That's not entirely true. A relatively widespread issue during 10.10 (Yosemite) updates was the installer seemingly locking up and actually moving all the files in /usr/local one by one to then from a backup location veeeery slowly, potentially taking >12h to complete the update rather than a pair of.
Besides, even if the installer did do that, the resulting updated OS still had all the same contents in /usr/local.
As far as I'm aware, the only change OS updates have ever made to the /usr/local folder is resetting permissions back to root:wheel.
because that's exactly what the logs showed it doing: https://discussions.apple.com/message/26856483#26856483 and because the preemptive fix (if you hadn't started the update yet) was moving /usr/local's content elsewhere: https://jimlindley.com/blog/yosemite-upgrade-homebrew-tips/
And it was for 10.10. I'm sure people who'd been bitten (or had avoided it through the procedure above) repeated it for 10.11 reflexively or just in case, but the issue was the 10.10 upgrade.
Incidentally, I had no idea about ⌘L to show logs during OS update.
In any case, even if the OS update takes a long time, the end result is you still have the same /usr/local you did before.
Also, FWIW, the discussion you linked to references TeXLive, as does the blog post you linked. I wonder if the issue here is not in fact having anything in /usr/local, but rather having used a package installer to install something into /usr/local (which I assume TeXLive does). It doesn't make much sense to me for the OS updater to move everything out of /usr/local and then back in one-by-one under normal conditions. But if you used a package installer to install into /usr/local, then it would make more sense for it to do something like that (which is to say, it may have special behavior around things covered by package receipts).
Edit: Well, under normal conditions, it might still move the folder away and back, but I'd expect it to just move all the top-level items from the folder back, instead of manually copying all of the nested files).
However, if everything you're installing that depends on Homebrew-provided software is also installed through Homebrew, then it should work regardless of location (I say "should" because I suspect that not every single Homebrew formula has actually been tested with a non-/usr/local install path).
Personally, I stick with /usr/local both because I've never had a problem with it, and because that makes it easier when working with software that uses a default PATH (since /usr/local is usually put in these default PATHs). But if you have any concerns whatsoever, then by all means use a different install prefix.
Sadly, you are correct about "not every single Homebrew formula has actually been tested with a non-/usr/local install path". In fact, while there are many Homebrew formulas of great quality, my impression is that there are also m many of rather poor quality, with other problems in them. E.g. just yesterday, I discovered that the Homebreak lmdb formula does not build properly versioned shared libraries -- because upstream didn't, and the packager either didn't notice or didn't care to fix it
I rarely (if ever) this kind of issue with MacPort and Fink, which try hard to avoid such problems (at the cost of a higher entry barrier for packagers -- for better or worse). Mind you, I am not everything is golden with them, either.
Disclaimer: I've been involved with the Fink project since OS X 10.1 or so.
Do I wish the 3rd party ones could be better integrated with the OS? Sure. But I'm definitely thankful it isn't Apple calling the shots (or more likely, releasing it and then refusing to call any shots at all for 8 years).
And that's way more up to date than it used to be.
> Apple gave MacPorts some support in the form of equipment, so there's some hints of their preferred method. But the core WTF is this: why doesn't OSX integrate a package manager for its unixy side?
Yeah who hasn't dreamt of a package manager handled like MAS.
I'd be happy if Apple helped package managers more, contributed (financially) to them and better took them in account or discussed stuff with them wrt major releases (see: Yosemite homebew woes), but I'm really quite glad the community is completely in charge of macports or homebrew or nix.
I don't see how it'd solve the primary MAS woes of horrible contributor/developer experience, uncaring maintainership and inflexible sandboxing.
I was imagining a package manager with the standard kind of "add whatever sources to your sources list you like" model, as most Linux distros have. If the MAS was rebuilt in terms of this, then presumably adding a custom package source would make custom apps (which, after all, are just packages) show up in the MAS app for selection as well, just as they'd show up in e.g. Ubuntu Software Center. Apple would only control their app/package source.
The interesting question is whether someone would be able to list an app in their third-party source as costing money—and, if so, how that would work, and where payment would go. Maybe each "source" could come with a payment processor token for the MAS client to interact with, additional APIs to let the MAS app grab payment receipts from your source server, etc. In other words, you'd be hosting less of a "package management repo" and more of a "store server with built-in package CDN"—but that's not too big of a change.
Now, I wouldn't expect Apple to actually go this far, but it'd be in line with their current philosophy on enterprise app distribution. Apple really really dislike third-party "app store" apps, third-party "updater" daemon apps, etc.; they would much rather build infrastructure to obviate your enterprise's horrible custom solution than try to have their CSRs understand and support it for you. I could see them building this thing if Microsoft, Adobe, etc. all bugged them to for long enough. And then you as an indie developer could take advantage of it by setting up a PPA-alike (and someone could create the equivalent of Launchpad to host yours and everyone else's.)
OSX actually has softwareupdate(8), which does work like this—and which at least the OSX system updates (managed now through the MAS app) execute in terms of—which could theoretically be fed custom catalogs (sources) in addition to Apple's, to get most of this part of the benefit. Never heard of anyone doing that, though.
> the core WTF is this: why doesn't OSX integrate a
> package manager for its unixy side?
They could, but my guess would be that they don't want friendly-looking tutorials (i.e. ones that the average user wouldn't be scared to follow) saying: > Ah, you just need to update your packages; install foo:
> macman -Syu && macman -S foo
They don't want to 'have to' offer support for average users accidentally doing 'power user' things, because they were built in.It's more likely that they just consider package management out of scope for their part of development-- something that benefits too few people to be worth the cost. Seems to have paid off, too-- package management has been well-handled on OSX for a long time, both through semi-sanctioned projects like MacPorts (which is community-developed but is hosted by Apple) and through community projects like Fink and Homebrew.
> there are lots of other "power user" things that are
> built in
Can you think of any that were they not there, they would still implement today?I thought someone might bring up AppleScript - but I think that's a relic of every user being a 'power user', and personally I really doubt it'd be created today if it didn't already exist; it probably doesn't take much to keep it around now that it is.
MacPorts is very, umm, opinionated. And doesn't seem to trust anything outside of itself. And has some weird opinions, too.
Example: For some reason, svn is a dependency for nmap. Forgot those gravity waves, the next nobel prize belongs to whoever can figure out why a network scanner depends on an obsolete version control system. So macports installs a shiny new version of svn. Which doesn't play nice with the svn that Xcode uses. Overtime I run (macport) svn from the command line it tells me to upgrade my repository, which breaks the Xcode svn.
The worst offender for MacPorts was TeX. I had an official install the latest version from TeX Live and MacPorts wanted to install a second version of TeX. I think they fixed it so you can use a TeX Live version, but it was definitely an issue.
I use ctrl-left and ctrl-right to switch virtual desktops. Can't remember if that's the default or if I used custom keybinding. There are a bunch of other window management keybindings that can be found in the OSX System Preferences.
Agree. I really like Spectacle (https://www.spectacleapp.com/) for window management on OS X. As a bonus, it's open source. (https://github.com/eczarny/spectacle)
* (the window manager sucks, but that's not the topic. I had to get it out)
* it needs a good package manager
For us ol' bearded folk (at least spiritually), OS X comes with a slew of unix tools we love. It already includes both vim AND emacs! However, these tools are hopelessly outdated: Despite OS X 10.11 "El Capitan" coming out last fall, Vim is still 7.3 (that's from August 2010. 2010!), and Emacs 22 (2007. That's right.)
So some enterprising folk come to the rescue: Fink, Homebrew, Macports...
Homebrew installs over /usr, so come the next OS update, all that gets squashed. Macports installs into /opt/local, but somehow doesn't survive an OS update. Also, when I tried installing SciPy it went and recompiled GCC4 from source. Guys, the 90s called, and it's been shown that recompiling from source for each user isn't worth the effort.
Apple gave MacPorts some support in the form of equipment, so there's some hints of their preferred method. But the core WTF is this: why doesn't OSX integrate a package manager for its unixy side?