News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by bediger4000 on Monday February 15, 2016 @10:21AM (#11103785)
"Many K-12 school efforts to reduce bullying have proven not very effective, leading educators to wonder what bullying prevention approach works best."

Could that be because the efforts have focused on having students, mostly those not subject to bullying, stop the bullying? My view is that only teachers and administrators can stop it, and further that teachers and administrators have informal policies that actually foster and increase bullying. Teachers and administrators know who the bullies are, they just don't do anything at all to stop them, probably because the bullies and the teachers and admins are all part of the same power structure.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by wlesieutre on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:33AM (#11110980)
The official policy from schools lately has been "zero tolerance" for violence, meaning if someone hits you and you defend yourself, you get suspended for just as long as they do. It's set up to let the school wash their hands of any responsibility, but without having to have an uncomfortable "Your kid is an asshole who keeps starting fights" / "My kid is a perfect angel and I'm suing you for suspending him" conversation.

It's not designed to solve the victim's problem, it's designed to make it not the school's problem.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by koolba on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:46AM (#11111126)
> The official policy from schools lately has been "zero tolerance" for violence, meaning if someone hits you and you defend yourself, you get suspended for just as long as they do.

While I think most would agree that endorsing violence is generally bad, I'd advocate children defending themselves in that type of situation. It's not the only thing to do (someone needs to call an adult/teacher/etc) but if kids are penalized for coming to the aid of a fellow in need, what less are we teaching them? [1]

> It's set up to let the school wash their hands of any responsibility, but without having to have an uncomfortable "Your kid is an asshole who keeps starting fights" / "My kid is a perfect angel and I'm suing you for suspending him" conversation.

> It's not designed to solve the victim's problem, it's designed to make it not the school's problem.

Bingo. That's the issue with a lot of these so called solutions to social problems. They only solve the legal problems of the org where they're taking place.

[1]: Spoiler: The lesson is don't get involved in other people's problems.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by ashark on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:50AM (#11111162)
Fear of accusations of bias (especially involving one of the nasty "-ism"s) and (legitimate!) fear of a tendency toward angry-mobbing people who make a bad decision, even if it's only bad in hindsight, drives a ton of society's behavior. See also: nutjob reports kids walking down the street as being in danger, entire security/child-welfare apparatus responds as if this is a legitimate complaint because if any one of them puts the brakes on it, even if nothing happens in this case they may later have their life ruined if something does, as it eventually will because statistics. ("tonight at 8:00—in the wake of [horrible incident], channel six investigative reporters uncover a pattern of ignoring complaints of children in risky situations on the part of the local police department")
Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by ashark on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:38AM (#11111043)
The budget and political will aren't there to do much more than they already do. A detention here and there, kid's back in class the next day. Parents of bullies are usually uncooperative, to say the least. Combative and with shocking amounts of free time, more often. Academic stats (and therefore budget) suffer just as much for the school regardless of whether the reason two dozen kids did a step worse on the standardized test than they would have is because they spent three weeks each under suspension for bullying. There's no where else to send them, not in the volume they are present. No budget for it, no mandate. We're allergic to categorizing and separating (and hopefully rehabilitating! But... that costs money) kids on the scale that would be necessary.

The teachers and administrators can at best treat the symptoms, not cure the disease. Of course they fail at this as well, sometimes, but there just isn't much they can do unless the bully's so violent that they can kick them out with little risk of losing a lawsuit afterward.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by bediger4000 on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:59AM (#11111245)
Haven't you just confirmed that in your opinion, the problem is that the teachers and administration can't or won't do anything, so they're doing "bullying theater", and handing off the problem to all the pencil-necked bystanders, who really have no business intervening, and lots of motivation not to intervene?

What a ludicrous situation.

Personally, I don't even believe the "fear of lawsuits" thing. I was in middle school in the mid-70s, in Missouri. The crustier teachers still gave out "swats" as punishment. No fear of a lawsuit there.

Bullying was more or less winked at, depending on who was getting bullied. You don't have to believe me, but I saw a PE "teacher" walk in on a football player banging a poor kid's head into the wall, repeatedly. The "teacher" checked to see who was getting beaten, then walked away quietly.

Bullying exists to preserve the power structure that teachers and administrators are part of, which extends from outside the school in. "Bullying Theater" isn't going to stop it, or even mitigate the problem, it's only going to make things worse, because after the theater takes place, then teachers and admins can legally wash their hands of it all, and blame the bystanders, as well as the victims.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by ashark on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @12:21PM (#11111443)
> Haven't you just confirmed that in your opinion, the problem is that the teachers and administration can't or won't do anything, so they're doing "bullying theater", and handing off the problem to all the pencil-necked bystanders, who really have no business intervening, and lots of motivation not to intervene?

Oh, totally agree. The end result is awful, regardless of the reasons.

> Personally, I don't even believe the "fear of lawsuits" thing. I was in middle school in the mid-70s, in Missouri. The crustier teachers still gave out "swats" as punishment. No fear of a lawsuit there.

This ain't the 70s. Such a teacher's ass would get fired very quickly. And it's not just lawsuits—parents can and will go to the media, and sometimes they print what they say, especially if something can be framed (justly or not, doesn't matter) as racism.

> Bullying was more or less winked at, depending on who was getting bullied. You don't have to believe me, but I saw a PE "teacher" walk in on a football player banging a poor kid's head into the wall, repeatedly. The "teacher" checked to see who was getting beaten, then walked away quietly.

I'm sure this happens—I've seen too many accounts of it to believe otherwise. As with things like e.g. the power of teacher's unions to protect bad teachers, I have a feeling the facts-on-the-ground for this issue vary greatly across the country, and even district-by-district and school-by-school.

I doubt many teachers have a desire to preserve some power structure that involves bullying, though some might—usually they'd rather the bullies be removed from their class entirely. They're no fun for teachers, and their parents are usually even less fun. Mostly they want to go home feeling like the kids learned well that day, and bullies and other troublemakers are a leading obstacle to that. Effective responses to bullying aren't even available, though. Send 'em to the office, maybe a detention. Take away some recesses in lower grades. Talk to their parents, but their parents usually back them up and just get pissed off at the teacher (typically accusing them of racism when possible) so that's just tons of fun and so productive. That's about all they've got, and all it does is buy them (and the kids) a few hours at best.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @03:01PM (#11112714)
> Teachers and administrators know who the bullies are, they just don't do anything at all to stop them,

You can't stop them, not even teachers and administrators. Bullying is psychologically tormenting as much as physical. Even the "physical" can't be stopped... punished afterward, but the deterrence effect is minimal and by that time the damage is already done anyway. Next year it will be a different bully that hasn't had the deterrence effect kick in.

And the psychological? How are you supposed to stop gossiping or name-calling or any of the other forms? You could turn schools into prisons (haha, like they aren't already) and not stop that.

This isn't difficult to understand. If we fail to understand it, that's because we don't want to understand it.

You take every kid aged 5 to 18, drop them in an institutional building for 40 hours a week supervised by minimum wage workers who couldn't hack a real major, miseducate and propagandize to them... and you get bullying in there. It's not a function of any single one of these factors accept perhaps classroom size and school population size... but it's still a result.

The only way to prevent it would be to do away with public education. If each child was supervised by an adult, or ratios were tiny (say 3 kids per adult), you wouldn't much have this. But that ratio is impossible with a public school system.

And since you want the system, you can't do anything about the bullying. So we pretend that bullying is a problem solvable with half-assed non-solutions like this.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by cmurf on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @04:05PM (#11113121)
A big part of school is about creating worker bees. Do what you're told. Collaboration is cheating. Respect for authority is given, not earned. Cultural and national indoctrination mandatory. It's all rather tribal.

It gets a bit more interesting in high-school, but that relaxation I think only helps to solidify the worker bee concept, with this hard work comes some faux-freedom. Most of college is an extension of this but with a lot more tolerance for edge cases to pick alternate and innovative paths.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by rauljara on Tuesday February 16, 2016 @11:58AM (#11111228)
"Could that be because the efforts have focused on having students, mostly those not subject to bullying, stop the bullying?"

The article didn't go into a whole lot of detail on the other less effective programs. But it did talk about how this program was effective precisely because it focused on students instead of focusing on punishment[1].

[1] I realize punishment isn't the only way to get teachers and administrators involved, but it does seem like programs focusing on punishment would have to get teachers and administrators involved.

Re:Anti-bullying program focused on bystanders helps student... by bediger4000 on Tuesday February 23, 2016 @09:53AM (#11159191)
Oddly, the bullying issue in schools is the only place where US society officially tries to focus on victims and cooperative behavior, rather than stringent rules and punishment.

As I said above, I think that punishment could prevent bullying, and that teachers and admins just don't want to. There's all kinds of goofy, illogical rules in place about "drugs" and "weapons" and other "safety" issues, where the faculty, staff and admins aren't afraid to punish instantly. Those punishments are justified more or less by "common sense", so why isn't bullying punished?