Barter transactions are supposed to be taxed. Literally, if I have a friend who comes over and rakes leaves out of my yard in exchange for and while I repair the brakes on his car, we're both support to report income (me for the free leaf-raking I got and him for the free brake repair labor).
If I call up an old mentor and he gives me useful, money saving tips that I employ to amplify my business's profits, should he be taxed "as if" he billed me as a consultant?
If employees of a for-profit startup ask questions on a mailing list they're members of, should the mailing list be taxed as if it were selling consultancy services?
And how (too tired to come up with an answer myself) would this case differ from Vanguard? I'm guessing it has to do with the fact that the Vanguard investment management company is charging other people market price for its advice, but what if my mentor did that? Are we now in a world where, if I sell a good for-profit to anyone, I must pay taxes on the income I would have gotten, any time I give that good to someone else for free?
What if my wife's a professional childcare provider? Do I have to pay taxes on the imputed income from when she's alone with our kids? (There are non-G-rated versions of that question, btw.)
(Honest questions, all. Don't know if I'm missing something here or misunderstanding the tax threat model.)