News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by incongruity on Sunday February 14, 2016 @01:59PM (#11099472)
And here are three white collar jobs that PBS says are going away due to machines:

Pharmacists, lawyers, and journalists.

It isn't just dangerous jobs - it's repetitive or easily automated ones across the board. In very few cases does it completely eliminate a role - more often it is a force multiplier, letting fewer do more.

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/updates/3-white-collar-jobs-robo...

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by wrong_variable on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:12PM (#11099541)
Journalists are not loosing their jobs due to automation. They are losing their jobs due to the greed of their corporate masters - who value profit over delivering news that can be trusted.

Being a real journalist is a far more creative work then being a programmer. Especially in fields like investigative journalism - you must be a 100,000X programmer if you think you can replace Glenn Greenwald with a bot.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by protomyth on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:48PM (#11099676)
> Being a real journalist is a far more creative work then being a programmer

At this point, there should be a name for "No True Scotsman" applied to creativity. I have a tough time seeing the comparison between someone reporting what actually went on to someone creating wholly new things. I actually don't want creativity in my journalists or historians. I want ethics and fact checking.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by dannycodes on Sunday February 14, 2016 @04:13PM (#11100040)
Reporting what actually went on is an act of creation. Any good story requires detective work, something that is based a lot on intuition, interpersonal communication, and lateral thinking. These skills are not easy to automate. Also, you'll never get the complete story, some guesswork and logic is required to fill in the holes and deliver a cohesive narrative. So in that sense you'd need quite the impressive program to uncover the truth behind, for example, watergate.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by protomyth on Sunday February 14, 2016 @05:11PM (#11100224)
I am surely not one arguing robots, etc. can do a reporter's job better than a person. No, what I am arguing is this continued BS of who is creative is basically a "No True Scotsman" commentary.

On the other hand, I am very little impressed by the quality of what passes for journalism and am pretty confident that a computer could write much of what I see with better fact checking. Very much like CASE tools of old were used to write programs. At least a robot might be programmed with the courtesy to quote the whole thought and not make cuts that can be attacked or change the meaning.

As to the narrative, too many journalists write their articles as if they were pundits defending their beliefs and "trying to change the world". It is great to be engaging and write something that interests people, but leave the punditry for the political campaigns.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by skybrian on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:23PM (#11099579)
You say it's greed but worrying about profitability isn't optional, particularly when revenues decline as much as they have been in the newspaper industry.

When customers stop paying, fewer journalists have jobs.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by marcosdumay on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:49PM (#11099680)
Well, if you go into the job of selling information, and all you have for sale is a bunch of lies salted with a few low quality non-threatening truths, the weird thing is that anybody pays for it, not that you are getting out of job.

The greedy non-news model predates the internet for a long while. The internet just brought some competition.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by cwyers on Sunday February 14, 2016 @08:27PM (#11100980)
Sure they are, it's just not their work being replaced - it's the printing press. Journalism used to be a loss leader for the real revenue making activities of the newspaper press, advertising. The most profitable were the classified ads and car ads. Well, Craigslist gutted classifieds, and a combination of services have supplanted car ads in newsprint.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by vtlynch on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:11PM (#11099764)
Agreed. Journalism is one job that robots will never replace. Even if software eventually could, what company would write it.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by natrius on Sunday February 14, 2016 @04:04PM (#11100003)
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by prawn on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:26PM (#11099831)
A company looking to save on staff costs or to sell to another who wants the same?
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by jonsen on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:44PM (#11099657)
Journalists are not loosing their jobs due to automation.

Well, the robots don't buy newspapers.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by onlyrealcuzzo on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:10PM (#11099526)
I've always wondered why pharmacists still exist, yet TONS of articles say that there's almost no chance of that job being automated in the foreseeable future. I don't get it. It seems like a problem that's virtually impossible for a human to do, and not too tough to solve programmatically. Doesn't make sense to me. Would love to learn exactly why it will or will not be automated.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by trgn on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:03PM (#11099732)
Pharmacists in small towns are often first in line for people to seek medical advice from, often for small things: chit chat about their cough, show a nasty bruise or ugly cut, a weird rash, etc... They're like doctors-lite, a listening ear, but with some authority, and some agency to suggest minor treatment. Not unlike nurses. And usually a pharmacist could recognize when something is more serious and refer somebody to a doctor.

I grew up in such a town, and as a kid, I knew the pharmacist a lot better than the family doctor: "my ma told me to ask you about this wart on my hand", that kind of thing. Heck, our pharmacists even did home deliveries to old people (on her bike, no joke). I'm in a my mid-thirties, so this is not entirely ancient history.

So I can see why that social aspect of the work - which is incredible valuable - cannot be automated.

Now, there's WebMD, pharmacists are doing a shift in CVS, "small town life" is pretty much dead, these soft relationships between shopkeepers and customers no longer exist, people no longer defer to authority as easily as they used to, ...

Also, pharmacists have the law on their side. Drugs are a political issue, so they nurture their role as gate-keeper. For that reason alone, the credentialing will persist. The only difference is that perhaps a pharmacist will just be the lady pushing the on/off button on the vending machine, but still, somebody will need to push that button. The jobs that will be automated won't be the pharmacist's job, it will be the assistant's jobs.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by hfourm on Monday February 15, 2016 @12:10PM (#11104451)
Another anecdote. Girlfriend recently got switched to a different generic birth control, which lead to her have super bad side-effects compared to her previous one. This was due to a Target pharmacy change in providers.

She tried to call the pharmacy to see if there was any other alternative, or chance to get on her old pill due to the nasty side-effects. All she got in response was heartless no's and not our problem.

So I totally agree with the idea that these soft-relationships are a thing of the past.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by hippy_ldud on Sunday February 14, 2016 @04:13PM (#11100041)
> on her bike, no joke

Why would using a bike to make deliveries be a joke?

Lots of things are delivered by bike.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by hk__2 on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:32PM (#11099606)
Pharmacists aren’t just people selling drugs. They know exactly how to combine them and why you should take one or another based on how you are, what disease you have and if you have allergies. They can even sometimes replace physicians.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by kansface on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:33PM (#11099866)
I don't get it. Everything you just said is better done by a computer.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by maxerickson on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:35PM (#11099618)
Automation can still greatly increase their productivity.

(Even really simple things like computerizing prescriptions and flagging known bad combinations make them more effective, roughly for free)

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by Aloisius on Sunday February 14, 2016 @03:56PM (#11099964)
All my local pharmacies have automated pill dispensers that handle hundreds of medications and flag bad combinations.

The pharmacists at my local pharmacy seem to spend most of their time advising patients and dealing with their problems, verifying the pill dispensers actually dispensed the right medication and it is all intact, handling physical scripts for things like controlled substances, calling doctors when a prescription doesn't make sense or wasn't clear, flagging possible drug abuse, managing inventory, handling drugs that can't easily be dispensed by the machines like insulin and checking how much a person's insurance will cover and if it is still valid.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by incongruity on Sunday February 14, 2016 @06:50PM (#11100618)
And 20 years ago, there would have had to be multiple pharmacists and techs to do all of the things that are being done by machines now. Just as I said above, technology is often more of a force multiplier than a strict substitute.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by petra on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:42PM (#11099647)
Laws say pharmacist must give you the prescription, in a pharmacy. So there's little automation.

But with online ordering(PillPack ,etc) ,the laws are different, so there's more automation.

Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by protomyth on Sunday February 14, 2016 @02:43PM (#11099649)
Well, IHS locally has a pill dispenser (looks like a pipe organ filled with pills that drop into the container), but they have two pharmacists. I guess there are still errors.
Re:Jobs that are disappearing thanks to robots by venomsnake on Sunday February 14, 2016 @09:57PM (#11101273)
Except the occasional mix in place, they are essential double check against doctors' errors.