News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The crash of 2016? by carc on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:51PM (#11076830)
I find all the economic prodigies here entertaining. People who's day job is to predict this stuff can't even make good predictions. I guess I never knew that techies were better economists than the economists
Re:The crash of 2016? by nostrademons on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:19PM (#11077322)
"People who's day job is to predict this stuff can't even make good predictions."

That's probably a good part of why everyone has an opinion - when the "experts" are so clearly clueless, everybody's an expert.

"If we've got data, let's look at data. If all we have are opinions, let's go with mine." -- Jim Barksdale

Re:The crash of 2016? by zzalpha on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:31PM (#11077651)
Or it's just good ol' Dunning-Kruger...
Re:The crash of 2016? by perseusprime11 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:23PM (#11078052)
Here's another quote: "Opinions are like assholes, everyone has one and they stink"
Re:The crash of 2016? by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:47PM (#11077165)
Do you have anything to back that statement up, other than 20/20 hindsight? I'll admit that few economists get timing right on big macro events, but please don't tar us all with the same brush: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10166958

If you want to see some decent economic commentary, look here: http://www.macrobusiness.com.au/ . These guys have been screaming bloody murder for at least the past year.

Re:The crash of 2016? by dandelany on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:09PM (#11077267)
How about the fact that index funds consistently outperform actively managed funds?
Re:The crash of 2016? by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:26PM (#11077634)
And the relevance of this is...?
Re:The crash of 2016? by dandelany on Thursday February 11, 2016 @12:27PM (#11081520)
You asked for evidence backing up the statement "People whose day job is to predict this stuff can't even make good predictions". Managers of active mutual funds are exactly these people. The fact that they can't beat the market is clear evidence they can't make good predictions.

Of course you could say "well, the good managers beat the market, even though on average they don't". But you could also say that the few people who correctly predict three coin flips in a row are "good at predicting coin flips" - it's easy to say this in retrospect but impossible to predict who the "good ones" are upfront.

Re:The crash of 2016? by Throwaway23412 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @07:43PM (#11077440)
The whole concept of "being good at prediction" is extraordinarily difficult to back up. If you were even a few percentage points better at prediction (especially economic predictions) than the average person, your life is pretty much made. You would literally be better than the average person at seeing into the future. There is a 1% of people (Warren Buffett and James Harris Simons for example) who are significantly better than the average person at predictions, but chances are some random Australian on a tech forum is not part of that 1%.
Re:The crash of 2016? by etherael on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:51PM (#11077721)
This is hilarious, or would be if the consequences were not so sad.

It's listening to someone standing on the deck of the titanic talking about the complexity of the design of the ship, how many great and esteemed members of the establishment signed off on it, and how crazy it is that anyone on the deck is pointing out that it's sinking because they can actually see it sinking, like anyone else can that actually looks at the horizon.

This is not a rebuttal. Arguments from authority about why the masters of the universe have it all figured out and those who are pointing out that they have no clothes are just clueless barbarians at the gate are fundamentally invalid.

Complexity, obfuscation and worship at the altar of authority do not actually make for solid fundamentals. This ship is going down, massively increasing the tokens for the representation of scarce resources so that the people who controlled the tokens back the last time they completely failed, does not make the people that controlled those tokens any more competent than they were at the actual game in question last time they failed.

All the central bank moves, the macroeconomic obfuscation, lies, Keynesian nonsense, negative interest rates, cash ban proposals, underhanded capital controls, worldwide currency wars, geopolitical games with oil to back fundamentally worthless scrip, bail-ins, bail-outs etc, none of it changes the underlying fact that the presently dominant system ordering the allocation and distribution of scarce resources is, as you sit here on the deck of the ship dismissing that fact, sinking below the horizon.

Re:The crash of 2016? by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:06PM (#11077775)
Yes that is exactly what I'm doing; you've cleverly seen through my subterfuge. I concede the argument to your superior reasoning and reading comprehension.

EDIT: Well this is embarrassing. I apologise to the guy above and below me. I guess it was actually my superior reading comprehension...

Re:The crash of 2016? by etherael on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:10PM (#11077789)
You seem to have missed the thrust of my commentary, I am saying that you are correct, it is appropriate to scream bloody murder, and that the person dismissing this as "some random Australian who couldn't possibly know better than the masters of the universe", to whom I actually replied, was hilarious.
Re:The crash of 2016? by Throwaway23412 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:16PM (#11078020)
Maybe I'm misinterpreting you or you're misinterpreting me, but I feel like I'm arguing against the concept of predicting the future. It's absurd that this is even an argument.

And when I say the top 1% are significantly better at making predictions than the average person, I mean better in certainty and specificity.

Look at yours and spangry's comments. Full of vagueness.

"Appropriate to scream bloody murder".

About what exactly? It's certainly appropriate to scream bloody murder about things that are happening. It would be nonsensical to scream bloody murder about something that isn't happening.

"the economic depression that will occur in the next 5 years will be started by bubbles popping in residential property markets"

What a huge range of uncertainty. So when is this economic depression occurring? Tomorrow? 2017? 2021? What kind of economic depression? Minor? Major? Capable of plunging the world into the Great Depression? Such vague predictions are fundamentally worthless to the average person.

Re:The crash of 2016? by etherael on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:25PM (#11078230)
But you're not actually arguing the concept of predicting the future, you're arguing that when you throw something up, you can't predict that it's going to come down.

Look at the charts, the writing is on the wall, denying at this point because the talking heads on the television are telling you that everything is going to be alright while it's very clearly not is not taking a cautious stance and saying one cannot predict the future, it is ignoring the facts on the ground as they are.

Baltic dry index, Deutsche Bank CDS spread on 60 trillion of derivative exposure, Sovereign Debt CDS', the leverage of gold on the primary exchange in the world for paper vs physical gold, the buckling price of oil, the desperate moves of the central banks in the previous 8 years coupled with begging from the too big to fail banks that even more reckless and wild moves need to be undertaken (Let the banks charge negative interest on deposits, ban cash so the consumers can't avoid it, allow the banks to make the spread, give us more quantitative easing, keep manipulating the roulette wheel so we remain on top despite our utter incompetence, pay no attention to the market moves that say we're about to be destroyed, except of course to the extent you need to understand that if we are it's the end of the world as we know it because we're too big to fail, etc).

The systemic cancer needs to be destroyed for the actual effective allocation of scarce resources to be performed, the existing central banking system, its oversight, and basically everything about it, needs to undergo creative destruction.

Re:The crash of 2016? by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:52PM (#11078305)
Nice selective quoting there. You have no intellectual honesty at all. Just for the record, I was very specific about the magnitude and nature of the coming crisis in the post I linked (and that you apparently read, but omitted parts that didn't fit your little narrative). This is my comment from 160 days ago:

"Mark my words: the economic depression that will occur in the next 5 years will be started by bubbles popping in residential property markets (China's first, most likely). Consequently, we'll be looking at financial system collapse when this is transmitted to banks via insolvent residential property speculators (to whom they've loaned significant amounts of money). This ain't going to be pretty...

On the hopeful side, countries like the US, Ireland and Iceland who 'took their medicine' during the GFC (sustained heavy property price declines or significant bank collapses), will be closer to fundamental values already. So they may have less distance to fall, even though there will probably be some overshoot. Also, OPEC flooding the world market with oil (to try and kill the US shale oil industry in the crib) and the likelihood that China will run down its foreign currency reserves to pay for stimulus (depreciating the US dollar) will mean US export industries (excluding oil and natural gas) become very competitive indeed.

Countries like China, Australia, Canada and the UK on the other hand, who staved off significant property market corrections during the GFC (especially Australia), are in for a very bad time (http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/11/global-hou...). Like worse than 1920s depression bad time (closer to 1890s depression)."

So: enormous crisis, china run down fx reserves, crisis will originate from distorted chinese property market driven by speculative bubble popping.

Here are a few news articles, some from just today:

http://www.marketwatch.com/story/kyle-bass-warns-chinas-fore...

http://www.cnbc.com/2016/02/08/latest-chinas-fx-reserves-dro...

http://www.wsj.com/articles/this-chinese-citys-property-mark...

And this is where I bow out. I'm done trying to reason with the unreasonable.

EDIT: I lied. Christ, you even misquoted me from a few posts up: "If you want to see some decent economic commentary, look here: http://www.macrobusiness.com.au/ . These guys have been screaming bloody murder for at least the past year."

Re:The crash of 2016? by spangry on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @08:25PM (#11077633)
I'm sorry, when did I claim I was some kind of share market mastermind? I wouldn't have a clue on how to work the stock market. I think you and I have very different definitions of the word 'economist'. I'm guessing you're one of those folks who think 'economics is all about money'?

Doing company valuations and making share market predictions are very different from having an understanding of macroeconomics or tax theory in a public policy context.

And very few people are good at prediction (myself included), and even fewer when it comes to timing. Economists have predicted 8 of the last 2 recessions :)

Re:The crash of 2016? by adventured on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:10PM (#11076969)
When the dollar soared, a crash in emerging markets was extremely obvious. It has happened several times before under similar circumstances. It doesn't take a prodigy to understand how it works, it requires not putting your head into the sand and pretending fake good times (paid for via massive piles of debt and endless rounds of currency debasement) last forever.

Who's to say most economists are any good at their jobs? Did you see what many of them were saying during the obnoxiously obvious real-estate bubble of 2004-2007? The dotcom bubble? And so on.

Re:The crash of 2016? by dpc59 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:27PM (#11077059)
The thing is that a lot of economists have a vested interest in markets going up and bubbles inflating, because their jobs at financial institutions depend on that, so when things start going bad they just block their ears, pretend everything is alright and hope that the markets don't suffer from too much panic.
Re:The crash of 2016? by gozur88 on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @09:58PM (#11077959)
I don't see how random people off the street can be worse economists than economists. Was there ever a profession that was wrong so often and still generally heeded? Nutritionists, maybe.
Re:The crash of 2016? by etherael on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:11PM (#11076975)
Plenty of people were better alchemists than alchemists back in the day, too.
Re:The crash of 2016? by clock_tower on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:17PM (#11076996)
And plenty of people were better doctors than doctors were.

Theodore Dalrymple had a column proving that Shakespeare did _not_ have a formal medical education, because he described symptoms correctly. (He contrasted this with a book by a practicing doctor from the time, who described patients purely in terms of the four humors -- creating fanciful descriptions unrecognizable to a modern practitioner.)

Come to think of it, there was also a book published a few years ago about US president James Garfield's death in the late 19th century. He didn't die of being shot in the back; he died of receiving the best medical care in the world.

Re:The crash of 2016? by crdoconnor on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @06:34PM (#11077095)
>People who's day job is to predict this stuff can't even make good predictions.

When you get paid for lending academic legitimacy to politically 'useful' recommendations, accuracy isn't necessarily priority #1.