Clicking "next" for 52 hours is clearly absurd, though I would take it farther and argue that no exam should be required to be an insurance broker at all.
I can see the benefits of requiring competency before being allowed to sell insurance to the public. Insurance is important. It's what you rely on to defray potentially millions of dollars in damages (up to and including the death of yourself or your spouse) when something goes horribly wrong. And it would be a huge travesty if you didn't actually have the coverage you thought you did because the unlicensed, untrained, and inexperienced agent that sold you your policy didn't correctly explain it, or didn't understand your needs.
1. Ethically, I think that if you choose to do business with an untrained, inexperienced broker, then the consequences are on you. In fact, there may be legitimate reasons to do so, which brings us to point 2.
2. If the members of a profession control entry into that profession, which is always the case with occupational licensure, then those members have a strong economic incentive to construct barriers to entry. More and more irrelevant requirements will be added over time. Certification protects against this tendency while still providing all of the supposed informational benefits of licensure. If certification requirements become too crazy and irrelevant, the price differential between certified and uncertified professionals will increase, and consumers will start to use uncertified professionals instead, forcing the certification requirements back down to sanity.
2. You know this licensing system did not come out of thin air? Got an example of a working, critical certification system?
2. My understanding is that there are few government-mandated certification systems because they tend to gradually evolve towards licensure, due to political pressure from producer groups. There are many private certification systems that work quite well. The Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval is a private certification system for household products. Stores such as Target certify the value of the products that they sell in order to guard their own reputation. I'm hesitant to mention this because I don't know much about it, but I believe accountants are also certified rather than licensed.
This has been proven false time and time again. I know libertarian types like to pretend it, but you are not an island. You do not exist in a vacuum.
In all seriousness, I obviously don't think a test should be required to buy insurance, but I do think that government putting a little more effort into educating the populace on financial topics (including insurance) would do much more good than having brokers jump through silly hoops like the one under discussion here.
So given that it will never happen that everyone is an expert at everything, we need alternate systems to protect people. Like licensing and regulation. All you've got is an impossible pipe dream.
It's much better to train the specialized provider, because then each head has only to fit the knowledge required for their own profession. This is feasible and with much less effort. Slightly worse result, but there's no free lunch.
Actually, I'd be inclined to "citation needed" that. Brains are curious things.
Out of my personal bumhole, I'd suggest that if you want to ensure retention, you're far better off retesting frequently. A big-but-not-quite-as-big certification test up front, and monthly recertification tests that are much smaller, but still cover the entire space fairly well, strikes me as much more likely to ensure retention. One big test is too amenable to cramming, which I believe is scientifically demonstrated to work great for passing tests but causes the knowledge to disappear a few days later. Then, scrap the hour requirements entirely.
It sounds like you are saying that California regulators made a disastrously bad test that doesn't measure knowledge well, so therefore we should require people to click "next" for 52 hours in the hopes that knowledge enters their skulls even if we can't measure it?
The law they broke was selling insurance without the use of unlicensed brokers.
Sounds like a job for Homer's typing bird!
I suppose one way to estimate how onerous this requirement is (I agree that to the extent it is arbitrary that it is dumb) would be to compare how much compensation the insurance license makes available to how much compensation spending the equivalent time learning a skill like welding makes available.
(I think most people wouldn't be very good at welding after 50 hours of training and practice)
The social cost is 52 hours of productive output from moderately skilled employees. (Or moderately less - if learning the material takes 20 hours, then the waste is 32 hours assuming people can simultaneously learn the material and click.)
The right thing to do is simply make people take the test, and if the test isn't accurately measuring people's insurance selling ability, fix the test.
Of course a problem with bad regulation is that can have an enormous aggregate effect, but in this case I think we can reasonably assume that Zenefits didn't need to encourage employees to avoid this regulation in order to grow itself rapidly.
Again, note that we are discussing spending 52 hours clicking through a powerpoint before you are allowed to take the test to get the license.
How do you know that they passed the exam? They told you?
"Again, note that we are discussing spending 52 hours clicking through a powerpoint before you are allowed to take the test to get the license."
No, we are not.
The Macro functioned to keep a person logged into the course and prevented the person from being logged out for inactivity. The Macro did not advance through the required material or quizzes in the education course — the Macro only kept the person logged in. The Macro only pertained to the prelicensing education course and did not affect the broker exam taken later.
If you have even accusations of some other activity (let alone evidence of it), go ahead and post it.
Um, 52 hours * 50 states (insurance regulations are per state, normally) = 2500 hours. More than the number of work hours in a year.
That's a bit more than "modest".
The whole point of Zenefits was to consolidate the point of contact and thus reduce the expense through consolidation. That doesn't really work if you need a separate person per state.
Normally, I find myself staunchly on the opposite side of the argument from Zenefits; I think that Uber and AirBnB are being patently abusive in their actions. I find the fact that Zenefits was threatening the insurance industry, who are noted for being a huge bunch of assholes, far more palatable.
It goes to show that my views aren't as immutable or as charitable as I thought.
> (I think most people wouldn't be very good at welding after 50 hours of training and practice)
You'd be surprised. That's the right range for basic functionality for a lot of things. Even a Language 101 class is only about 100 hours, and you can normally ask for the bathroom and find basic directions afterward.
You'd be surprised.
Would I? I was talking about employability, not avoiding wet pants during a 2 week visit. I think if it were much worth employing someone to weld after 50 hours of training, we wouldn't have industry screaming about welders (maybe it's regulation requiring industry to only hire well trained welders?).
Separate issue.
Yeah, the industry is screaming for welders, machinists, etc. Yet, the salaries aren't going up, hmmmmmmmm.
Perhaps they don't actually have a shortage of welders, but, instead, have a shortage of cheap welders.
I have yet to see any companies subsidizing the education of these folks. That's the true sign that they're really serious about it.
This is true.
I don't see the insurance training as how-to-do-one's-job, however. More akin to how not to do it. Financial health and safety training.
A welder receiving 50+ hours in health and safety at the start of their career, among other trainings, seems reasonable. As does 1 hour health and safety training and sharing each week with the team. An equivalent requirement in finance does not seem unreasonable, given the damage that can be done by being unaware of (once you know them) basic concepts in mis-selling, fraud, money laundering and a long list of identifying black-market financing organisations.
The specific law that Zenefits violated was a law insisting that before selling insurance, your employees need to sit at a computer and click "next" for 52 hours. Once they've clicked "next" sufficiently many times, only then are they permitted to take the exam to determine whether they have enough knowledge to sell insurance.
Shouldn't this scandal also highlight the perils of a regulatory state?