News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:31AM (#11086991)
While I ultimately agree with your conclusion, you're eliding the issue, which is the transfer pricing. You have one affiliated entity providing a service at below market rates to another affiliated entity. Ordinarily that raises concerns about tax dodging. Here, it has the effect of shifting money from something that isn't tax exempt (the asset manager) to something that is.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by snowwrestler on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:00AM (#11088108)
Ok they are affiliated entities, but the it seems relevant to me how they are affiliated. Since the manager is owned by the fund, it seems there is an argument that the entirety of the manager's business is an expense to the fund, just like if a company buys its own airplane and hires its own pilots and ground crew, instead of flying commercial all the time. Or like how Apple bought a bunch of semiconductor companies to design chips in-house, instead of just buying off-the-shelf components.

Reducing costs is typically one of the main reasons one organization buys or incorporates a subsidiary, instead of just going into the marketplace for what they need. Will that now be illegal if it reduces the total tax payments of the formerly separate organizations, as a side effect? That seems like a pretty dramatic intrusion into business decision-making.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:28AM (#11088347)
Except here, we've got an entity that engages in two activities, one of which is for policy reasons tax-exempt (holding stocks in a mutual fund) and one of which is not (investment management).

Say a non-profit hospital ordinarily purchases services from a for-profit testing lab. The testing lab receives market-rates for its services, and pays tax on that income. Now, say the hospital purchases the testing lab, but continues to operate it as a for-profit subsidiary. But the hospital makes the subsidiary sell its services at cost, eliminating the subsidiary's tax liability while boosting the hospital's non-taxable surplus. Maybe that's still okay. But now say instead of a testing lab, the subsidiary is an advertising agency. Same result?

It's worth reading Matt Levine's take on this: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-11-25/calpers-fee... (scroll down to "Vanguard and taxes").

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by vonmoltke on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:39AM (#11088433)
What is the difference between the hospital running the lab as a for-profit subsidiary at cost and the hospital folding all lab operations into the non-profit entity? Ditto for the advertising agency? The road you are going down would make any acquisition of a for-profit entity by a non-profit entity illegal.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:47AM (#11088501)
Non-profit exemptions rest on the government's policy of forgoing tax revenues on specific favored activities. Non-profit entities have to take great care to avoid engaging in activities besides those favored ones. So the non-profit hospital likely couldn't fold the advertising activities into itself without jeopardizing their tax-exempt status.

The problem is not the acquisition of the for-profit entity by the non-profit entity. The problem is when those entities don't interact at arm's-length.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by jrock08 on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:17PM (#11089181)
I'm not sure if this is a valid comparison, but imagine that a group of doctors got together and founded a hospital, and decided that they would run the hospital as a co-op, where employees would buy into the co-op rather than receiving a normal salary. However, as they grow they realize that they actually need some corporate guidance, so they find a management company. The management company doesn't want an ownership stake in the co-op, and the co-op doesn't want to dilute it's members, so instead they mutually agree to pay the management company a fixed X million dollars for it's contracting services. In the meantime, the co-op grows 10-fold, but the contract with the management company doesn't change (somehow, let's just assume the co-op doesn't require active management, they just need guidance occasionally or something). Now, someone looks at this and says, hey, if you had the normal management structure you'd be paying 10 times what you pay for your current management since they would take home y% of the profit and that would be taxed, but instead your co-op gets better tax treatment.

This would clearly be absurd, the management company is happy with their fee, and the co-op members are happy. The fact that "normal" corporate structure would pay more in tax shouldn't really factor into the decision since the question should be, given your corporate structure, are you paying taxes.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:59PM (#11089517)
Your analogy hits a snag here:

> In the meantime, the co-op grows 10-fold, but the contract with the management company doesn't change (somehow, let's just assume the co-op doesn't require active management, they just need guidance occasionally or something)

The question isn't what a "normal management structure" would cost. It's what the affiliated entity would normally charge in the market for the same service. Vanguard's sells its investment management services to the mutual fund at cost because it's owned by the mutual fund. It wouldn't do that otherwise.

So to make your example comparable, the co-op buys the management company, and makes it operate at zero profit. So the question is: would the management company be happy making zero profit if it weren't owned by the co-op? The answer is: probably not.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by jrock08 on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:08PM (#11089596)
So, I'll admit that I don't understand the details of how vanguard is paying employees or the external people that actually manage the money, but presumably, they pay a fixed fee to someone to manage the money, and that fee is significant (but not a significant fraction of the money under investment). The fact that "normal" in investment funds is percentage of money under investment plus percentage of the profit shouldn't matter since they've found a way to run a company that doesn't need to pay those fees to get the money invested.

edit: I should add, that I'm fairly certain that the employees at vanguard are in fact getting paid.

edit2: So the question is should we look at whether the employees/contractors at vanguard are getting paid market rate, or whether vanguard as a whole is charging market rate to the investors. My comparison to the hospital co-op was that it's unfair to compare apples-to-orangutans.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by kspaans on Saturday February 13, 2016 @06:32AM (#11093574)
But isn't one of the points of Vanguard that their investment management is cheaper by its very nature? Namely: passive, index-tracking funds are simpler and cheaper to manage than active ones?

I can see that they could have run afoul of some tax rules due to their structure, but it seems disingenuous to argue that they should charge management fees just as high as their active management competitors. (But sure, maybe they should charge more than they do now.)

Then again, as an owner of Vanguard index funds, maybe it's hard for me to be rational in this case. >:D

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by OrwellianChild on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:50PM (#11089986)
I feel like I'm missing something here... Is it not legal to run an investment management company as a non-profit? Likewise, is it not legal for the non-profit arm of Vanguard to mange its own investment as an integrated part of its organization?

At what point do these legal distinctions begin to take effect? If a friend and I pool resources and purchase some stock, then later sell it at a profit and split the trading fees, did we somehow owe unpaid tax?

It seems like this is a tax against vertical integration in financial services, which I'm not sure I understand the need for...

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by badloginagain on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:43AM (#11088457)
Can you back up and explain what "transfer pricing" is? The article itself kind of skirts around the issue, and it sounds like it's at the heart of the issue.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:57AM (#11088572)
The Wikipedia article is pretty good: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_pricing#Profit_alloca.... Basically, it has to do with the prices charged for goods and services between related entities. Generally, laws require that these prices be the same as they would be if the companies were interacting in arm's-length market transactions.

Consider, for example, a tax dodge Samsung is alleged to have engaged in. Samsung Electronics makes products in South Korea, then sell them at cost to Samsung Distribution, which is an affiliated company in a low-tax jurisdiction. Samsung Distribution then exports the products at market price to Best Buy, etc. Samsung Electronics books little or no profits in South Korea--all the profits are booked by Samsung Distribution in the low-tax jurisdiction.

There is also a corporate-entity angle to this. Operating as a separate corporation has benefits: if one goes bankrupt, its creditors cannot reach the assets of a related entity. But if transactions between related entities are not arm's-length, it's easy to shift money around between them and abuse the protections of separate corporate forms by, e.g., leaving riskier lines of business undercapitalized in case of a tort judgment.

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by badloginagain on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:45PM (#11089418)
Thanks. Sounds like a hell of a thing to prove wrong-doing, especially if it's crossing multiple legal/tax/regulatory jurisdiction's.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by gmarx on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:53PM (#11090014)
Holding stocks in a mutual fund is not tax exempt. You pay taxes on dividends and I think also you pay as the turnover produces net profits. You also pay capital gains on shares you sell. Eventually it all gets taxed
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:31PM (#11090793)
The mutual fund itself is tax-exempt and passes profits and gains onto owners of the fund. Think about the alternative: you create a corporation to hold the assets of the fund. Dividends on those assets would be taxed when the corporation receives them before they are distributed to shareholders.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by Zigurd on Friday February 12, 2016 @10:25AM (#11087798)
That's not how transfer pricing works. Mutuality that extends to fund management means the ultimate owners are the customers of the fund - the people who placed their money with Vanguard. So unless you extend the concept of transfer pricing to all mutuality (something investor-owners would love), co-ops and other ownership and business models that don't maximize profit in the same way that investor ownership does, that just not a "transfer pricing" issue. That idea that investor ownership has some special place in the economy is a pretty vile concept.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by SilasX on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:23PM (#11091416)
I can understand the concern about tax dodging, but how far does this go? You could make the argument that any non-profit arrangement that throws of monetarily-beneficial goods below price is dodging taxes.

If I call up an old mentor and he gives me useful, money saving tips that I employ to amplify my business's profits, should he be taxed "as if" he billed me as a consultant?

If employees of a for-profit startup ask questions on a mailing list they're members of, should the mailing list be taxed as if it were selling consultancy services?

And how (too tired to come up with an answer myself) would this case differ from Vanguard? I'm guessing it has to do with the fact that the Vanguard investment management company is charging other people market price for its advice, but what if my mentor did that? Are we now in a world where, if I sell a good for-profit to anyone, I must pay taxes on the income I would have gotten, any time I give that good to someone else for free?

What if my wife's a professional childcare provider? Do I have to pay taxes on the imputed income from when she's alone with our kids? (There are non-G-rated versions of that question, btw.)

(Honest questions, all. Don't know if I'm missing something here or misunderstanding the tax threat model.)

Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by sokoloff on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:36PM (#11091978)
Barter transactions are supposed to be taxed. Literally, if I have a friend who comes over and rakes leaves out of my yard in exchange for and while I repair the brakes on his car, we're both support to report income (me for the free leaf-raking I got and him for the free brake repair labor).
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by humanrebar on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:43AM (#11087058)
So the fund business isn't paying (enough?) taxes on fees paid to their investment management business?
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by rayiner on Friday February 12, 2016 @08:46AM (#11087075)
The fund doesn't pay taxes on fees paid to their investment management business. From their perspective that's a cost. And he investment management business is running at break even, so they don't pay taxes either.
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by matthewmcg on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:21AM (#11087286)
Wouldn't near break even be the long term equilibrium in perfect competition for investment management services? Doesn't this really just expose how much other managers over charge?
Re:Vanguard's Low Blow by jacobr1 on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:03AM (#11088137)
Yes, it does identify how much they overcharge.

But the law is there for a reason, to prevent tax dodges. Like selling a patent to fully owned foreign subsidiary in a low tax jurisdiction for $1. Then having that subsidiary collect royalties of millions from the parent domestic company. The expenses (of the royalties) are deducted, and tax is only payed on the much lower profit. The foreign subsidiary pays local (lower) taxes and keeps the profits in a foreign account. This is clearly a tax dodge. If you allow the IRS to levy tax on market rates for patent transfers and royalties, they can can redo the accounting to figure out what a fair tax would have been without the accounting games.

I'd really like to see the law changed to allow Vanguards actions (presuming they are indeed in violation) but I'd also be worried about adverse consequences.