News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by refurb on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:56PM (#11092051)
I don't think that's true for all companies. The big, multi-national company I work for keeps all candidate assessment form that have been filled out by the interviewer (even for summer interns). Of course we're trained beforehand to not put stuff in the form that could be construed as discriminatory based on protected classes.

You have to keep in mind that if a candidate is rejected and comes back and says it was illegal discrimination, those forms are valuable evidence to show why the candidate was not selected. Get rid of the forms and it's basically your word against theirs in court.

That said, I've also been told that no one every goes to the trouble to dig those up later on. Even for current employees. You could get a letter of reprimand put in your file and nobody would probably see it again (this comment came from HR).

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by Gracana on Saturday February 13, 2016 @08:20AM (#11093826)
The university I worked for had a very strict hiring process, and it was all recorded as well.

The process worked something like this:

1) Get approval from HR to start the hiring process. Your department needs to have the money to hire someone, and a need to fill a position. I'm not sure how either is decided.

2) Define the position. Several people are involved here, basically you define the role and the areas of expertise that you want and need.

3) Information from 2 gets sent back to all involved parties, and everyone ranks the skills by necessity and comments on things.

4) HR takes the information and creates job listings, and collects candidates.

5) Interviews take place, and you grade applications according to what you decided in 3.

6) Hire someone who satisfies the requirements and did well in the interviews.

There's some leeway in the system because the interview and the judgment of the interviewers matters, but you can't just accept somebody because you like them, and you can't reject someone because you don't.

As for what happens with an applicant's information after they're rejected... I'm not sure where it goes or whether it gets called up again if they re-apply. Our department was pretty small though, if we didn't hire you the first time, we won't have forgotten you by the second time around.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by neoncontrails on Saturday February 13, 2016 @05:54AM (#11093509)
" Get rid of the forms and it's basically your word against theirs in court."

Isn't that the ideal situation to be in, if you're the defendant? The burden of proof rests on the employee to prove discrimination. From the company's point of view, surely, the fewer forms, the less proof.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by rdancer on Saturday February 13, 2016 @01:55PM (#11095167)
In a civil suit, the standard is "preponderance of evidence". In a he said, she said situation, circumstantial evidence becomes very important. If you've hired a hundred black lesbian octogenarians, and you're sued by a class of 20-something latino hetero males, you better be able to prove your hiring process wasn't discriminatory.

Some jurisdictions also shift the burden of proof under some circumstances so it is actually worse for the defendant.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by Buttons840 on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:52PM (#11092222)
Are there laws that would allow me to get the interviewers notes?
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by weinzierl on Saturday February 13, 2016 @03:11PM (#11095475)
In Germany the interviewers notes and all the other documents related to the candidate have to be destroyed when they are not needed any more (Datensparsamkeit, literally data austerity, officially data reduction and data economy).

When a candidate is rejected there is period of to months they can sue for discrimination. After that one additional month is considered to be justifiable. So everything has to be destroyed three months after the rejection letter if there is no discrimination case.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by Alupis on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:55PM (#11092234)
Yes, during discovery, for instance.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by Buttons840 on Friday February 12, 2016 @10:38PM (#11092374)
What do you mean?

I was thinking for example: I can request a copy from my employer of HR docs specific to me. Does this only apply because I'm employed, or does it extend to interview notes?

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by Alupis on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:03PM (#11092465)
The parent was discussing illegal discrimination -- if you were suing for any reason, part of the process would be discovery, in which you may request documents and information for use in your case.[1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discovery_(law)

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by icedchai on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:10PM (#11092493)
You actually think "interview notes" are recorded anywhere formally? Pretty unlikely in 90% of corporations. You're likely requesting something from the circular file.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by cm2187 on Saturday February 13, 2016 @08:31AM (#11093851)
And half of the recruiters are drawing dinosaurs on their notepad during the interview!
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by pmiller2 on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:14PM (#11092507)
In California, at least, the law specifies that it only applies to "current and former employees."
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by fidget on Saturday February 13, 2016 @06:10AM (#11093532)
In the UK, it's as simple as just requesting it from the company
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by pjc50 on Saturday February 13, 2016 @04:25AM (#11093358)
EU data protection does, but only if the notes are computerized.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by marcus_holmes on Saturday February 13, 2016 @09:04AM (#11093936)
I used to be the IT Director for a document scanning business in the UK.

Scanning paper HR records was the single most painful job we had to do. The entire file became a complete legal nightmare purely because it stopped being paper and became covered by Data Protection.

Usually the HR department had to go through every single employee file and shred any documents that might be grounds for legal action before they got scanned.

The process before scanning was: - employee is annoyed - employee requests their HR file - HR sanitise file and sends it to employee

after scanning, every single page was indexed. So they couldn't react to a request by destroying pages (because there'd be holes in the index). So they had to sanitise every single file before scanning.

I understand the point of Data Protection law, but in this case it was really counter-productive. Evidence was destroyed wholesale.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by pjc50 on Saturday February 13, 2016 @09:38AM (#11094064)
That sounds like "working as intended" - after all, if instead of just requesting their file the employee had initiated legal action against you, it would have been illegal to destroy those documents. And it also raises the question of which part of your HR process is generating incriminating documents in the first place?
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by marcus_holmes on Saturday February 13, 2016 @12:01PM (#11094673)
not so much "incriminating" as "not required to be kept and could possibly be misconstrued".

Not our HR process, our customer's. What was actually destroyed depended on their interpretation of the law.

One common one was the Data Protection requirement to not keep inaccurate data meant that all but the latest employee change of address forms had to be destroyed. Easy to implement post-scanning, pain in the arse to do pre-scanning.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by tomp on Saturday February 13, 2016 @05:25AM (#11093451)
Why would that be so? It's not the candidate's personal information...
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by newjersey on Saturday February 13, 2016 @07:15AM (#11093675)
If you store I formation about me, it is by definition my information. It may be your thoughts but if there is a link to me, I should get to see it.

Think multi device ad retargeting. How cool would it be to get back information on what the ad exchange thinks I am like...

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by rayvd on Saturday February 13, 2016 @08:38AM (#11093871)
Wow. No. My thoughts are none of your business.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by pjc50 on Saturday February 13, 2016 @08:42AM (#11093883)
It's not thoughts, it only applies to data stored in a computer.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by newjersey on Saturday February 13, 2016 @09:29AM (#11094014)
Thank you. I guess I didn't articulate it well enough for the grand parent comment here. I guess we could make an exception for personal AND non-commercial diaries but if you make business decisions that affect me based on information you store about me, then I should have a right to see them.

I'm also thinking about the rights of everyone including criminal (including terror) suspects to see (I am specifically not asking permission to alter or delete, that's another conversation) all the information the government (and their agents in the private sector) stores about them.

I know it sounds onerous specially because of the issue of authentication (how does the CIA know that it is me who is asking for information about me and not someone impersonating me?) and I don't have a good solution for these questions.

Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by wildmusings on Saturday February 13, 2016 @04:26PM (#11095735)
This is a ridiculous idea to me. If I run a business, my internal evaluations of candidates and employees are no one's business but my own. They are my observations about the world, with the productive end of hiring better employees. Whether my decisions affect you or not is really not relevant; we make free decisions that affect other people all the time. I take issue with any claim that people have legally-binding private obligations to each other beyond abiding by contracts, and refraining from violence and fraud.
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by newjersey on Saturday February 13, 2016 @11:37PM (#11097152)
OK, what about a compromise: you can keep your conclusions private, you only need to disclose to me the raw data you used to reach such conclusions. Is that better?
Re:Why Do Employers Rarely Offer Explanations to Rejected Ca... by wildmusings on Saturday February 13, 2016 @04:32PM (#11095759)
Let's do some reductio ad absurdum here:

"We're not banning thoughts, just those that are inside books."