What is really needed is a concept for micro-transactions - transactions that may even go down to fractions of a cent!
If you're a newspaper and you're trying to sell an article (e.g.) for 20 cents, it's not possible unless you use Bitcoin, and even then it's a hassle.
Adblock Plus might actually be in the position to introduce a platform for this - in contrast to Flattr, they have a huge userbase, a massive number of clients for their opt-out scheme... I'd gladly put, say, 10-20€ a month on my Adblock account, and enjoy a web free of paywalls, advertising, malvertising, video eating off my mobile data...
https://medium.com/@rayalez/somebody-should-create-a-youtube...
tl;dr - I think that youtube red model would work really well for this.
Aka permission-based marketing. Most common examples being email and SMS subscriptions. Most studies of marketers actually conclude that email marketing is their most effective tactic.
Don't overthink it.
Advertisers will pay users directly - through some kind of micro-payment process.
Users will choose which sites they use to view the ads and obtain their revenue through.
Websites will compete for users by providing services or content, that users may decide to pay for from the revenue they receive from advertisers.
The advertising abuses and the tracking will stop when users reward only the advertisers and websites that behave ethically.
The above is a simplification of course, there's a long way to go before it happens, but I think the advertising world will grudgingly accept it eventually.
Publisher gets a cut, for providing a place for the ad, having made the consumer come to it, and also for providing information on the consumer's interests. This is the current situation.
But the consumer would get a cut too. For renting his pixels, his CPU, his internet connection, his eyes, his brain. He would get to veto types of ads he dislikes. He would get to say he only wants 30% of ads to be displayed (and let the crowd define these 30%). He could partitipate in surveys, share his buyings lists, share events of his life (ex moving to a new city), in exchange for better revenue, or deals.
This (tiny) revenue really could help bootstrap microtransaction. On top of that, if the NYT can benefit from the microtransactions, the NYT will talk of such a program. Adoption could be boosted by all the news outlets.
Would participate as a consumer? Do you think publisher, advertisers, announcers would participate too?