Having said that, Lands' End's drop in quality came during the same period that so much manufacturing was moving to Asia. I suspect that whatever corners Lands' End started cutting were the same corners that most of the other brands it competes with were cutting as well. And this may well have happened with or without the Sears acquisition.
But, to your broader point, especially if you're going to use low cost overseas manufacturing extensively keeping up quality implies a lot of hands-on monitoring and working with the manufacturers closely.
[0] http://www.patagonia.com/ca/product/let-my-people-go-surfing...
Edit: linked
I've not read the book yet, so it's not a rhetorical question. Living in the Pacific Northwest Patagonia and their company story and ethos are known to just about everyone who's ventured into the outdoors.
I've been finding screaming deals on ebay for clothes, so have been "NEW without tags" Tommy Bahama stuff. Even the gently used stuff is such good quality that you can barely tell it's been worn at all. So for things like cashmere sweaters it's great value. For example I got a $250 mock sweater for $40 and it's awesome. I get more compliments on that thing than anything else I wear to the office. Kind of like this one but in more of a purple bordeaux color:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/NWT-TOMMY-BAHAMA-Half-1-2-Zip-Sweate...
Anyway, imo the quality of both LL Bean stuff and Tommy Bahama blow J Crew etc all out of the water. They're like how Lands End used to be, before Sears ruined them.
It is not to say that nobody can be successful in brick and mortar retail, but Buffet more or less rode the Great Moderation. Not to take away from him, but after equities stopped rotting around ... 1985ish, things were sort of on autopilot. The Dow broke 2000 in 1986...
I think a similar effect could be claimed for being called the next Buffett. There is a long list of investor casualties after such a comparison (including the ones you mentioned).
Most recently I'm thinking of Bill Ackman, who was on the cover of Fortune last year with the title "Baby Buffett"... right before a painful 20% tumble.
It's like being the MVP of the NBA. The competition is fierce, and you are playing a zero-sum game, hence generating returns greater than available by putting money 'in the market' is hard and (sometimes) ephemeral.
The Berkshire business was a New England textile company that kept suffering as the textile industry was slowly but surely being moved out of the United States. Buffet has said many times that buying Berkshire was a mistake.
Two things: 1) People still act from emotion even when there's a hell of a lot of money at stake and 2) that kindly grandpa thing that Warren Buffett has going is an act.
I think it probably influenced his thinking, and putting more emphasis on known brands. Berkshire Hathaway made suit linings, a commodity, and were not a known consumer brand. After BH, he made investments in See's Candies, Coca Cola, national or global name brands that have a hold on their market - a "moat" as he calls it.
He started off in that direction, buying Lands End and making a bid for Restoration Hardware. I recall an interview or press release laying out a vision for Sears as a "store of stores" that showcased iconic American brands - Kenmore, Diehard, Lands End, etc.
Somewhere along the line that dream died, and the cash flow was used mostly just to repurchase shares while letting the stores Languish. A bunch of concepts were tried in a handful of stores, but none promised an attractive ROI so they were dropped. Bruce Berkowitz is another investor that used to get compared to Buffett an awful lot, and tied his fate to the Sears project. He's still buying more shares and saying he sees value there.
I don't really have a point other to say that investing is hard, and identifying talented value investors who will outperform in the future is even harder. Whether this was a dumb idea all along, or a poorly executed good idea is tough to say.