> because payments toward ownership build capital
Money invested outside of property also builds capital. Money not spent on mortgage interest builds capital. Money not spent on maintenance builds capital. Money not spent on property transaction-related costs (surveys, legal fees, Stamp Duty in the UK) builds capital. Owning property when a major housing bubble collapses burns capital faster than your wildest dreams. (Not everywhere has a housing bubble at the moment, but an awful lot of places do.)
Obviously you can argue with a lot of that, but the picture is nowhere near as clear-cut as you're making out.
If you rent, you're likely paying all those additional fees in addition to a share of the mortgage for the owner. Property owners aren't charities and are under no obligation to take on those costs when they can get somebody else to take them on for them.
It really is as clear cut as that.
Sentences like that are a huge red flag. It cannot be as clear cut as that. You can't ignore price levels when making that kind of blanket statement. Think of it as a reductio ad absurdum: if it's always better to buy, then it's still better to buy when buying costs 25x the annual rent, right? 50x? 100x? 1000x? 1000000x? People really do fall into thinking like this; it's exactly how bubbles happen.
Buying my current place would probably cost about the equivalent of 35 years' rent (before taking into account opportunity costs etc). That's longer than I expect to live. I could just about swing it, but my savings would be gone, I'd suddenly be stressed about losing my job etc. You might think it's still clear-cut, but it's far from obvious to me. If prices weren't completely ridiculous, sure, I'd probably go for it. But they are, and that matters.
Considering buying costs at multiples of renting basically doesn't occur in reality, so it's not worth spending brain-cycles thinking about it.
> I'd suddenly be stressed about losing my job etc.
Is your rent free? Job stress affects both kinds of home tenancy.
> That's longer than I expect to live.
Well, I hope that's not true. I'm dipping into the wine now, so I'll toast to your health and long life!
Do you think everyone on HN is 16-22 years old?
Average life expectancy in most of the world is >70. So somebody expecting to die in the next 35 years would have to be over 35, at which age I'd hope they would have learned about basic economics and arithmetic.
This isn't a very difficult discussion since it can be pretty easily rooted in readily available information and pretty basic calculations. There's even on-line calculators that will do the hard work of adding numbers together if people can't be bothered.
The hard realities that lots of people can't seem to get into their noggins are pretty simple:
- housing costs money, are you recouping that money in some way? owners do eventually, renters do not. Period.
- property owners don't run charities, all those things house owners pay for explicitly, renters pay for implicitly, they just don't get the itemized list
- renting a bedroom out of some guy's basement is not the equivalent of buying (or renting) a house, if you think they are, you've entered into a conversation you cannot possibly understand and you need to back slowly away
- owners get many more options to sway the cost of housing into their favor than do renters, in surprisingly common cases, owners can even make money off of their property
- Buy $1.2M - Rent $1800 a month. By law rent can only be increased a limited amount every year (and it's never been increased for me).
The landlord is getting 1.8% return on his money before his maintenance expenses, taxes, etc.
The only scenario this makes any sense is interest rates remain at 0% for the next 30 years. Even in this case it's not clear that house prices can keep appreciating at the same rate. Unless we go negative rates.
If I have 1.2M in cash why would I buy this house instead of renting? I'm taking a big risk with a lot of money. It's true that over the last 10-20 years people who have taken this bet came usually ahead (except in some parts of the US) but it's still a huge risk.
- London yields 2-5% https://www.portico.com/yields - No such rent capping law in London, it's generally expected that rents will increase every year and there's plenty of demand to cover it.
Clearly, people are making the decision to buy the house.
An income from investments of $60,000 a year isn't enough to live like a king, but it's certainly enough to live like a yeoman, even after taxes. If you buy an expensive house with that money, instead of buying an income stream with it, the best you can hope for is to live like a wage-slave.
It has to be an absolutely bizarre market for a renter to find an equivalent place to rent, then have enough money left over that they can invest in some mythical financial instrument that will earn them all that rent back plus whatever valuation a property owner is earning while their property appreciates in value.
At the end of the mortgage the owner now only has to pay any applicable taxes and the cost of living is more or less "free" (minus maintenance). A renter will rent forever.
A renter can rent a small room as part of a larger house, but you can't buy a small room.[1]
My personal investment fund has had 50% per year gains since 2012[2].
Perhaps we do live in a bizarre market because I've done exactly what you described.
[1] Do that here. https://flatmates.com.au
[2]
2012-2014 in tech. TSLA & SCTY contributed the bulk of my gains.
2014- in Australian gold miners, whose index has doubled in a year. https://www.google.com/finance?cid=16106836
Sure you can. Housing units come in all shapes and sizes. In the U.S. at least small places are usually sold as condos and can be as small as any efficiency.
> Perhaps we do live in a bizarre market because I've done exactly what you described.
No, you rented a smaller place than a house, then invested the difference.
I said "equivalent place to rent".
I'll say it one more time and maybe this time your reading comprehension will kick in, unless you live in an absolutely bizarre market, where rents are vastly under mortgage costs, and you can rent an equivalent property (same size, same number of bedrooms, etc.) at those vastly lower rates, you'll never have enough money extra that you would have spent on property ownership that will earn back the money you've set to fire by renting.
For example (since you seem to need a specific one):
A house that costs $600,000 needs slightly more than $2,600/mo to service a 30 year loan. Unless you live in an absolutely bizarre housing market, you will not be able to rent the same house for an amount that is significantly less than that.
But, let's suppose you cut a deal and rent it for $2,000/mo. That leaves you with $600/mo. You need to turn that $600 into $2,000 every month to make up for the loss on rent. I laugh at your 50% return, because now you're only $1,100 a month in the hole each month.
Suppose your landlord is a real cool guy and let's you keep the same $2,000/mo for 30 years (unlikely, but let's suppose he's an idiot), You've now burned about $400,000 and still have to figure out how to cover housing costs until you die.
Your smart friend on the other hand, after 30 years, has $600,000+ in property, no more major housing costs for the rest of his life and spent less than you to get there.
Suppose your friend hits it big, he can refinance after a few years, lower his mortgage payment below your rent (which has probably gone up by then), and can now make 50% gains on his investments and he's still buying his property.
Let's say he hits it really big on his investments, he can just pay the house off early, not pay the balance of the interest, his housing costs go to near zero and now he can invest all the money he'd spend on housing on your 50% return investment plan.
If he's real smart, he'll just buy a second house, and rent it out to you since you'll just pay most of that mortgage for him.
After 30 years he now owns two houses, has made a fortune on your investment plan and you're still paying what are probably much higher housing costs for renters.
Maybe you're a real clever guy and after 30 years you've somehow saved up enough to just buy a house outright and skip all the other costs (minus maintenance), maybe you but the house your renting from your friend. Great, you now own property, and your friend still has his house and the money you paid to buy his second house (now valued well in excess of the $600,000 he paid for it) plus the fortune he earned investing in your stock tips, plus you'll probably have paid him back for all the interest he ever paid on the house via your purchase price.
(okay okay, I'm handwaiving away interest and taxes and such, but the math doesn't change all that much once considered and most competent landlords simply pass along those costs to their tenants).
You've also got hundreds a month in day to day maintenance and upkeep, not to mention the taxes and insurance and hoa fees. Oh, and a point of PMI unless you've got 120k in your back pocket for a 20% down payment.
Don't forget 6% commission, closing costs and other taxes on the sale.
Buying doesn't pencil out against renting when the rent is lower than a 30 year mortgage payment.
You seem to think that renters don't pay for that and owners operate a housing charity where they foot all the maintenance and other costs while renters just pay some kind of courtesy "I'm occupying your property" fee.
In many 30 year models, given a $500k home up for rent or purchase, the owner comes out somewhere between $1mil-$2mil ahead of the renter in terms of total asset ownership. After which the owner has only maintenance and taxes to pay for living while the renter continues to burn their money at higher and higher rental rates.
During the same 30 year period, the owner will have a diminishing cost of living while the renter will maintain around a steady cost (on average) meaning that not only will the owner come out wealthier than the renter, it will be easier for them to gain that wealth as per inflation.
Run the numbers on your scenario without handwaving and you'll show the homeowner taking a stark loss over the renter.
1% rule is a good place to start. That would estimate the rent would have to be 4400/mo minimum for that 600k property to cashflow. 2600/mo? no way.
Best calculator I've found (http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc...), given standard values like a 4% mortgage with a 20% downpayment and a 5% investment return rate, shows your scenario break even at best over 30 years -- hardly "large and unambigouous margins".
So now it's just your reasoning that's broken.
Here's the tl;dr - You need to pay for housing no matter what. Do you buy and rent out your property to somebody who'll pay your mortgage and costs for you? Or do you pay those costs for somebody else? Assuming an equal start, the property owner comes out somewhere around $1-2mil ahead of the renter over 30 years, and has housing in the end.
For those parameters, on a $500k property, you would need to find an equivalent property to rent for $1,491/mo for 30 years for renting to be "better". After which the renter has no housing and the owner has housing into perpetuity.
Good luck finding equivalent housing under $1,491/mo for that kind of property. In most areas in the U.S. at least, an equivalent property rents out for far higher than $1.5k/mo. In the areas I spot checked it was more in the range of $2.5-$3k/mo.
This assumes the owner only ever keeps this particular mortgage, never pays down the principal, never rents any of their rooms out or takes any other cost saving measures that aren't available to the renter.
Meanwhile percentage of income required to live in that property will stay the same for the renter while going down (relatively) for the owner.
If you fiddle with the down payment slider, you'll note that no matter what it's set to, it doesn't make all that much difference in the ratio. Set it to zero since you can finance 100% without too much fuss. Now this sets things as equal, there's no additional money to invest for the renter other than some imaginary delta they would save by renting at rates far below any available realistic market rental rate.
The renter still has to find property to rent about a thousand dollars less than the going rental rate in the market he's in, then still has to find housing at the end of the 30 year period.
If the owner decides to sell at some point along the way, they can convey the stored value of their property into their new property. The renter has simply burned all that money and will rent forever, at increasing nominal costs pegged to inflation or current market forces (whichever is greater).
So that I don't have to repeat myself again, here's an excellent write-up on the topic. Assuming an equal start, the property owner comes out somewhere around $1-2mil a head of the renter over 30 years, and has housing.
Your analysis link makes the same handwavey errors you did in your initial breakdown -- maintenance costs far too low, ignoring other costs involved with homeownership, etc. Interestingly enough, the link has a postscript where he redoes the analysis after people point out those errors with just a couple of those factored in (not all of them) and concludes that the renter would just about make his money back -- and that's with a rent payment about the same as the mortgage payment, not 25% less.
Even if rents are a bit lower now, that $2600 payment will stay approximately the same. In ten, fifteen years, those initially lower rents will have surpassed the $2600. Moreover, rent continues to be money set on fire. Less and less of that $2600 is burned on interest as time goes on.
Mortgages have ways to reduce the burn. You can choose accelerated payment plans with more frequent, smaller payments. There are ballooning options: pumping some money yearly into the mortgage to pay down principal.
Your figures are way off.
I started with $5000 in late-2012, and 3.5 years later, I have lower six figures investments. That's enough to buy a house in some parts of the country. So I don't get why I have to wait 30 years to buy a house if I wanted to.
I'm guessing you own property with a mortgage tying you down financially and are trying to justify why you did so.
I can quit today and live for 7 years doing absolutely nothing.
Can you?
> So I don't get why I have to wait 30 years to buy a house if I wanted to.
Why don't you? Then continue to just live in one bedroom of that house and rent the rest out to make more investment income? It doesn't make sense that you aren't? In fact it sounds pretty stupid that you aren't: in one swoop you secure infinite-term housing and you can get other people to cover all of your cost of living.
> I'm guessing you own property with a mortgage tying you down financially and are trying to justify why you did so.
No not really. There's a bit left, but I can finish paying it out from savings pretty easily. It's not worth it because my interest rate makes borrowing the money essentially "free".
>I can quit today and live for 7 years doing absolutely nothing. Can you?
Sure, I can liquidate my assets and pretty easily retire for the rest of my life to a few places my wife and I have scouted out in nice parts of the world. It wouldn't be lavish, but it would be fine.
If we're clever, we'll instead probably just rent our current house out to somebody like yourself and use the (rent - maintenance - taxes) to take out a mortgage on the same property we're thinking of buying outright for retirement and just live on the passive income forever. We'll thank the renters for funding our retirement with a gift basket full of cheap wine and summer sausages once a year. The mortgage on the place we're eyeing is not in the U.S. and current runs ~$600/mo. The rent on my house right now would run around $3k-3.5k/mo. In 30 years the rent on my house would run around $6k (keeping with expected inflation). The mortgage on the property we bought would still be $600. Feel free to do the math.
I and my wife expect to live another 40-50 years if that puts the value of property ownership into perspective for you.
There is almost no long-term scenario where renting wins over buying in the long-term. It would require a magical multi-decade convergence of oracle-like investment ability and absolutely bizarre and sustained housing market that has no historic precedent anywhere in the world.
Let's take two scenarios:
(A) In scenario A, you pay rent on an apartment for $5000 per month.
(B) In scenario B, you pay a fixed-rate mortgage on a residence in the amount of $5000 per month.
Therefore:
In scenario A, you are essentially taking $5k and setting it on fire once a month.
In scenario B, you are paying that money toward a share of the property's ownership.
So instead of setting it on fire, you're gaining $5k of equity in the property.