News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by duaneb on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @10:55PM (#11070659)
I have come to understand this brutal sentencing structure, or at least some of the reasoning. It appears to be the "other side" of the question "how many guilty men should go free for how many innocent men"? The strength of the punishment is proportional to how hard it is to convict with certainty. The aggressive sentencing is greatly exaggerated to form a disincentive for all the men we cannot convict.

Justice strikes me of an area where humans tend to reason intuitively. It's also an area that is extremely difficult to measure in any quantitative way. I would be highly interested in understanding what drives existing criminals--my own intuition tells me these sentences are not very preventative, but allow for the illusion of making progress against crime, particularly violent crime. (These people are monsters! Thank god they're gone for life, or the dangerous part of their life.)

Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by Fjolsvith on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:48AM (#11071648)
The disincentive of aggressive sentencing is just well-wishing. When I committed my crime, I was not even aware of what laws I was breaking or even the amount of punishment I could receive. Most of the men I knew in prison also were not thinking of consequences at the time they were being bad boys. I would say the main exception to this were the men who had been in organized crime.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by Natsu on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @01:27AM (#11071078)
There is the fact that criminals are less able to commit further crimes while in prison.

It's not foolproof by any means, but I'm kind of comforted by the fact that the man who deliberately ambushed and murdered mom with a hammer, then later threatened to do something like that to grandma cannot, in fact, pay us a visit barring some failure of the prison system.

Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by duaneb on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:19PM (#11076572)
> There is the fact that criminals are less able to commit further crimes while in prison.

This presupposes we catch the criminals. This doesn't really match up with reality—it's actually quite difficult to get any conviction from some murder cases, for instance. In a limited sense, what happens to the individual doesn't matter nearly as much as laws affect crime rates.

Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by Natsu on Friday February 12, 2016 @03:38AM (#11085962)
I was pointing out that prison, as a sentence, serves a use beyond mere retribution. The fact that some criminals are never caught is not relevant to that claim.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by justinpombrio on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:27AM (#11070916)
My understanding is that this has been studied, and criminals are deterred almost entirely by the certainty of being caught, and almost not at all by the severity of punishment.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by mseebach on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @02:26AM (#11071240)
The problem with this line of argument is the assumption that deterrence is the only purpose of punishment. Justice (in the hard-to-quantify sense referenced by the GP) for the victim and community (and on a practical tangent, the deterrence of vigilante justice) is a pretty significant purpose of punishment.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:29AM (#11070922)
Varies. Texas sentenced petty criminals to hoe potatoes in the desert sun. Petty crime recidivism plummeted in Texas.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by wildmusings on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @12:31AM (#11070932)
Let's not forget retribution. We intuitively feel that it is wrong for someone to live well after having caused someone else so much suffering.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by Fjolsvith on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @04:52AM (#11071653)
We most certainly do not feel this way. An eye for an eye is not a life for an eye.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by girvo on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @05:57AM (#11071860)
We might not, but a sizeable portion of the populace does
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by wildmusings on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:53AM (#11073505)
I honestly doubt that you have no problem with a heinous murderer living comfortably in his mansion and never serving time in prison.

I'm not talking about taking limbs and eyes here...

Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by zimpenfish on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @11:18AM (#11073703)
Without wishing to get into politics, that almost certainly already happens - if you have money or standing, you can get away with a lot.
Re:Former federal judge to President Obama: Free the man I s... by Fjolsvith on Wednesday February 10, 2016 @10:56PM (#11078141)
If he mounts a good defense and is proven innocent, then he never committed the crime.