News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by danhak on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:15PM (#11082850)
Shouldn't states be able to compete among themselves, in a free market fashion, in order to attract business development that is likely to pay huge dividends over the long term?

It's a little disingenuous to divide the incentive package--which is effective over 20 years and only if Tesla meets all its targets--by the population of Nevada, without similarly considering the taxable revenue the company will generate over the same period if those targets are reached.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by krapht on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:39PM (#11083040)
My problem with it is that citizens are supposed to be equal under the law. There isn't equal access to these incentives. Doesn't an educated professional moving to Nevada also bring positive externalities to the state? Yet they will never be able to negotiate incentives like these due to the great disparity in bargaining power.

I am against special carve-outs, subsidies, and other manipulations of the tax code in general for the same reason.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by danhak on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:45PM (#11083090)
Your point is well taken, but an educated professional moving to Nevada is not likely to affect the state's economy enough to move the needle.

I'd contend that there is equal access to incentives like this for any entity with sufficient scale.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by fennecfoxen on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:03PM (#11083233)
> there is equal access to incentives like this for any entity with sufficient scale.

Even when that's perfectly so and the rest of Democracy is perfectly fair, this dynamic is intrinsically unfair and benefits the rich and powerful established interests at the expense of smaller entities. It's the gateway from capitalism to cronyism.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by danhak on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:33PM (#11083443)
Maybe I'm out of touch, but I just don't consider a fledgling electric car manufacturer to be an "established interest."
Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by fennecfoxen on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:49PM (#11083556)
Elon Musk is worth $13 billion. Tesla Motors is worth $19 billion (roughly half of Nissan). Both are household names. You read about their exploits in these pages, and in publications such as the New York Times or Wall Street Journal, as a matter of routine. QED

And sure, you don't expect the Mom and Pop family-owned shop down the street to spring up to compete with Tesla like you might expect a local bakery to compete with General Mills, but you do expect Tesla to have some competition in areas like the labor market.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by krapht on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:53PM (#11083162)
Sometimes I like to pretend I live in a country where those with money and influence don't receive preferential treatment from the state. I know why it happens. I know it will continue to happen. The same thing happens on the country-scale with multi-nationals picking the most favorable nation to be taxed in. But I don't want my government to enable the game by playing it.

Pardon me while I wait for Tesla's windfall to trickle-down and lift all my boats.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by fennecfoxen on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:00PM (#11083197)
Expecting to have a government (or a series of governments) work like a "free market" is problematic, because there is no reason to expect that market to be efficient. In particular, no one should expect a free market to be efficient when transaction costs are high. Consider transactions one would have with a regional government: a family moving from one state to another is expensive, paying a lawyer for your small business to ensure compliance with a new jurisdiction is expensive... even just getting a real conversation with your state-level representative (let alone lobbying for a tax break) is kind of a big deal: has anyone here done it recently?

As a result, you would expect concentrations of power to emerge in the form of special interest groups and corporations who can pay those transaction costs more readily.

(This is intro-to-Econ level stuff, if you ever care to study the field.)

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by rhino369 on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:13PM (#11083306)
>Shouldn't states be able to compete among themselves, in a free market fashion, in order to attract business development that is likely to pay huge dividends over the long term?

Sure, but that competition should be based on taxes that don't discriminate for and against certain individuals and companies.

There is also an argument that allowing states to compete with each other just causes a race to the bottom. Tesla was going to build the factory anyway. The country as a whole is worse off is Telsa is allowed to negotiate away all taxes by forcing states to compete over it.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by prostoalex on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:48PM (#11083552)
> The country as a whole is worse off

In a vacuum environment where it's 50 states and no one else that rings true. In global environment US was already competing at country level, would Nevada be better off if the factory went to China or Mexico?

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by protomyth on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:43PM (#11083077)
> Shouldn't states be able to compete among themselves, in a free market fashion, in order to attract business development that is likely to pay huge dividends over the long term?

That sounds perfect except we are talking about governments that are supposed to represent all of the people and not just selected interests. This is a judgement by government picking a winner.

I dearly wish it was illegal for local or state governments to give any tax deals for specific companies or organizations.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by Shivetya on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:04PM (#11083238)
The Federal government does the same and much of it is for similar reasons, should it be prevented from doing so? We have many examples at all levels of companies donating to political campaigns to get returns.

I don't mind states competing with each other to bring in jobs. Such competition can cause some states to not make bad budgetary decisions that drive business out as well as trap their population in undesirable areas. Business and personal mobility is what makes the country stronger economically. They are betting on a return of investment which is better use of money that making financial promises to agencies which produce no money but instead incur long terms costs. Those deals are usually purely to prop up the political fortune of local politicians. They lead to upside down budgets and long term debts that force higher taxes putting them at a competitive disadvantage for new jobs and drive professionals out.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by protomyth on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:17PM (#11083339)
> The Federal government does the same and much of it is for similar reasons, should it be prevented from doing so?

Yes, a hundred times yes. This is one of the biggest problems with our tax law and allows politicians, under the guise of promoting businesses and jobs, of bribing people and companies. One law for all.

Competing can be done without alterations in tax law to bribe companies. Its a straight up cash bribe and nothing more honorable. All of these deals are made with other people's money. Its bad enough we have status seeking politicians trying to attract sports teams. I look at the absolute bull that FX companies deal with and see all the problems of allowing government bribes.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by prostoalex on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:51PM (#11083564)
> This is a judgement by government picking a winner.

It's not like Nevada had a rush of battery factories, and they picked out one company, letting the others rot.

Politicians get elected and fired based on jobs and taxes. New factories bring jobs and (allegedly) increase the tax base.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by protomyth on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:59PM (#11083619)
They chose to use tax money to support one business over the existing businesses in the state. If it requires tax breaks to foster businesses than perhaps they need to work on the whole system and not pick a specific business.
Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by prostoalex on Thursday February 11, 2016 @05:24PM (#11083799)
> They chose to use tax money

Non-existent tax money as of now. The way the incentives work, Tesla would have to generate enough business activity (revenues, sales, profits) to accrue that tax liability. It's quite possible that business activity will never materialize, the tax liability will fail to accrue, and the incentive won't even have a chance to kick in.

The state is making a bet that (a) such activity will materialize, (b) once materialized, it will draw such a high amount of ancillary business (suppliers, resellers, distributors, etc.) and residential (property, shopping) activity that it will more than compensate for lost revenue.

The bet is not completely uneducated as case studies from the past (mainly around Texas cities attracting Nissan and then Toyota away from Californian cities) suggest that overall it's worth it.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by protomyth on Thursday February 11, 2016 @06:07PM (#11084064)
It may make them money, but they picked a winner. I find governments doing this type of stuff just encourages churn of companies. If anything would improve the overall business climate in the US, making all of these deals illegal would be a good first step.
Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by prostoalex on Thursday February 11, 2016 @06:42PM (#11084242)
The "pick" though was 1 out of 1, and I mentioned in another comment how one could sort of replicate it by moving into a state that has 0% sales tax to boot (finding a cheap property that would not generate a large property tax bill would be step 2). It also seems that Nevada extended a similar deal to Faraday, and actually went out of their way to attract them http://www.autoblog.com/2016/01/28/nevada-lawmakers-spent-25... at which point I get what you're saying - why doesn't Nevada just pass a universal incentive for certain industries instead of operating on a company-by-company basis?

I agree on the churn, though, in dense populated environments big retailers are known to close up shop in one town to reopen it across the street in different town with different plaza, just because the second town offered a better tax deal.

> in the US, making all of these deals illegal would be a good first step

It might improve the overall business climate in China though. Once the supplier chain is set up and functioning, it's hard to move it elsewhere

http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-and...

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by protomyth on Friday February 12, 2016 @09:28AM (#11087358)
If you want to read an example of the churn check out the FX industry and incentives.

Technically, the pick was tailoring laws for 1 company versus all the other companies in the state. Is there no company in the state that could benefit more than Tesla and produce growth with changed rules? Even if there was, I still believe this dealing making should be illegal since it encourages corruption and is unfair to everyone else. This is the type of thing that has politicians / political staff members "retiring" to cushy jobs in the private sector.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by LordKano on Thursday February 11, 2016 @05:03PM (#11083646)
Shouldn't states be able to compete among themselves, in a free market fashion, in order to attract business development that is likely to pay huge dividends over the long term?

Of course they should but I believe his objection is the sweetheart deal for one company.

For example, if Nevada wants to compete with Arizona, it should lower its tax rate. It shouldn't be able to keep the tax rate high and offer a deal to one company that eliminates taxes for them and for them alone.

It provides one company with an unfair advantage over any potential competitors.

Re:Nevada’s $1.3B gamble on Tesla by pbreit on Thursday February 11, 2016 @04:09PM (#11083285)
Plus, there's no money to dole out without the deal.