News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hoverboard fires by Animats on Monday February 08, 2016 @12:32AM (#11056500)
Hoverboard fires continue.

Underwriters' Laboratories has now announced 1) that as of Feb 2, they have a test program to certify hoverboards for not catching on fire or blowing up, and 2), all UL labels on hoverboards so far are fake.

Amazon is refusing to pay hoverboard manufacturers for their products, and is taking returns on all hoverboards. The hoverboard industry in Shentzen has collapsed.[1]

There are still daily hoverboard fire news stories.

Good technical analysis is rare so far. However, so far, the following have been reported:

- Fake Samsung batteries

- Batteries without cell-level protective devices

- Battery pack mismatched to charger, causing overcharging.

It takes about seven protective devices to make a lithium-ion battery safe. Some cells come with a small round circuit board at the end of the cell to provide protection and thermal monitoring at the cell level. Some don't. Some cells have overpressure vents. Some don't. Some have thermal fuses. Some don't. Chargers need to follow a charge curve, monitor cell temperature, and have a backup cutoff circuit to stop overcharging. (If you overcharge a LiIon cell, it will catch fire unless some safety device trips first.)

This may be the worst product launch in modern history.

And these things aren't even Internet-connected.

[1] http://qz.com/582542/chinas-makeshift-hoverboard-industry-is...

Re:Hoverboard fires by pjc50 on Monday February 08, 2016 @04:51AM (#11057235)
The hoverboard industry in Shentzen has collapsed.

This is a classic "market for lemons" event. People might say that there is a market for safe electric skateboards, but since consumers have no way of identifying a safe one and all the safety markings are forged, they're not going to buy one at all.

People need to bear this in mind when asking for deregulation in general. Sometimes it's necessary to remove the actively dangerous vendors from a market.

(When life gives you flammable explosive lemons, what would Cave Johnson do?)

Edit: arguably this is already happening in the consumer IoT market. The default assumption is that a product will spy on you, be uninteroperable, insecure, and vulnerable to remote-bricking by the manufacturer. Each individual product has to swim upstream this current of skepticism. Hence the joke about at least the exploding skateboards not being internet-connected.

Re:Hoverboard fires by EliRivers on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:28AM (#11057337)
On a tangentially related subject, I ran into an old chum over the weekend who has spent the last four years living in a major city in China, and he's coming back because he says he just can't trust anything. He can't breath the air, he can't trust the water (even sealed bottled water, having seen enough sealed bottled water that was actually taken straight from the factory tap), recently some people were executed for selling plastic rice (which did exactly what you would expect to the people eating it). Regulation is so necessary. To be fair, he did make it clear that the penalty for fucking with the food supply is death.
Re:Hoverboard fires by pjc50 on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:44AM (#11057389)
Indeed. Public trust is an important shared resouce, and like any other shared resouce vulnerable to people who want to asset-strip it for a profit. People forget that in the West the level of general trust we enjoy is high, took a long time to build, and requires continuous engagement to maintain.

That's why incidents like Flint, MI need to be addressed with a national response, or in a few decades people will be struggling to work out where to get safe water in the US.

Re:Hoverboard fires by Animats on Monday February 08, 2016 @12:28PM (#11059439)
"Arguably this is already happening in the consumer IoT market. The default assumption is that a product will spy on you, be uninteroperable, insecure, and vulnerable to remote-bricking by the manufacturer."

Maybe that's why the Internet of Things market isn't taking off. The Nest smoke detector isn't a reliable smoke detector, because it can be disabled remotely. The Samsung Internet-connected refrigerator loses functions because Google changed something and nobody takes responsibility for updating the refrigerator. The home IoT crowd is selling into a market where things are expected to work for 20 years. The startups are totally unprepared for that. (The classic HVAC companies, such as Honeywell, might get it right. The Honeywell Lyric smart thermostat has a 5 year warranty.[1] Nest, 2 years. Honeywell's WiFi enabled thermostat is round. They're not copying Nest. Nest is copying the famous Honeywell Round, from 1953, designed by Henry Dreyfuss.)

[1] http://yourhome.honeywell.com/en/faqs/lyric/lyric-thermostat

Re:Hoverboard fires by dh997 on Monday February 08, 2016 @08:42AM (#11057997)
Even awesome, thoughtful Boosted boards catch on fire now and then. I think even with the beginning of honest alternative transport devices pushing technology to break new ground inevitably results in some teething issues that will get fixed as engineering and safety standards evolve with the benefit of hindsight. The sentiment of condemning an entire catagory of products for cheap knockoffs and slow-moving regulators is wrongheaded and dumb.

(If there were blanket bans for use, as opposed to sale, I wouldnt be suprised to see mobility device exceptions... But so far the much hooplahed NYC hoverboard ban never materialized on the street level.)

Re:Hoverboard fires by Animats on Monday February 08, 2016 @01:59PM (#11060114)
"Boosted" brand powered skateboards use lithium-iron-phosphate batteries, which are inherently safer than ordinary lithium-ion batteries. The LiFePO4 chemistry doesn't have the thermal runaway problem. That was a good decision. They give up some range, but don't have fires.

Thermal runaway in LiCoO2 cells is the cause of most battery fires. Overcharging or cell overheating starts a chemical reaction that raises the temperature, which accelerates the reaction further. This continues until the battery catches fire or explodes. In battery packs, this can cascade, with one cell forcing adjacent cells into thermal runaway.

There are other safer battery technologies. The A123 Systems cells[1] don't have the thermal runaway problem and are supposedly resistant to fires due to physical damage. They pass the "nail test", where a nail is driven through the battery. Price is about 2x low-end cells from China. A hoverboard powered with those should not catch fire.

A problem with "Boosted" skateboards is that they can easily be taken over via the Bluetooth link.[2] Worse, they support over the air firmware updates. Unsigned over the air updates. There's an exploit for this, called FacePlant.

[1] http://www.a123systems.com/lifepo4-battery-cell.htm [2] http://www.wired.com/2015/08/hackers-can-seize-control-of-el...

Re:Hoverboard fires by masklinn on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:24AM (#11057327)
> When life gives you flammable explosive lemons, what would Cave Johnson do?

Well considering combustible lemons are readily available he'd fire his engineers and skip straight to "burn life's house down".

Re:Hoverboard fires by chris_wot on Monday February 08, 2016 @04:54AM (#11057242)
Make explosive lemonade of course!
Re:Hoverboard fires by kyledrake on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:29AM (#11057338)
"Chinese companies that helped fuel the global hoverboard craze are unraveling rapidly, after Western retailers like Amazon demanded new safety and legality standards earlier this month. Some are so upset by Amazon’s actions they plan to protest outside Amazon’s Guangzhou office later today (Dec. 29)."

Unbelievable.

Re:Hoverboard fires by anc84 on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:03AM (#11057258)
> And these things aren't even Internet-connected.

Thanks for adding a huge round of neurotic laughter to my monday morning! :)

Re:Hoverboard fires by developer2 on Monday February 08, 2016 @05:35AM (#11057360)
There's also the matter that a huge number of hoverboard sales are fraudulent with stolen credit cards. Add this to safety issues, and they're just not worth sticking your neck out to sell them.