News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by danvoell on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:34AM (#11073382)
Might explain why winners of free market capitalism want to institute measures (laws, regulations) to keep others from achieving the same level of winning.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by tomp on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:53AM (#11074056)
> Might explain why winners of free market capitalism want to institute measures (laws, regulations) to keep others from achieving the same level of winning.

I don't think that's an accurate description of reality. My take is that everybody wants to institute measures that benefit them and hinder others... but the "winners" (i.e. the rich) have comparatively more political power and thus also more success forcing these measures through.

Re:Why winners become cheaters by anigbrowl on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @02:43PM (#11075409)
My take is that everybody wants to institute measures that benefit them and hinder others

How convenient for you! What would your response be towards a verifiable counter-example?

Re:Why winners become cheaters by tomp on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:13PM (#11075613)
Discussion, I guess. I'd love to hear some counter-examples.

My only rhetoricism in the comment was that "everybody" was probably an exaggeration; more accurate would be "most people".

Re:Why winners become cheaters by anigbrowl on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @03:46PM (#11075846)
Yeah, I knew you were being a bit hyperbolic but this is a bit of a touchy issue for me (see other comments on this thread) so I apologize for my sharp tone.

Obvious examples would be people like aid workers, religious clergy and others who ostensibly hew to some unselfish non-discriminatory ethical code, but as well know such activities often sacrifice material wealth in exchange for significant social currency, plus there's a disappointingly high proportion of predatory types to be found among those ostensibly caring for the most vulnerable. I don't have the paper to hand now and can't remember enough to look it up but I was surprised last year to discover that people with sadistic tendencies (as measured by clinical instruments) are over-represented in the paramedic profession, for example.

One group that I am inclined to think is extraordinarily concerned with maintaining a level playing field even at their own personal expense is the community of economic theorists, although this claim might seem pretty counter-intuitive at first glance. It also gives rise to a weakness at the heart of the profession; economists are so concerned with discovering objective criteria for efficient outcomes that they don't have a don't have a good model for greedy or altruistic behavior, and until fairly recently have relied instead on the conceit of everyone being rational utility maximizers, much as you did in your grandparent comment. This implicit assumption has led to the discipline being long labeled as 'the dismal science,' notwithstanding the majority of its practitioners' positive rather than normative aims.

Re:Why winners become cheaters by tomp on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:45PM (#11076306)
Re: aid workers; I agree that they don't seem very selfish, but we might simply be hitting the bottom of the power continuum - because they know that they couldn't succeed/gain influence in any other endeavour, they opt at least for good feelings (that one gets when one is altruistic/ethical); or as you said, they benefit in other ways. I'm not saying that's a bad thing - there are definitely worse ways to satisfy one's emotional needs; just that it doesn't mean they wouldn't fuck people over if given a chance.

Re: clergy - what is this, I can't even... I guess this simply wasn't the best example, but I can't even begin to consider members/representatives of one of the most corrupt, deceitful, greediest institutions in the past 2000 years - the longest-running scam - to be anywhere near selfless.

Re: economists - I'm afraid my opinion of them weights heavily towards them being completely delusional; economics is such a vague "science" and everything is completely unprovable, so having a theory (which isn't correct - no theory is) is infinitely more valuable than being intellectually honest and admitting that you basically know nothing. This is apparent both in theorists (academia encourages this), as with practitioners (LTCM: win Nobel => crash the market; or the past few presidents of US FED - each "fixing" the market only to make it crash even harder). Sure, they might be well-meaning, but so were middle-age "doctors" who made leeches suck their patients blood...

Re:Why winners become cheaters by anigbrowl on Thursday February 11, 2016 @03:29AM (#11078958)
I'm too tired now to address the whole thing but just to clarify that when I said clergy I didn't mean Christians in particular.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by dec0dedab0de on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:25PM (#11074299)
My take is that everybody wants to institute measures that benefit them and hinder others

Maybe I'm not living in the real world, but I sincerely doubt that most people would like to hinder others.

Re:Why winners become cheaters by michaelt on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:41PM (#11074416)
Most people probably don't think of the things they support as "hindering others" - they think of it as "making the market take externalities into account" or "preserving the character of the neighbourhood" or "ensuring safety for customers of our industry" or "bringing our short-term incentives in line with our long-term incentives"
Re:Why winners become cheaters by anigbrowl on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @02:53PM (#11075482)
Taking externalities into account isn't hindering others, since the externality is by definition an unwanted imposition pf costs on a third party that didn't exist prior to the economic activity that generated it. I fail to see how this is different from an unpaid bill, and Nobel laureate Ronald Coase has rather convincingly argued* that the costs of mitigation in advance or in arrears ends up being the same, but that the transaction costs of enforcing property rights against externalities are a sufficient barrier to many pollutees that polluters are often willing to gamble on others' inability to adequately enforce their rights and pocket the resulting savings.

* in The Problem of Social Cost, an unusually readable essay for the field of economics.

Re:Why winners become cheaters by evanpw on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:01PM (#11074559)
"protecting American jobs"
Re:Why winners become cheaters by bduerst on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:51PM (#11074988)
It's rational when the hindrance means fulfilling self interests.

I've been in competitive workplaces where people would try to get your project shot down because it could compete for resources with their own.

Re:Why winners become cheaters by tomp on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @02:28PM (#11075292)
Measures that benefit a group of people implicitly hinder all the rest.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:36AM (#11073397)
Part of the same psychology. Like Lance Armstrong, they begin by rationalizing "I just want to level the playing field". Then they take acts to elevate themselves well above the field.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by ickwabe on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:40AM (#11073423)
Joe Rogan interviewed Lance Armstrong in depth and Armstrong talks in detail about how he got to the point of justifying "juicing" to himself.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEfSdPz1WtA

Re:Why winners become cheaters by maxxxxx on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:34PM (#11074366)
Rogan was way too nice with Armstrong IMO.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by neonhomer on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:40PM (#11074408)
Most of the winners have won through illegal actions or government collusion. That's not free market capitalism.
Re:Why winners become cheaters by minikites on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:11AM (#11073647)
This is why we need strong labor protections like unions.