News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by rdtsc on Friday February 05, 2010 @11:04PM (#1105714)
It is interesting the approach taken in US vs Europe. Europe is taking more of precautionary approach, they are at least doing more research, they seem more skeptical. In US worrying about cellphone radiation is considered "conspiratorial" for some reason. Are these flak groups sponsored by large wireless telecom carriers?

I observed the same thing in regard to food and additives. FDA seems to need strong irrefutable proof of toxicity before they would ban an additive, Europeans seem to take more of a precautionary approach -- if the additive is thought to be harmful, they will be banned. Is it just me or have others noticed the same?

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by RK on Saturday February 06, 2010 @01:15AM (#1105887)
I'm not sure that's really a general difference in approaches. After Canada banned BPA in baby bottles, people started going crazy about it in the US, and eventually the FDA decided to change its stance. Meanwhile in Europe, nearly all countries concluded no further research was necessary and that BPA was fine.

My European friends that I asked about this claimed that it was because "European governments are much more easily influenced by companies". Not the response I was expecting.

If you read the section on government regulations in the Wikipedia article on BPA, you'll get an interesting perspective on one issue, at least in terms of precautionary principle vs. safe till proven otherwise.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by sailormoon on Friday February 05, 2010 @11:59PM (#1105805)
* In US worrying about cellphone radiation is considered "conspiratorial" for some reason.*

Indeed, as demonstrated by the majority of responses to this article. Surprising, at least to me.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by CamperBob on Saturday February 06, 2010 @04:32PM (#1106707)
It shouldn't be surprising if you understand a bit of basic logic. No one can prove a negative, yet this is exactly what the so-called "precautionary principle" demands of us.

I can't prove that cell phone radiation is always harmless to all respects of human health under all conditions, and you can't prove that there's not an invisible teapot in orbit around Neptune. Instead, the burden of proof must lie with the party making the positive assertion.

It would be very obvious by now if handheld radio transceivers caused cancer. The physics say it won't happen, and so does the epidemiology. Case closed for now, worry about something else.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by rdtsc on Saturday February 06, 2010 @08:27PM (#1107050)
What is lacking is long term studies. That is essentially what the doctor in the article notices.

The same is true for food additives. How many companies do you think conduct 20 year long studies on chemicals that mimic hormones? Pumping rabbits and mice with massive dosages might not be the same as a long term exposure to very small doses.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by CamperBob on Saturday February 06, 2010 @08:32PM (#1107058)
We're all "long term studies." Where's the brain-cancer epidemic? People who smoke are more likely to get lung cancer, an otherwise rare disease. So if everybody started smoking, we'd see a large spike in lung-cancer cases. However, we have not seen a large spike in brain-cancer cases across all populations who started using cell phones en masse in the 1990s.

So exactly what problem is being addressed here, besides poor high-school physics education?

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by sailormoon on Sunday February 07, 2010 @12:19PM (#1107903)
The physics say it won't happen

Does it? That's a very strong statement. We are still very ignorant of the subtle workings of the body.

There have been numerous studies and as I see it the jury is still out. Mobile phones have only really been in common use for a decade; that's less time than it takes for eg. lung cancer to develop. I'm not "worried" as such, but I'm certainly open to new data, and think it's rather too soon to declare absolute victory to one side or the other.

Anyway I wasn't trying to say this study is right or wrong or anything really. I was just commenting on the instantly dismissive attitude of many of the responders to this article. I think such dismissiveness is unwarranted.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by CamperBob on Sunday February 07, 2010 @04:51PM (#1108342)
We are still very ignorant of the subtle workings of the body.

Not at the atomic level, we're not. Photon interactions work the same way in your brain as they do anywhere else.

Re:Warning - cell phones and WIFI - not so safe by sailormoon on Wednesday February 10, 2010 @03:37AM (#1114489)
I don't know what definition of "photon" you are using but I don't think it is appropriate to describe the effects of microwave radiation, which occurs at very different wavelengths as visible light, which "photon" traditionally refers to.

EM radiation at ~microwave levels has well-known effects, it's true, such as protein denaturing and other localised internal heating. The effect of randomly, and perhaps partially, denaturing proteins over long periods of time in important parts of your body is rather ill-studied, I would have thought.