News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by jpeg_hero on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:46AM (#11087494)
I'm no neckbeard (well, maybe I am, ha) but I've been wondering really if the new "Safety Council" will be the beginning of the end.

There's already stresses on the system, baroque user name / user discovery, you go to post and you can't condense your point into the space allowed even though you tried a few times, you've been using twitter for a while so the novelty is wearing off, you are in your own place in your own "timeline curation journey" -- maybe you have too few people and you don't get a lot of value out of timeline checking, maybe you've got too many and the high volume posters drown out the good signal from the low volume posters (that's where I am at, and don't know how quite to fix it,,,), maybe your interests have changed, so when you check your timeline its like listening to those old mp3's from the 90's that you still keep around (not your current tastes, and terrible encoding rates), so now you need to curate a new timeline, and that's a lot of work, and where to start?!?

,,,anyways, this is your feeling about Twitter, and then, now there is this new layer of the "Safety Council Directorate" and the wild west feel is gone from some of the signal, and maybe it even makes you worried about your own potential implosion from a social media misstep ("So You've Been Publicly Shamed"),,, and then you say to yourself, to hell with it, this Twitter thing is getting too ponderous.

---

http://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/02/twitters-new-safety-cou...

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by bonaldi on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:30AM (#11088362)
I haven't hammered this point home because I've lost the graph, but have absolutely seen one breaking down user growth month by month, and there's a clear turning point around about August 2014 — which is of course the month the Gamer Gate frenzy kicked off.

If there's something in that correlation, then actually the Safety Council is unlikely to be the beginning of the end — but it may come too late to reverse the damage done by the abusers who have run rampant on Twitter for years.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by r721 on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:58AM (#11087580)
>maybe you've got too many and the high volume posters drown out the good signal from the low volume posters (that's where I am at, and don't know how quite to fix it...)

One of solutions: add high volume posters to thematic lists and unfollow them. Check lists when you have time for that.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by daigoba66 on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:50AM (#11087519)
> maybe you've got too many and the high volume posters drown out the good signal from the low volume posters (that's where I am at, and don't know how quite to fix it...)

Unfollow. Seriously, that's the best way to decrease noise. Yeah, perhaps they do occasionally tweet something interesting. But if 50%+ is just noise, it's hardly worth it. I'll look for their content elsewhere.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @10:56AM (#11088070)
OMG. I left twitter a while ago and now seeing that it turns into a digital nanny state makes me even happier to be out.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by coldpie on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:10PM (#11089125)
If you're the type of person to say something likely to be censored on Twitter, we don't want you on there anyway.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by PKop on Friday February 12, 2016 @05:57PM (#11091309)
You envision some perfect censorship filter. What if reality differs from your ideal?

What if, miracle of miracles, you and I disagree on what should or should not be censored? What if Twitter straight up abuses this power? Either way, the result may be fewer users, and this could hurt Twitter as a business.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @01:36PM (#11089338)
"We"? Are you the queen?
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by coldpie on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:12PM (#11089646)
Which of Twitter's unacceptable content policies do you find objectionable? I agree with all of them, and I think the vast majority of Twitter users do as well.

https://twitter.com/rules

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by dayon on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:36PM (#11089851)
Instead of rules, look at what's being censored and tell us if you agree.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_Twitter

http://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/censoring-...

And so on.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by coldpie on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:50PM (#11089981)
I do not have any problems with Twitter's actions in the New Yorker article. I don't find "slippery slope" arguments persuasive when there is real harassment being committed right now. I don't think the wikipedia link is relevant to this conversation; it seems to be about state censorship. The "Controversy" section as it's written now is obviously not NPOV and cites no sources.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:52PM (#11090000)
Exactly. Give them the tools and they'll censor whatever the fashion of the day calls offensive.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by coldpie on Friday February 12, 2016 @03:17PM (#11090186)
I know! It starts when you can't call a woman a slut, threaten her life, and post her private details and nude pictures on Twitter, and then before you know it you can't print out her picture, ejaculate onto it, and mail the soiled photo to her family[1]. What a crazy world we're headed towards.

[1] Why yes, this does actually happen. Harassment on the Internet is no joke. http://blog.unburntwitch.com/post/139084743809/why-i-just-dr...

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:13PM (#11090648)
Exactly! So let's just pick that one thing, and then invent some "guidelines" that totally won't prevent anything like that ever, but allow you to arbitrarily censor people with the wrong opinions. Awesome! War against "harrassment", mission accomplished!
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by nommm-nommm on Friday February 12, 2016 @05:08PM (#11091051)
Entitlement generation.

I don't have a problem with Twitter "arbitrarily censor[ing] people with the wrong opinions." Its their platform and they don't have to give a voice to everyone who has one, they can do whatever they please and promote any agenda they want. That is their choice. If you don't like Twitter's rules you're free to start your own site, or write a book. Nobody is entitled to use someone else's site any way they wish.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by PKop on Friday February 12, 2016 @06:00PM (#11091323)
People are bringing this up to say that it could annoy many users and chase them away, as well as limit their user growth, not that they don't have the right to do it. Bad business decision, in other words.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:31PM (#11089817)
That's why basic rights like freedom of speech exist, to protect us from such "well-intended" attacks in favor of an alleged "vast majority". "Harassment" as in that policy or other "codes of conduct" can be pretty much anything, in particular now that it has become standard mode of operation to claim victimhood for just about anything to silence other people.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by coldpie on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:53PM (#11090013)
The constitutional right to freedom of speech applies to public (government) institutions, not to private (non-government) institutions like Twitter. Twitter is exercising their constitutional right to freedom of speech to disallow certain kinds of content on their platform. There is no violation of anyone's constitutional freedom of speech.

If you think it's a poor business decision, that's your call, and time will tell. But it has precisely nothing to do with "freedom of speech."

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by mason240 on Friday February 12, 2016 @03:56PM (#11090509)
Freedom of speech and the First Amendment are two different things, but I suspect you already know this.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by elcapitan on Friday February 12, 2016 @04:10PM (#11090626)
No, that's just how he brushes off inconvenient problems.
Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by walterbell on Friday February 12, 2016 @11:28AM (#11088344)
> maybe your interests have changed, so when you check your timeline its like listening to those old mp3's from the 90's that you still keep around (not your current tastes, and terrible encoding rates), so now you need to curate a new timeline, and that's a lot of work, and where to start?!?

Lists could be used as forkable alternate universes, but Twitter does not provide the tools.

- keep high and low frequency users in separate or topical lists, keeping in mind that people may change tweet frequency

- create annual (past you, future you) lists and fork each year, removing people or topics that are no longer aligned

Instead of Twitter black box curation that cannot possibly serve the millions of niche threads and communities, Twitter could enable 3rd-party analytics for refactoring lists/streams by metrics that are under the control of users. Even the curation signals could be crowd-sourced on Twitter itself, with appropriate API support.

Twitter could have an API competition to re-engage 3rd parties. Use the raw datasets already available to academia and identify new signals and APIs to enable client side, human "intelligence augmentation" innovation in curation analytics. As a side effect, curation will provide new signals for targeting.

Re:Twitter, to Save Itself, Must Scale Back World-Swallowing... by pjc50 on Friday February 12, 2016 @02:30PM (#11089812)
The safety council is not likely to achieve much, but it's a very necessary step in the right direction. Otherwise the threat of driveby harrasment flashmobs is going to start driving people (especially women) off twitter.