Non-existent tax money as of now. The way the incentives work, Tesla would have to generate enough business activity (revenues, sales, profits) to accrue that tax liability. It's quite possible that business activity will never materialize, the tax liability will fail to accrue, and the incentive won't even have a chance to kick in.
The state is making a bet that (a) such activity will materialize, (b) once materialized, it will draw such a high amount of ancillary business (suppliers, resellers, distributors, etc.) and residential (property, shopping) activity that it will more than compensate for lost revenue.
The bet is not completely uneducated as case studies from the past (mainly around Texas cities attracting Nissan and then Toyota away from Californian cities) suggest that overall it's worth it.
I agree on the churn, though, in dense populated environments big retailers are known to close up shop in one town to reopen it across the street in different town with different plaza, just because the second town offered a better tax deal.
> in the US, making all of these deals illegal would be a good first step
It might improve the overall business climate in China though. Once the supplier chain is set up and functioning, it's hard to move it elsewhere
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-and...
Technically, the pick was tailoring laws for 1 company versus all the other companies in the state. Is there no company in the state that could benefit more than Tesla and produce growth with changed rules? Even if there was, I still believe this dealing making should be illegal since it encourages corruption and is unfair to everyone else. This is the type of thing that has politicians / political staff members "retiring" to cushy jobs in the private sector.