bio oils are a matter of research at the moment and I don't think that the fuel cells exist yet.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by vlehto on Wednesday February 24, 2016 @03:09PM (#11169808)
In large scale I'd agree that only using vegetable oil for car fuel seems like bad idea, because we seem to be running out of food at that point. But using electricity conversed to hydrogen with relatively bad efficiency (70%) we are soon running out of electricity too. Combine that with hopefully shift from fossil fuels to renewable, and the shit we are in deepens.

Now if you could use batteries and electric cars for short trips you would have very high efficiency. Then shift to refueling capable system for long range needs. This is only possible if the "long range" system has very low infra needs.

Optimally we would have some kind of standard that would allow you to swap battery to fuel tank + fuel cell unit in your electric car. I've ranted about that previously.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10942912

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by creshal on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:44AM (#11157717)
> Hydrogen has the "water out of tailpipe!" hype about it

¹ May or may not contain traces of hydrogen peroxide, but shhhh.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by masklinn on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:51AM (#11157747)
Does that really matter? Isn't the trace of hydrogen peroxide in water output going to be irrelevant and decompose into water on short order?
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by huhtenberg on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:54AM (#11157499)
> No range limitations exist once the infrastructure for refueling is in place

Holds true for any type of energy source.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by ars on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:03AM (#11157529)
Mostly true, but only if refueling doesn't take more than 5 minutes or so. So not necessarily true for battery energy storage.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by mikeash on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:26AM (#11158658)
The current state of the art requires charging for 20-30 minutes for every 2-3 hours of driving. Not ideal, but pretty good. Already good enough to make for the best road trip experience out there as a whole. And that's today, not some hypothetical future. How good will it be by the time hydrogen fueling stations are more than a novelty?
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by duhast on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:29AM (#11157648)
Tesla demonstrated battery swap in less than 2 minutes. So it is at least technically possible.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by ars on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:57AM (#11157770)
Technically, but not practically.

You'd have to have some government involvement here so that all batteries are owned by the same entity, so you can swap batteries from different manufacturers, at any energy station.

You also have to standardize on only a few battery types, which makes it harder to design the car, since you can't custom fix the battery to available space.

And that means future battery advances are impractical - who wants to use a battery that can't be part of the swap network?

It's not realistic.

A hybrid power system is more practical - use hydrocarbon fuel for >50 mile trips, and a battery you plugin at home for shorter trips.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by keenerd on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:44AM (#11158188)
Practically it could work out very well.

The Big Three might voluntarily standardize on a battery formfactor and swapping bay, because it would put them ahead of Tesla. "Our patent is free, follow our lead Mr Musk."

There could still be plenty of flexibility in shape, but it would likely be constrained. Like, the width/depth must be a fixed number of centimeters, and there must be a common connector and common mounting points. But the length is up to the manufacturer, programmed into an RFID tag for the swapping bay. (And you'd be able to use shorter batteries inside a larger vehicle.)

Battery advances are the most trivial of all to incorporate. Already li-ion packs require dedicated charging circuitry. The exact cells used don't matter, a tenth-of-a-cent EEPROM is programmed with the charging curves of the cell chemistry.

If anything battery tech will advance much faster with swapping. Without swapping you have to be very conservative. Advances can only be introduced with new models (so once a year) and are very costly to get wrong across a fleet. With swapping you could put a couple of prototypes into the pool every month, and swap them out immediately if the prototype underperforms.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by Shivetya on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:39PM (#11162563)
but they did nothing with it. there is a lot of talk it was only done to qualify for a specific tax break and after that one station where have they built more? is that one station even open to the public?

to be honest I think the idea of swapping the battery is more of admission of the shortfalls of battery technology than anything. Now I think having a battery that swaps is more interesting from the serviceability aspect

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by nkoren on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:43AM (#11157715)
...until battery-swap technology was invented.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by masklinn on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:53AM (#11157752)
That's not really a mass-market option, you'd need to stock large amounts of batteries for a fuckton of different models (each car or at least segment or manufacturer having their own battery geometry), or all cars would need to use modular batteries which loses structural advantages and reduces storage capacity. Battery-swap is more of a stunt than anything useful.

All vehicles can load up at a pump, you can't swap the same batteries in a tuktuk, a large sedan and a bus.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by jacquesm on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @07:46AM (#11158487)
You meant 'until it was made practical'. It was invented more than a 100 years ago.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by rurban on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @04:48AM (#11157737)
If the safety problems are solved, yes.

But just one tiny explosion, as in the Tesla batteries when loading as it happens with the cheap chinese hoverboards, and the company is doomed. Just think of the Hindenburg desaster.

See e.g. https://www.propublica.org/article/a-new-road-rage

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by ars on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @05:26AM (#11157902)
Explosion from hydrogen? Not a problem at all - hydrogen is MUCH MUCH safer than gasoline.

The main reason for that is that it doesn't stick around - it's lighter than air, so all the fuel rises instantly, and so does the bulk of the fire, which stays with the fuel.

It makes hydrogen fires rather safe as fires go - they are out within seconds.

For example the hydrogen fire in the Hindenburg was out within about 10 to 15 seconds. The casualties came from burning fabric and other things (like crashing).

Hydrogen is not a good fuel for other reasons (see my other post), but not because of safety.

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by _ph_ on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @06:53AM (#11158224)
This might be true for leaks in ventilated spaces, but I am really scared by the idea there could be a hydrogen leak in an underground garage. Also, in the case of a traffic accident, we are talking about a high pressure tank, so the risk of the tank failing structurally is much larger than with the unprepared fuel tank. Finally, hydrogen is much easier to light than fuel.
Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by sharps_xp on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @03:37AM (#11157424)
from my brief reading about hydrogen fuel, that infrastructure is going to be crazy expensive and going to be political suicide for anyone who wants to write policy supporting it.

Let's just pour all that money into making superconductivity at room temperatures a reality!

Re:Welsh-made hydrogen car prototype unveiled for trial by mikeash on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @08:30AM (#11158679)
A hydrogen fueling station costs millions of dollars. A Tesla supercharger costs maybe $200,000. A home charging station is typically less than $2,000. I can't understand why anyone thinks hydrogen is worthwhile.