News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:05AM (#11144987)
The irony is that Uber is somehow showing that you don't need taxi licenses to run a responsible taxi service from the point of view of the drivers. It's totally doable to run an effective and safe service without requiring taxi licenses.

The problem is their morals when it comes to how they treat their drivers.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:08AM (#11145000)
The insurance of Uber cars outside the US is dubious. I'd question whether uninsured cabs are a safe option.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by TheCoreh on Sunday February 21, 2016 @12:42PM (#11145471)
Here in Brazil at least, Uber requires drivers to pay insurance for both them and the passengers for any potential accidents.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by vkou on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:24PM (#11145703)
Do any private insurers offer packages which permit the use of the vehicle as a taxi?

Does Uber check that their drivers have such insurance?

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:37PM (#11146375)
Does Uber check those insurance documents?
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:04PM (#11145598)
Not in Denmark although a small country. In fact most European countries will have them insure themselves to the extend it's needed to be self employed to begin with.

Also the US insurance (and legal) system is a very unique one which other countries don't actually have. So not sure what you are worried about from that perspective.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:53PM (#11145866)
In the US Uber provides insurance to the drivers.

Outside the US drivers are responsible for their own insurance.

How do you know the Uber you get into has suitable insurance? Any commercial passenger carrying driver needs more insurance than a normal car driver.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by Negitivefrags on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:28PM (#11146326)
Why would you need to know that the car you are getting into has insurance? What difference could it make to you? Isn't that entirely their problem?

Perhaps I'm missing something as a non-US citizen.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:36PM (#11146372)
In the US Uber provides insurance for all their drivers. Outside the US the drivers have to buy their own insurance.

In, for example, England the insurance is part of the regulatory burden. I know that a taxi in England has valid insurance. I don't know if an English Uber car has valid insurance.

Uber avoids the regulation, and under-insured cars is one risk of that.

> What difference could it make to you?

The car crashes and you lose a hand. This puts you out of work for a few months; makes it much harder for you to get new jobs; reduces your productivity. You'll need some modifications to your home. You'll need money. A properly insured car makes it easier to get that money.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by cnorthwood on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:01PM (#11146500)
In England, Uber is licensed as a minicab firm (taxicabs you can hire on the street, minicabs you must order through an operator, and the Uber app acts as the operator). Uber play completely fair with the regulation here (maybe the regulation was never as onerous as in the states). You can generally see on the side of the vehicle that it has the licensing from the appropriate council. The council won't license a minicab that doesn't have insurance.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by barkingcat on Sunday February 21, 2016 @10:11PM (#11148169)
That means Uber in England at least is obeying local laws. In other countries Uber is not registering and licensing as the local equivalent of minicab, that's why they are getting banned.

I think Uber should want to obey laws in the territories that it is trying to operate in. To not do so is just picking the wrong kind of fight.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by Negitivefrags on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:44PM (#11146413)
Right, I guess I never considered that since I live in a place that has public healthcare.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:18PM (#11146588)
Even with public health care you're going to need money.

England has public health care, but you're going to want a better prosthetic and you're going to want money to make adaptations to your home over what will be available. And you're going to want money to cover your reduced income while you're off work.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by brrrt on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:12PM (#11146878)
So liability insurance - isn't that generally required by law in European countries? I know it's illegal to own a car w/o such insurance in Denmark, for instance.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kalleboo on Sunday February 21, 2016 @09:32PM (#11148029)
Regular private car insurance excludes commercial use. Same with how regular home insurance doesn't cover if you run a storefront from your home.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by nommm-nommm on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:21PM (#11148414)
Yes, everyone has personal insurance that covers your car for personal use. You can't register a car without that in all places I know of.

The issue is they also must have insurance that covers them for business use when they are using their car for business. Every personal insurance policy I've read says it isn't in effect when the car is being used for business purposes. If I tried to file a claim under my personal automobile policy it would go something like this

"...and you were driving for Uber at the time? Yeah...lol."

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:26PM (#11146628)
But that will also mostly be paid by the public welfare system even if it came to that.

It looks more like you are clinging to some edge case potential for something thats most likely not going to happen in any meaningful way.

Again. Europe is very different than the US in that regard.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by roel_v on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:03PM (#11147112)
In 'Europe' also there are many damages you will be left hanging with if whoever caused your damage is not insured. If you think you're golden when something happens to you because you live in Europe, you're in for a rude awakening in case something would happen. There are many personal injury lawyers across Europe. They just don't make as much money because of no punititve damages.

(Example off the cuff, was on tv a while ago: girl gets ankle damaged in accident at car show. Yes the foot gets the plaster 'for free', but here are some other costs that aren't covered by national insurance: travel costs, time off for parents, adaptation to the house to accommodate reduced mobility, wheelchair-accessible car, ...) Please tell me if I'm wrong, but I know of no social healthcare system that covers such costs).

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kalleboo on Sunday February 21, 2016 @09:26PM (#11148005)
I can only speak for Sweden, but travel costs are definitely covered (since it's cheaper than an ambulance), and the general welfare system covers grants for adaptation of houses and cars for wheelchair-accessibility. E.g. https://www.alingsas.se/sites/default/files/bidrag_till_bost... and http://www.forsakringskassan.se/privatpers/funktionsnedsattn...
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:44PM (#11146723)
I'm not sure why you keep mentioning the US, I'm not talking about the US.

The only reason I mention the US is because Uber takes care of the insurance for Uber drivers in the US, but they don't do that anywhere else. Everywhere else the drivers are expected to buy the insurance. In some places you know that Uber are regulated as part of the taxi system and so you know the drivers will have bought insurance as part of that regulation. But that's not everywhere.

Properly insured cars are really important, even when you live in an area with public health care and welfare systems. There are many costs involved in severe injury that are only minimally covered by public welfare.

This is not a super rare event! About 1,700 people die each year in road traffic accidents in Great Britain. (And that's the lowest it's been since records began). Very many more are severely injured.

In England you'll get minimal help from public welfare systems - you'll get a prosthetic limb but you'll want a better one, and that will cost. You'll want to make adaptations to your home - you'll get some help, but you'll want more and better adaptations. Depending how you're employed you'll get some statutory sick pay or disability benefit, but these are likely to be much less than you were earning. (Statutory sick pay is £88.25 per week for 28 weeks.)

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:31PM (#11146952)
I still don't understand what your point is.

My original point was that Uber because of it's use of technology have solved the problems that would normally require licenses. I.e. it's as safe to drive as any other service.

Insurance is a minor problem which 1) can easily be fixed, 2) isn't really a problem with the uber model.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kybernetyk on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:06PM (#11146849)
Yes, sure, the medical bills will be paid to an extent. But what about you losing your income? Making your home fit for being disabled? Rehabilitation? (Public system pays only the bare minimum here).
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by Negitivefrags on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:28PM (#11146938)
Well, in my country at least (NZ), everyone automatically has insurance to cover all of that for accidents. It's called ACC. In exchange for that, we have a "no-fault" system so you can't sue someone for an accident making the concept of liability insurance for accidents something that doesn't exist here.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by Nutmog on Sunday February 21, 2016 @09:31PM (#11148023)
That's nice for people getting injured. Insurance then becomes something you get to protect yourself, not because you're required to have it to protect other people. If you crash into an expensive car, you're still on the hook for the cost of that unless you have your own insurance. But that's a decision you can make yourself if you're worried about the risk of causing expensive damage - no need to worry about whether every car you go near is insured.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by nommm-nommm on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:29PM (#11148449)
serious questions.

Does public healthcare help you if you need to install a wheelchair ramp in your home? Or other lifestyle modifications that are a result of injury? Such as increased costs of transportation? Lost wages?

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:27PM (#11146036)
As parent said, the USA market is unique. How do you know your taxi has suitable insurance! Or insurance at all? Insurance laws in China are completely different from the US (everyone is seriously under insured, even the normal taxis).
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:31PM (#11146339)
In England I know my taxi has insurance because it's part of the regulation.

In England I have no way of knowing whether my Uber has valid insurance for carrying passengers.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:08PM (#11147621)
I have no idea about England. Not everyone lives in England, some of us even live in Asia. My point is that Uber should follow the laws of the countries they are in, and if those laws are holy (in the sense that adequate insurance is not enforced or not apparent), then that is a problem with the laws, not Uber's business model.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:17PM (#11146586)
What kind of insurance are you talking about? The driver has insurance for driving their car how can that ever be the passengers problem?
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:51PM (#11146758)
How would I know the driver has an insurance which covers driving people for profit? The usual insurances do not. If something would going to happen to a passenger they do not know whether that is covered.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:37PM (#11146986)
Well that seems to be a problem with legislation not the uber model per se. Just don't see the problem but then again I don't live in the UK so I don't hear about all those examples of that happening.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:29PM (#11147242)
The legislation is already there: If you drive around you need insurance. That is a sensible policy. Uber saves cost because neither they nor their drivers are appropriately insured. It's only a matter of time until something bad happens.

It's not a problem of legislation but a problem with Uber.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:06PM (#11147616)
Its not a problem with Uber but with the drivers. Uber could require proof of appropriate insurance when onboarding new drivers though.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:53PM (#11146776)
People carrying paying passengers need extra insurance.

The normal insurance a car driver has does not cover them if they take paying passengers.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:15PM (#11146574)
Can you come with a specific example?

I don't see the issue. Most european countries have insurance either via the wellfare state or through legislation or insurances. What do the passenger care about drivers insurance for? If anything Uber is not going to leave just an inch of potential room for critique so of course they are insured as you need to be just in order to own a car.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by DanBC on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:52PM (#11146772)
In England all car drivers need insurance. But car drivers who carry passengers need extra insurance.

In the US Uber buys this extra insurance for all their drivers. Outside the US Uber does not buy this extra insurance. It tells drivers that they have to buy their own extra insurance. Remember, this is extra insurance on top of the regular insurance that all car drivers must have.

In some countries Uber drivers are regulated just as normal minicabs, and the regulators will check that the uber driver has this extra insurance. But in some other countries Uber is aggressively resisting that regulation, and there are concerns that the cars are not properly insured.

Imagine if you lost an arm tomorrow, or had a brain injury. You may get all your hospital treatment for free. You may get all the prosthetic limbs for free. You might get some paid leave from work. But even so, you are going to be left with large costs. Those costs are covered by insurance. But if you were a paying passenger in a car, and the car driver did not have the extra insurance, you would not be covered by their insurance. You would not get the money you need. You could try to sue the driver, but if the driver is poor you're unlikely to get the money.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by briandear on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:04PM (#11147381)
Perhaps it would be prudent to have disability insurance on yourself and not worry about the driver's insurance. How do you know that drunk driver that hits you while your crossing the street has insurance? How does anyone know anything? Insure yourself, the it makes no difference what other people are doing. It's called personal responsibility. Definitely a foreign concept in Europe, but not completely extinct.

Think about this.. In a normal taxi, how do you know the driver has insurance? Perhaps it has expired. It's no different than any other kind of business. Relying upon someone else to be insured is just foolish.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by wpietri on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:13PM (#11147417)
I love that you think personal responsibility means me having to pay in case somebody else hits me with a car. Rather than them being personally responsible for their driving into me.

Regardless, the way insurers generally work is that they will try to recover the cost of damage for the responsible party. So, for example, if you have homeowner's insurance and somebody drives into your house, your insurer will pay you and then try to recover the costs from the the driver's insurance company.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by nommm-nommm on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:48PM (#11148514)
You know most cars/business have insurance because the state checks that. Sure there may be some who get by for a little while but the system is very effective for the most part!
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:42PM (#11146718)
There is a difference between a regular car insurance (which indeed everybody is required to have) and a commercial car insurance. The former excludes damages while transporting passengers for profit which is fine according to law and will not pay if an Uber driver has an accident.

I do not need to fear that nobody is going to pay my healthcare after an accident. However, that is paid by the public at large instead of the one responsible (so Uber shifts liability away from them to society). Additionally, nobody is going to reimburse my other damages, such as loss of earnings if the driver can't pay.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by briandear on Sunday February 21, 2016 @07:07PM (#11147396)
Insure yourself. Why would you not have disability insurance or protection against lost wages? That's foolish. What if you fell down the stairs? Are you going to shift that burden onto society because you failed to insure yourself?
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Monday February 22, 2016 @02:53AM (#11149252)
That's not the point. Of course I can insure myself. But the price of my insurance and everybody else's is calculated with the knowledge that in case of a traffic accident they don't need to pay. As traffic accidents are the most common this significantly reduces the premiums. If more and more drivers are not appropriately insured they need to recalculate that.

This is shifting the burden to society, in the name of unnecessary high premiums for those who insured themselves.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:32PM (#11146960)
You will have same issue when driving with a friend of your no. Or are you saying they aren't covered in the UK then? That seems to be easily fixable.

Again sure you can blow it up to be a big problem but it's easily fixable and doesn't in itself take anything away from the original point which started this weird insurance thread.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by roel_v on Sunday February 21, 2016 @05:55PM (#11147072)
No, those are insured. Personal passengers != business passengers.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by nommm-nommm on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:01AM (#11148573)
There's a big difference between your buddy paying you $20 to take him to the airport couple times a year and regularly giving strangers rides where you expect to make a profit.

Even if you picked up a hitchhiker and they gave you $20 for your troubles that hitchhiker is not your customer and you don't regularly drive around looking for hitchhikers to make a profit.

It's actually pretty straightforward. That's why the term "sharing economy" is so disingenuous; nothing but doublespeak.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:24PM (#11147219)
Usually my friends don't pay me to drive them (or if they do it is to cover cost and not make profit).
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by marincounty on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:56PM (#11146474)
In the US you need something called Ride Share Insurance.

I couldn't find a price quote, but I imagine it's not cheap.

Your current policy holder is not required to offer this special insurance. They can cancel you if they feel you are driving for Uber without telling them.

No beefs with Uber, other than stop fooling with vechicle requirements, and fees. You're hiring independent contractors?

Oh yea, whatever you do don't go into debt over Uber. Buying a new Prius to work for this company seems rediculious.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by Laforet on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:14PM (#11146569)
In New Zealand, Uber drivers are required to have a drivers licence to carry paying passengers (P endorsement) and have commercial insurance.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kuschku on Sunday February 21, 2016 @12:14PM (#11145327)
The German license is just the requirement for the driver to actually have a drivers license.

In Germany people who want to transport others for profit need a special drivers license. Say bus drivers, taxi drivers, chauffeurs, etc.

If Uber drivers are willing to get this license, they can operate completely legally.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by johannes1234321 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @12:48PM (#11145502)
No they can't. In Germany Taxus have a lot of regulation. Among other things: Fixed prices approved by city councils (I.e. no extra charges in times of high demand), "Beförderungspflicht" (the driver can't easily deny a trip, even when goinh just round the corner), taxi operators have to ensure providing "enough" round the clock service and a few such more things Reason is to ensure taxis are a reliable part of pulic transit systems.

You can make the "Personenbeförderugsschein" which allows to do "shuttle services" but compared to taxis they can't randomly pick up passengers but I.e. have to return to their base before picking up the next passenger, no waiting at a "strategically" good position etc.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kuschku on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:17PM (#11145672)
I never claimed they could operate as Taxi, but in the way they planned to operated.

And a Personenbeförderungsschein is the only thing you need for that.

In some cities even the only differences between a hired service like Uber or a Taxi is that Uber may NOT use Taxi-only spaces, and may only pick up people who have arranged the journey before pickup.

Which is exactly what uber wants.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:30PM (#11146060)
Also, to say, if the city allowed chauffeurs before Uber arrived, and decides that Uber should be regulated as a taxi, they must force those existing businesses to register as well, or create special onerous laws to make a distinction.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by germanier on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:15PM (#11146255)
Firstly, the drivers should get a license to drive people around for profit (Personenbeförderungsschein). Every chauffeur has that.

Secondly, under current regulations unless you are a taxi you need to return to a designated premise after every trip. Every chauffeur needs to do that as well.

There is already a meaningful distinction in the law. The second restriction might be a bit harsh, but often Uber isn't even abiding by the first which is a pretty basic requirement.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:05PM (#11147612)
Well, the second regulation would definitely disallow things like Uber. The first regulation is quite reasonable, but I don't see why it is Uber's responsibility to ensure compliance when all of its drivers are independent contractors. At some point, if people lie about their insurance status, they should be found out and punished.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kuschku on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:42AM (#11149894)
Because, as courts in Germany and California have ruled, Uber drivers are not independent contractors.

Scheinselbstständigkeit is what Uber is doing, and it means Uber is responsible for the insurance.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by tn13 on Monday February 22, 2016 @03:07AM (#11149307)
WTF is a "responsible taxi service" ? Is the bar to being 'responsible' getting some government license ?

Exposing itself to "license" means exposing themselves to arbitrary government control and has nothing to do with being responsible. On the contrary focusing on making good profits is the best way to help both drivers and passengers without compromising interests of both.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kuschku on Monday February 22, 2016 @05:44AM (#11149901)
Because the government license insures the taxi has insurance, the driver is trained, every part of the taxi is separately checked every year, the taxi is clean, the driver can't overcharge, the profits from the taxi driver stay in the region and are not transferred to New York.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by kafkaesq on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:14PM (#11152395)
Exposing itself to "license" means exposing themselves to arbitrary government control and has nothing to do with being responsible.

You know, "arbitrary" things like insurance, anti-discrimination provisions, etc.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by wildmusings on Sunday February 21, 2016 @03:20PM (#11146280)
>The problem is their morals when it comes to how they treat their drivers.

I'll bite. What's immoral about how they treat their drivers? Their drivers choose their hours, choose which rides to take, and can work for as many uber-like services at the same time as they want.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:24PM (#11146612)
And will will answer you.

You hire people as self-employed but rip them of the opportunity to work as self-employed by.

1) Not allowing them to set their own fees 2) Not allowing them to hire people to drive for them 3) Discouraging tips 4) Deciding what types of cars they can drive in.

All things you would normally do to people who where hired because they would trade that potential upside of being selv-employed by for instance having access to ex. healthcare and vacation.

In other words. Uber takes away all the good things about being self-employed and replace them with restrictions that would normally only apply for someone who was employed. While at the same time not giving them access to those things that are actually advantageous about being employed.

Uber isn't a technology disrupter it's a legislation disrupter.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:10PM (#11147629)
To be fair, taxi drivers are also self employed, usually don't get health insurance or vacation either. Uber isn't "changing that game" in the private car-for-hire business.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:41AM (#11152088)
But they can hire people to work for themselves and build a business around that. Uber drivers can't. This is one of the core principles of being able to run an actual company. the ability to delegate work out to others.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Sunday February 21, 2016 @06:50PM (#11147320)
That doesn't seem to address the parent's point that no one is forcing them to take the job, and they find it to be better than their other options. How, then, would banning them help?

Is Uber responsible for the generally poor opportunities in the economy? Does their offering of these positions disrupt a solution to some public goods problem? (A good heuristic for whether one should care about a kind of lawbreaking, btw.)

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by iamdave on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:08PM (#11148384)
That doesn't seem to address the parent's point that no one is forcing them to take the job,

No one forces self-employed independent contractor tradesmen to become self-employed independent contractor tradesmen, and yet when one comes to your house to fix your plumbing or electrical work-there are still requisites under the law that they're entitled to.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:08AM (#11148611)
That's simply repeating the situation, not addressing the criticism. The same argument applies there as well.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by iamdave on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:50AM (#11148801)
The criticism makes no sense...just because one isn't "forced" to work doesn't mean protections from employer abuse or misconduct suddenly don't matter if someone decides to take the work.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Monday February 22, 2016 @01:16AM (#11148918)
But this isn't some random abuse with "take it or leave it". It's something they knew about all along and went into with open eyes. What doesn't make sense is this dogmatic insistence that no right should be waivable under any circumstance. In what sense is it actually misconduct. As I said initially (and which I didn't see a response to), if you legitimately believe a case of lawbreaking is harmful and the kind of thing we should care about, that should translate into "here is a public goods problem whose solution that disrupts". So how does this lawbreaking do that? And why not just spell that out the first time around?

The opposite position is like saying, "you are the rightful owner of that apple, therefore you can't trade it for something better even if you want to, because that would be abusive of your rights".

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:48AM (#11152150)
I have already explained the issue. Uber takes the best of having them self-employed and give them all the worst things about being employed as working conditions.

The Uber driver have absolutely no way of building a business or expanding it. No way of making more money. No way of hiring people. No control over which car to use and so on.

This is not the conditions someone who is self-employed work under.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:01PM (#11152276)
And that's still not responding to the criticism: even with those downsides, it's better than all the government-endorsed options. Whose fault is that, and what does arresting them accomplish with respect to their welfare? (Which I believe was your motivation for objecting to the practice.)

Edit: I'm not trying to be snarky; it's just that this issue comes up a lot, and I always look for such an explanation and yet never get it. Hence why someone came up with the "Copenhagen interpretation of ethics" argument. If you could actually fill this gap in my understanding, I would gladly help spread the insight to those like me who don't see consistent internal logic behind it.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by iamdave on Monday February 22, 2016 @03:23PM (#11153978)
So I just want to make sure I understand the criticism, as I feel we may have inadvertently drifted here:

Someone who knows the risks (physical, emotional, mental what have you and furthermore etcetera) of a job shouldn't be afforded certain protections from the government to minimize those risks, if they take a job that opens them up to the possibility of said risks?

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Monday February 22, 2016 @04:00PM (#11154247)
They should be afforded those protections, but they should be waivable by informed parties (barring some dynamic that would explain why this is a bad idea and which no one in the thread has articulated). Is there a reason to believe the drivers aren't informed of such tradeoffs or did not become informed very soon?
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by wildmusings on Monday February 22, 2016 @12:11PM (#11152370)
>The Uber driver have absolutely no way of building a business or expanding it. No way of making more money. No way of hiring people. No control over which car to use and so on.

They have strictly as much or more opportunity to do all of these things than if Uber didn't exist. Driving for Uber doesn't stop you from doing other drive-for-hire work. And because Uber exists, they can at least make some money when they aren't getting any customers of their own.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:45AM (#11152124)
I refuse to buy the premise of "no one is forcing them"

will strictly true it's also completely ignoring the reality that we people have needs that forces us to make choices, often choices we don't want to make but have few other choices.

It does address the parents point because if you don't see that I am not sure anything I say will change that.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by SilasX on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:58AM (#11152257)
You don't understand the logic of "this is a better option than all others and removing it doesn't help unless that's part of some [effective] collective action strategy to a problem"? If so, that's a strike against your model of the problem, not in favor of your criticism.

If you could articulate the collective action problem that such a ban would resolve, that would improve my worldmodel to the point of seeing what insight you're offering here and possibly agreeing. If you can't, then maybe your position doesn't correspond to a better worldmodel than one that I and the original parent hold.

Also, it's not so much that "no one" forces them to work, but that Uber doesn't. My need for satiation "forces" me to buy food, but I hope that doesn't, in your mind, justify a crackdown on all food sellers.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by cultureulterior on Monday February 22, 2016 @11:27AM (#11151959)
Tipping is a terrible societal habit, though. Pay them a living wage, fine. Just don't force people to waste time on a another, entirely separate payment.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by newman314 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @12:49PM (#11145509)
AND your data...
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:01PM (#11145581)
For what?
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by brbsix on Sunday February 21, 2016 @02:05PM (#11145916)
There's been some legitimate concern over what Uber does with the customer data it collects. Spying on and blackmailing journalists and whatnot. Who knows what else. They don't exactly have a "do no evil" motto.

http://www.whosdrivingyou.org/blog/ubers-deleted-rides-of-gl...

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @04:30PM (#11146650)
Which is why i said form the point of view of the drivers :)

I.e. the claims that because uber isn't doing things by the book it's somehow less safe than using regulated taxi's.

This is obviously false since the logging of the drivers and the passengers probably make it one of the most transparent safety protocols out there.

Most studies show that some of the biggest detergents against crimes is the risk of being detected.

So in other words. Uber is as safe for the passgener, if not safer, than any other taxi company out there.

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by newman314 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @08:07PM (#11147619)
AFAIK, Uber holds on to your trip data forever. There is not an option to say expire my trip history after x months.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by venomsnake on Sunday February 21, 2016 @11:56AM (#11145213)
Lets just say that after the sexual assault allegations both in US and India - responsible is in the eyes of the beholder.
Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by z92 on Sunday February 21, 2016 @12:00PM (#11145248)
Would like to add that these type of things happen in legal taxi services too. One can't prevent it.

Therefore the question is: How easy is it to track the offender, in both the services?

Re:Uber ruled illegal in Taiwan by ThomPete on Sunday February 21, 2016 @01:02PM (#11145587)
This happens with all kinds of taxi services not just ubers. But the big difference is that with uber you know who did it.