News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by dredmorbius on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:51PM (#11147839)
Funny you should ask....

If I'm looking for something to buy:

1. I'll search for it directly. In particular, I'm interested in solid reviews. This quite often means not giving much credence to review mills -- CNET, Yelp, etc., -- where the nature and intentions of reviewers are quite often suspect. Amazon have this problem as well, though to a very slightly lesser extent.

2. Map-based systems (OpenStreetMap, Google Maps) are often what I use when seeking a specific option locally. I suspect thes are underappreciated.

3. Classifieds systems. There's a reason Craigslist took off like it did, though its quality/relevance have been lagging for some time. It's still ground zero for housing ads.

High quality recommendations mean a lot. I happened to be reading a blog through one of my rare unfiltered browsers, and realised it included book recommendations on the sidebar, for which the blog editor was highly qualified to offer assessments and endorsements. The state of advertising is so bad that I had missed these previously. The blog would be better off putting those recommendations into posts or other content less likely to be filtered. First time in quite literally years that I'd had the least sense of missing something.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by kasey_junk on Sunday February 21, 2016 @10:46PM (#11148300)
Many (maybe most?) ads are not looking for an immediate conversion. They are looking for long term impacts. Its why lifestyle programs like Top Gear are so valuable.

Half the ads I see on the internet are for pickup trucks, something I'm clearly not going to click through & buy.

Interestingly enough, I did buy a truck I don't need recently...

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by dredmorbius on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:25PM (#11148432)
Right, and the branding power of advertising is significant. It's been argued (persuasively IMO) that targeted advertising is counterproductive in this regard.

Much as I find the practice annoying, a large stadium or other facility endorsement programme has a sticking power for brand awareness which a microtargeted, microsecond-auction online placement doesn't. Much the same as investing in streetfront retail space speaks to a certain confidence in your own products or services.

Don Marti and Doc Searls have both written on this many times and at length.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by kasey_junk on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:36PM (#11148471)
I think one of the arguments for the more specific form of targeted advertising is for the measurement of impact, not that it is in some way more impactful.

Assumedly that measurement can lead to more impactful ads, but we are awfully new to programmatic advertising for that to be proveable.

I do know that advertisers believe targeting is valuable.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by dredmorbius on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:16AM (#11148647)
IMO that single-targeting-impact measurement is grossly misplaced. Though this also isn't generally my area of expertise (I have however worked in campaign assessment for various marketing efforts).

Better IMO is to look at broader measures of response. Multiple campaigns with various metrics -- coupons, response codes, promotions, differing Web URLs, etc. See what has a better measured response as an aggregate on desired outcomes.

The problem with ever-more-intrusive-and-objectionable advertising is that it turns people off.

I've largely abandoned commercial media, will consciously avoid stores whose advertising (or products) are annoying, and keep winnowing down the list of mobile service providers who are even vaguely acceptable to me (if I can possible swing it, I don't carry a phone), due in part to consideration shown their own customers.

I'm hoping that eventually those negatives will be large enough to sway practices. Google are actually in a position to have an impact, I've encouraged them on this before.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by Hoasi on Monday February 22, 2016 @04:41PM (#11154504)
The thing is, marketers are still ”experimenting" for the most part. Just as traditional advertising was sold to clients for years even when its efficiency could not be measured. Right now, it can be measured better through tracking, direct mail, “CRM” and the likes, but it doesn't mean it translates into sales—far from it. Digital agencies are surfing on the hype and cashing in as fast as they can before clients cut their advertising budgets again, just as it happened with other channels, like TV ads for instance.
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by punee on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:38AM (#11149881)
It's quite telling, but by no means surprising on Hacker News, that you completely failed to address the question.

The question wasn't "What would you do if you were looking for something to buy".

The question is: "What would you do if you were a business and had something to sell?"

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by aninhumer on Monday February 22, 2016 @10:01AM (#11151181)
But the answer to the latter depends on the answer to the former. For example, if people tend to rely on review sites to make their choices, you should make sure your product compares favourably to the competition, and then solicit reviews for it. (And if you can't do that, maybe your product isn't worth buying.)
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by punee on Monday February 22, 2016 @10:30AM (#11151429)
People tend to rely on watching television commercials to learn about new products. So you should buy more TV advertising. Correct?
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by aninhumer on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:41PM (#11153175)
The question was in a hypothetical context of a world without advertising. My point is that you can't talk about what a business should do in that situation without first clarifying what the alternative to advertising is in this world.
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by dredmorbius on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:24AM (#11151924)
Quite, yes.
Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by MiddleEndian on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:56AM (#11152239)
>The question is: "What would you do if you were a business and had something to sell?"

Make a high quality product.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by dredmorbius on Monday February 22, 2016 @09:56PM (#11156152)
Useful but not sufficient on its own. Gresham's Law, in various incarnations, including Akerlof's "The Market for Lemons" suggests limitations.

A trusted third-party reviewer (Consumer's Union, CarFAX, Kelly Blue Book) helps.

Anecdote: the last really big-ticket item I bought (automobile), I'd had positive experiences with two manufacturer's products previously, but really didn't care for their current offerings within the product class / price range I was seeking. The vehicle I did buy was one I considered based on its Edmunds review -- best in class, multiple years running. Some years on, I've been happy with the purchase (though of course, post hoc rationalisation is a common fallacy).

For other products, other signifiers matter.

On G+ I detailed frustrations looking for a decent LED cabinet-lighting system. I'd exhausted local, online (Amazon and major hardware/lighting store) sources. A recommendation from my G+ contacts was for Ikea. The specific product didn't work, but Ikea had another set of lighting components (separate cord, transformer, remote switch, and lighting elements) which has worked excellently. Took a few weeks longer than intended to find what I was looking for.

Otherwise, I rely strongly on what local retailers will carry and stand behind. Ikea, for some products, turns out to be a good source. Factors depend heavily on what it is I'm purchasing and just how it will have to function.

Re:The Ad Blocking Wars by m52go on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:18PM (#11154749)
I'm sure the failed entrepreneurs in this crowd (I'm one of them) here will find it easy to refute that point.

High-quality product is nothing without leads (i.e, potential users, buyers, downloaders, etc), and one way to get consistent, reliable way to get leads is through promotion.

Then there's branding and awareness, which is probably what most ads these days are meant for.