News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by merpnderp on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:17AM (#11066270)
Won't this push a lot of highly payed professionals into early retirement? Doctors, lawyers, and managers, at the point in their careers where they are the most experienced and capable, will likely decide in meaningful numbers it is no longer worth putting in the hours if they only get to keep 27% of what they earned.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by msbarnett on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:18PM (#11066901)
> Doctors, lawyers, and managers, at the point in their careers where they are the most experienced and capable, will likely decide in meaningful numbers it is no longer worth putting in the hours if they only get to keep 27% of what they earned.

Only 27% of what they earned above $10 million. They keep considerably more of the first $10 million they earn.

Did the entire nation sleep through the day they explained how marginal tax rates work, or something?

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:28PM (#11066986)
> Won't this push a lot of highly payed professionals into early retirement?

Probably not.

> Doctors, lawyers, and managers, at the point in their careers where they are the most experienced and capable, will likely decide in meaningful numbers it is no longer worth putting in the hours if they only get to keep 27% of what they earned.

This rate cuts in for income over $10 million/year. That's on the order of 5 times the cutoff for the top 0.1%, and the top 0.1% is on the order of 150k tax payers in a nation of 300+ million people. Even if the whole group decided to stop doing work that would subject them to the new rate (which is different than "early retirement" -- more on that next), we aren't talking about giant numbers.

And the way marginal taxes work, if they are okay with putting in effort as long as they are getting as good as they do under the current tax system but unwilling to do so at the new rate that would kick in at $10 million, then they wouldn't stop working entirely, they'd just stop doing the extra work to go over $10 million a year.

Which probably isn't that much of the work they are already doing in many cases, and, in any case, so what? It opens up more opportunities -- even if you assume no one is willing to do work that would only return what income over the new top marginal rate would return -- for people who are currently making less than the point at which that new top rate kicks in. So, the main effect would be the super rich having somewhat more leisure time (or making decisions less weighted by maximizing financial returns and more based on other factors, which may not always mean less total working time, but better working conditions or more enjoyable work) and everyone else having more income-earning opportunities available.

Not exactly the end of the world.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ameister14 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:39PM (#11067067)
Yes, and the real rate for those making above 500k is less than 10% lower. So...35% of what they earn.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by toomuchtodo on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:24AM (#11066355)
Only 27%. ONLY! Did you know the UK has a 40% income tax over £42,385? And plenty of doctors, solicitors (lawyers), and managers continue to work for income.

https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates/current-rates-and-allowa...

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by tyingq on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:56AM (#11066677)
The 27% is what they keep, not the tax rate. The comparison would be 73% to your 40%.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by toomuchtodo on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:07PM (#11066795)
Thanks for clarifying that. In that case, people should feel free to not work any additional time if that additional income that intrudes into that highest marginal tax rate doesn't provide enough incentive for them after tax.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by nightski on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @01:52PM (#11067699)
27% is what they keep, I think he was implying a 73% income tax rate. What are you trying to say here?
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by toomuchtodo on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @01:55PM (#11067723)
> What are you trying to say here?

Taxes are too low in the US, the lowest they've been in ~100 years. They must go up, and if people in the highest income brackets make less, so be it. You're still making 7-8 figures/year. At some point, enough is enough. Who is to say what enough is? Society, the system in place enabling you to earn that money in the first place.

My apologies I wasn't getting that point across.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by MuEta on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#11066378)
At least for doctors, I would think that the average annual income is somewhere around $300,000-400,000 (and that may be too high). This group would, all-in, be taxed somewhere between 50-60% including medicare, Social Security, etc., no where near the 73% imposed on any dollar made past $10,000,000. There may be a handful of doctors in the world pushing the $10,000,000 barrier. I assume that the landscape is similar for lawyers and managers, and that people tend to focus on those making huge money to generalize the whole field.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by vnchr on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:32AM (#11066444)
If so, that might improve the job prospects of many up and comers in those fields. I think your point is clear that there's potential for loss because of the retiring talent, but that can incentivize investing in talent down the pipeline.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ameister14 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:40PM (#11067081)
There aren't enough qualified doctors for our population as it is.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by maxerickson on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:28AM (#11066396)
They get to keep a larger fraction of the first $10 million of income.

I wonder how many people earning more than ~$1 million per year really care about the exact level compensation they get (there are an awful lot of people that reduce their working time well before that level of income).

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by dangoor on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:26AM (#11066367)
People don't always work solely for the money. Also, that top tax rate is only in income above $10 million. The money below that threshold is taxed at lower rates. So, they would be keeping more than 27% of their total income
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by frandroid on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:33AM (#11066449)
How many of these people make over $10M a year? Also, even if they do, they wouldn't be taxes that high on the first $10M.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by vorotato on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:21AM (#11066323)
Good, more room for the next generation.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ctdonath on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:27AM (#11066387)
Why would the next generation want to take up that room? Would you take up a career where despite long & expensive education, long hours, hard work, and lives-in-your-hands responsibility, you kept just 27% of your income? would you put in a million dollars of effort to net a quarter of that in return?
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by delazeur on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:05PM (#11066771)
That's not how tax brackets work. You would "only" keep 27% of your income over $10MM, but you would keep a much higher percentage of that first $10MM.

> would you put in a million dollars of effort to net a quarter of that in return?

Even if I was paying 27% on the first $10MM, putting in $1MM worth of effort would get me a return of 170% per year.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:35PM (#11067047)
> Why would the next generation want to take up that room?

Because they want the things money can buy.

> Would you take up a career where despite long & expensive education, long hours, hard work, and lives-in-your-hands responsibility, you kept just 27% of your income?

Maybe, maybe not, but, anyway, that's not how marginal rates in a progressive tax system work. Even if the marginal rate that kicks in at $10 million is 73%, that means you only keep 27% of the amount after $10 million, and some greater amount of the part below $10 million. Obviously, an increase in the top marginal tax rate decreases the incentive to work to increase income once you've reached the annual income level at which the higher tax rate applies, but doesn't it really hurt anyone that people already making at least $10 million/year prioritize making additional income less over other priorities?

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ctdonath on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @02:10PM (#11067833)
Ronald Regan, as a movie star, regularly didn't make movies precisely because the progressive tax system would head into confiscatory levels making the effort worthless to him. Such rates denied both the public at large from products they wanted, and the government tax revenue. I don't want my world to actively discourage the talented from producing.

I want to encourage people to make insane amounts of money, because that is largely the result of far-and-above productivity which everyone else benefits from. Jobs are created, desirable products/services are generated at affordable costs, money is invested (even banked "cash" gets loaned, and extravagant luxuries create markets), and the general standard of living is raised.

The cost of discouraging effort is never included in these "soak the rich, redistribute the wealth" equations.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @03:16PM (#11068407)
> Ronald Regan, as a movie star, regularly didn't make movies precisely because the progressive tax system would head into confiscatory levels making the effort worthless to him.

Really, if the greatest cost to society you can point to of increasing the top marginal income tax rates is "fewer Ronald Reagan movies", I don't think you are making a very strong case.

> Such rates denied both the public at large from products they wanted, and the government tax revenue.

The case that it denied government net tax revenue requires more than Reagan not making movies, it requires a whole-economy comparison of what activity occurred instead and the actual taxes applied against that activity.

> I want to encourage people to make insane amounts of money, because that is largely the result of far-and-above productivity which everyone else benefits from.

This "trickle down" concept is a widely held article of faith in some parts of the population, but not a position well supported by evidence.

> The cost of discouraging effort is never included in these "soak the rich, redistribute the wealth" equations.

The "cost of discouraging effort" is very hard to empirically establish without ambiguity, and there are sharply different opinions on what it actually is. What proponents think that cost is usually accounted for in where the various parameters are set; people who have different views of what the cost is, obviously, disagree that these settings are correct.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ctdonath on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @05:28PM (#11069330)
Pardon me for using a simple high-profile example to make the point. Detailing the failings of socialism in a mathematically provable form would take far more text than you are willing to read. As you note, it is very hard to empirically establish without ambiguity the economic realities of taking from those who earn and giving it to those who don't. Perhaps, given the understandable disagreements, we should adhere to the notion of individual freedoms which the Founding Fathers enacted for the USA and let those who wish to pool their wealth do so, and those who would rather decide for themselves do so; alas, we face the votes of those seeking to force, thru threat of government-sanctioned violence, others to adhere to economic principles they deeply disagree with.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by msbarnett on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:57PM (#11067222)
> Why would the next generation want to take up that room?

Are you seriously asking why anyone would consider a career in which they are "only" able to keep 27% of any money above $10 million they make in a single year?

You're incredibly out of touch if you don't think most people would kill for that opportunity.

> Would you take up a career where despite long & expensive education, long hours, hard work, and lives-in-your-hands responsibility, you kept just 27% of your income?

Yes I would absolutely do that for the privilege of keeping only 27% of anything more than $10 million a year I make. This is an incredibly good problem to have.

> would you put in a million dollars of effort to net a quarter of that in return?

This is not how marginal tax rates work. Consider putting down Atlas Shrugged and consulting a remedial math textbook.

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by ctdonath on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @02:19PM (#11067911)
Would you put in $100M effort & risk where you'd need a 4x return on investment just to break even?

As I work to make my owns end meet, I'm quite aware of the consequences of having a ~50% tax rate, putting out $X00,000 effort just to net half that.

And yes, I'm quite aware of the technical errors in my presented math. This is a casual forum, not a peer-reviewed paper. What baffles me is how others here won't do the remedial math showing that a 100% tax rate on everything over $1M wouldn't come close to paying for what Bernie et al promise and those here expect as obvious (never mind the always-neglected effect high taxes have on high productivity).

Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by Spooky23 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:33AM (#11066446)
27% of X, where X>0, is more than 100% of 0.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by rglullis on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:30AM (#11066424)
I don't know what is worse: the ageism you are showing or the mentality of an 18th century economist.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by pluckytree on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:24AM (#11066350)
To learn from whom?
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by toomuchtodo on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:24AM (#11066357)
I can tell you that teachers don't make six figures and above.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by enraged_camel on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:27AM (#11066389)
You are assuming that those professionals choose to remain a part of the workforce due to their high income.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by pc86 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @11:29AM (#11066408)
No he's not. He's assuming that losing a large percentage of that income would be enough impetus to leave it.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by dragonwriter on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @12:30PM (#11067000)
Those are equivalent assumptions, so there doesn't seem to actually be an argument here.
Re:Bernie Sanders’s Tax Plan Would Test an Economic Hypothesis by pc86 on Tuesday February 09, 2016 @01:15PM (#11067371)
They're not at all equivalent.

"I want to retire but I'm not going to because I am not willing to lower my standard of living to match what I will earn in retirement."

vs.

"My effective tax rate has increased and I can no longer afford my standard of living. I might as well retire now instead of in 5 years."