Unlike many other consumer products you really don't have any idea what you're buying until after you've bought it. Making an incorrect or misled choice in health insurance is sufficient -- literally -- to completely ruin your life financially in a matter of hours, or cause unnecessary death via untreated illness.
If you want to claim that you can read a health insurance policy binder and understand it be my guest. I am a frequent writer and editor of technical literature and capable of writing code and I have a pilots license and I find health insurance policies almost incomprehensible.
We make sure that you don't get a bad haircut by requiring licenses for barbers. You can't fix my sink or chimney without licensing. We require licensing and testing to act on someone's behalf in the legal system, and in nearly all sales of securities, and of financial products, of which insurance is one mind you.
If Zenefits wanted to make an in-public argument that these rules are not necessary they were free to do so. I would have disagreed, and I'm sure others would have shared my opinion. Maybe they could have won the argument.
They didn't do that. They aren't righteous crusaders passionate about consumer choices and regulatory issues, they're opportunistic business people who broke the law and committed fraud instead of following the rules or working to change them.
Zenefits employees did pass the exam, and they possess the knowledge you believe is necessary. It's just that the law requires 52 hours of clicking before you are even permitted to take the exam. Why do you think this is a good law?
The requirement isn't "clicking next for 52 hours" it's spending that amount of time studying an online course. You're required to actually pay attention for 52 hours and then certify that you did.
For another example, the requirement inherent in a multiple choice exam isn't a matter of "filling out a semi random sequence of the letters A, B, C, and D" it's knowing the answers to the test.
The filling out the letters is a signal that you know. Signals aren't perfect, in that example if you don't know but copied answers from someone else that's cheating and the signal would be unreliable then, and you've subverted the actual intended requirement.
The requirement in this case is spending about a week of your life actually studying this material and the clicking of the next button as well is a signal that you did it.
Don't confuse the means with ends. You could have argued that the amount of hours spent studying the material is also a useless metric. But that's a more nuanced argument that you haven't made, and one that has defensible positions on both sides.
Clearly clicking next isn't a meaningful requirement, but so what, it's not actually the requirement. Spending time studying is, and they cheated and lied about it.
But lets take your claim as a premise; why is it important that a person spend time learning? Suppose two people know the material equally well, but one of them learned it faster than the other. Why is that a good regulation? How does it benefit consumers to make it illegal to learn things fast?
I know a former algebraic geometer (lots of category theory) who learned Haskell very rapidly. Would it benefit consumers of his services to pass a law saying he needs to learn Haskell at a slower rate comparable to a RoR hipster without a math PhD?
https://govt.westlaw.com/calregs/Document/ID813F6A0622011E4A...
> why is it important that a person spend time learning? Suppose two people know the material equally well, but one of them learned it faster than the other. Why is that a good regulation? How does it benefit consumers to make it illegal to learn things fast?
I don't know. But I do know that basically every educational institution requires some level of engagement measured in time. You can't just pass tests to get an undergrad degree or a PhD either. The requirement to spend actual time is hardly cruel and unusual.
I also know that the requirements were clear enough to be known to Zenefits and they willfully evaded them.
What is the difference between a Harvard graduate in Economics and someone who attended and completed all the requirements for an Econ degree but was short one art elective class and never got a degree? Should he just fudge his job applications since the art class isn't important?
What's the difference between someone assigned 100 hours of court ordered community service who did it and someone who went back to court with forged paperwork saying they did it?
In all the examples, and Zenefits as well, the difference is that the person is committing fraud, is lying, and is not ethical.
Cheating on requirements isn't the same as arguing to change the rules, regardless of how confused you continue to pretend to be about it.
Yes you can. Almost every school has a procedure for taking a test or convincing a professor that you have the knowledge the class provides. You still pay the cost of the course, but do not actually attend it.
Getting my degree many, many years after entering the field, I skipped a huge swath of undergrad classes this way. Stuff like non-computer related classes was all that I needed to do 'in person'.
In other words, I skipped 'pressing buttons' for a large chunk of time due to fact that I knew the material and could prove it.
The main difference to the above being that the school recognized that it was possible for a student to understand the core material completely without taking the class, and the above rules do not admit that possibility.
So would you say you had experiential learning in the subject matter of the classes you were being allowed to skip after demonstrating both evidence of this experiential learning and the attendant competency?
Testing out of a course due to earned knowledge is different from passing a multiple choice exam with Cliff Notes awareness of the material.
Some of the classes did just have multiple choice tests that would have been easy enough to 'Cliff'. Though it's not really relevant to larger discourse.
That still doesn't change the facts of the original situation. The test is the determining factor of whether or not they 'completed' the course. Indeed, someone who 'Cliff'ed the notes, and passed the test, and watched Netflix on a second screen while pushing all of the right buttons would still be accepted. Which is the ultimate failure here. Either the time limit is necessary and can't be skipped (due to the physical limitations of some inherent process), or the time limit is artificial and the actual possession of knowledge is sufficient.
Who is served by putting an artificial time limit in place that does not actually prove knowledge of the material?
heating on requirements isn't the same as arguing to change the rules, regardless of how confused you continue to pretend to be about it.
Try to pay attention. Above you said that you'd argue against changing the rules. I asked you to justify that, and it sounds like you don't have much of an argument beyond "well universities do it too".
Please don't be uncivil. This comment would be fine without that bit.
No it doesn't, and by saying that, you're telling the rest of us that you don't actually understand what's going on, but you want to seem "edgy", and "disruptive".
A policeman can be strongest, but a sexual harassment case will disqualify him.
When I see a broker license, I know I'm dealing with a knowledgeable, honestly practising professional. Can't say that about Zenefits anymore. They must lose license.
EDIT: You can give credit to any kind of cheating with the reasoning you gave. Why is SAT I verbal section important in a student becoming an electrical engineer? He should be allowed to cheat, according to you?
I think a person should be allowed to take the SAT without actually being obligated to click "next" for 52 hours. If they don't know the material they'll get a low score.
Unless you're asking every person to recite the whole textbook, the only way to be sure is an attendance policy.
What exactly do you believe that clicking "next" repeatedly tells you about a person's behavior?
(Again, remember that the question is why 52 hours of clicking is a good law. If a person didn't click for 52 hours when the law didn't require it, that would not be evidence that they are willing to violate unjust laws.)
It isn't. It's 52 hours of study, everyone is latching onto "clicking" to make a disingenuous point. Almost every exam you take is intended as an assessment of your knowledge, not "are they able to recite answers to 10 questions in a 2 hour period inside an exam room"
the state wants you to make sure you read everything and that you can answer questions about it. It doesn't seem like a stretch at all, especially considering people run their livelihoods based on that license. It's a license to conduct a proper practice and a career.
Besides, the "redundant" requirements just caught a person trying to cheat -- Zenefits. So you cannot even claim they aren't working.
Certification also amounts to delegating due diligence. Licensure goes a step beyond that by actually forbidding voluntary exchange in certain cases. You are not just delegating due diligence, you are delegating your freedom to make your own choices.
> or to figure out if a "certification" actually means anything or is some bullshit anyone can hand out.
You still have to do legwork to figure out if a license is just bullshit. Because licensure is almost always controlled by members of the given occupation, there is a tendency for more and more bullshit to creep into licensure requirements over time, stuff that has nothing to do with actual competence, because it creates a barrier of entry into the occupation. Friedman has countless examples in his book.
It's also the signal to customer that the guy they are dealing with did not simply pass a test, but is actively practising the profession in a manner he is supposed to.
If this is your point, sorry but your argument doesn't follow. There's nothing against the certification authority requiring 52 hours of training. And there's nothing against Zenefits cheating if they believe a certified expert is better than an uncertified one (and this is the argument underlying Mr. Friedman discussion).
Certification vs. Licensing is a complex discussion topic, I tend to prefer certifications over licensing, but this is definitively not the point with Zenefits.
On the other hand, Zenefits might not have bothered with certification since it wouldn't have been legally required, or the requirements might have been less silly if certified professionals had to compete with non-certified.
You have to prove this. Also, you have to consider a problem in the way the market works. Insurance brokers are paid by insurance companies through referral fees, not by the final user. If you know something about economy, this should ring a bell: "moral hazard." Or we change the way the market works, but there could be unintended consequences or external regulation is required to ensure the market is fair.
You can outlaw certifications over a year old, but you cannot take the earned certification away. Besides, you cannot take them away mid-year for malpractice. Once you're certified to pass something, you have passed it. You can't go back in time and unpass it.
The main reason I oppose licensure is that producer groups (e.g. insurance brokers) will exert political pressure to add more and more irrelevant requirements in order to obtain a license. Take barbering for example: in many states in order to become a barber, you need to complete hundreds of hours of theoretical instruction in the anatomy of the face and head, the elementary chemistry of sterilization, the histology of hair, etc. Just to cut hair!
In addition, the professional activities that require a license tend to gradually expand due to political pressure. Doctors spend a lot of time doing things that could be performed by a skilled technician, and the result is unnecessarily expensive medical care, and some people not having access to care at all.
Wasn't there just recently an article here complaining about the quality of academic accreditation, or in other words about how those certifications were simply bogus?
Let's say you buy insurance. Let's say that after paying premiums for a couple of years, you come down with some dread disease. You contact the insurance company to tell them that you need $737,248.44 or you'll die from your dread disease. They say, "LOL. We don't do that. So sorry." You visit your broker and he says, "I didn't know! I just printed up a certificate and hanged (hung?) out my shingle. Guess you're out of luck."
Lawsuit time? Hm. I suppose your estate would still have standing to sue. Unless we've got tort reform as well as licensing reform. Anyway, the neat part is there isn't any consequences to the broker. Sure, you could hit him with fraudulently claiming to be certified, but there are all these other people doing the same sort of thing without any certification at all, so it doesn't sound like a major crime. And of course, we're talking about employment benefits, so you aren't the one picking the broker, your employer is...
Here's the question: How would any approach to avoiding that situation not involve something that strongly resembles licensing? (Here's a hint: what is the difference between pulling someone's certification and pulling their license?)
"The only justification for licensure over certification is a paternalistic one: consumers are simply too ignorant to choose their own insurance brokers, even if some are certified and some are not. As Milton Friedman said in Chap 9 of Capitalism and Freedom, this argument "amounts to saying that we in our capacity as voters must protect ourselves in our capacity as consumers against our own ignorance.""
Actually, that's a pretty fair description of what is going, how it's supposed to work, and why. Here's another quote for you: "The doorstep to the temple of wisdom is a knowledge of our own ignorance," which may or may not be Benjamin Franklin. But I suppose the idea that one may not know something, and that the something might be important, is unappealing to many people. Stop and ponder for a moment how much trust you put into the people around you on a daily basis. And most of them don't even have an incentive and opportunity to screw you.
Now, about the 50-odd hour spree of next-clicking...
History is path dependent, and any optimal solution to a problem (or apparently optimal, on theoretical economic grounds) may not be reachable given the previous states of the system.
Have to click next for 50-hours? Probably because the real, physical class takes 50-ish hours to cover the material.
Why have a class at all? Why not just have an exam? (Anyone here familiar with the various industrial certification exams around? Trust 'em?) The exam is also likely pretty simple, otherwise you have no brokers and the insurance sales system becomes very expensive. (Has anyone reading this passed the bar?) So consider it from a liability standpoint: with a class and an exam, a "reasonable person" can be "assured" that the broker has been exposed to the appropriate information and has understood it adequately.
This isn't to say that Zenefits hasn't made a huge misstep for seemingly little benefit (bypassing a 56 hour course?), but I wish there was some discussion of the absurdity of the law that was broken alongside the bashing of Zenefits for breaking it.