Girls rejected 30 year old me because he was an asshole.
35 year old me wasn't rejected.
25 Yo girl rejects guy because she thinks she can do better
30 Yo girl rejects guy because she thinks she can do better
35 Yo girl keeps guy because she thinks she is running out of time to form a family and have kids
You could have been the same idiot + asshole during the whole time. Reality, most likely, is a combination of both scenarios.
"There’s the risk, for example, that the first person you date really is your perfect partner... If you follow the rule, you’ll reject them anyway. And as you continue to date other people, no one will ever measure up to your first love, and you’ll end up rejecting everyone, and end up alone with your cats."
"Another -- probably more realistic -- option is that you start your life with a string of really terrible boyfriends or girlfriends that give you super low expectations about the potential suitors out there... The next person you date is marginally better than the failures you dated in your past, and you end up marrying him. But he’s still kind of a dud, and doesn't measure up to the great people you could have met in the future."
"So obviously there are ways this method can go wrong. But it still produces better results than any other formula you could follow, whether you’re considering 10 suitors or 100."
The point is that relationships can't be boiled down to a single number or objective metric.
(FWIW, many people dislike feeling like they're always being judged and evaluated, and would find someone who tries to rank-order all their partners very unattractive. Thus adopting any formula at all disqualifies yourself from a majority of partners, and the folks who are left will be those who probably like the idea of rank-ordering partners themselves. Good if you're mathematically-inclined and looking for someone else who is too, but many people seek emotional connection in a relationship.)
edit: It also ignores the fact that you yourself are going to change as you date people. Some of the relationships that didn't work out for me, didn't work out because I was terrible at being in a relationship, and that doesn't factor into the equation at all. It sort of presumes you're some perfect relationship oracle.
(which isn't to say that the math isn't interesting, because it is, I just think anyone that takes the math as an actual model to use in their life is being silly).