Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis
by ameister14 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:39PM
(#11067067)
Yes, and the real rate for those making above 500k is less than 10% lower. So...35% of what they earn.
Probably not.
> Doctors, lawyers, and managers, at the point in their careers where they are the most experienced and capable, will likely decide in meaningful numbers it is no longer worth putting in the hours if they only get to keep 27% of what they earned.
This rate cuts in for income over $10 million/year. That's on the order of 5 times the cutoff for the top 0.1%, and the top 0.1% is on the order of 150k tax payers in a nation of 300+ million people. Even if the whole group decided to stop doing work that would subject them to the new rate (which is different than "early retirement" -- more on that next), we aren't talking about giant numbers.
And the way marginal taxes work, if they are okay with putting in effort as long as they are getting as good as they do under the current tax system but unwilling to do so at the new rate that would kick in at $10 million, then they wouldn't stop working entirely, they'd just stop doing the extra work to go over $10 million a year.
Which probably isn't that much of the work they are already doing in many cases, and, in any case, so what? It opens up more opportunities -- even if you assume no one is willing to do work that would only return what income over the new top marginal rate would return -- for people who are currently making less than the point at which that new top rate kicks in. So, the main effect would be the super rich having somewhat more leisure time (or making decisions less weighted by maximizing financial returns and more based on other factors, which may not always mean less total working time, but better working conditions or more enjoyable work) and everyone else having more income-earning opportunities available.
Not exactly the end of the world.