News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High by coldtea on Sunday February 07, 2016 @08:33PM (#11055954)
>While the article seems to criticize rent-seeking behavior only in businesses and professions that require lower levels of education, if we combine this article's statements with the often repeated claim that the US pays roughly twice as much for health care per capita as other developed countries it seems reasonable to ask: Is there a rent seeking problem in the medical and dental fields too?

Western countries with same or even stricter bars to become a doctor/dentist etc manage to have 1/3 to 1/10 the prices the US has.

So I don't think it's "rent seeking" that's responsible for this. I'd put the blame more on insurance companies and the bizarro US ideas about employment insurance and healthcare.

Nor I think "occupational licensing" for e.g. cabs which can be considered rent-seeking is the same as requiring higher levels of education from doctors, lawyers and such things.

Re:The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High by rogerbinns on Sunday February 07, 2016 @09:40PM (#11056116)
> So I don't think it's "rent seeking" that's responsible for this.

It isn't entirely responsible, just as no other factor is entirely responsible. But they sure do reinforce each other. For example rent seeking by the AMA means that doctors cost more. Because doctors cost more, more people who need doctor services will need a payment obfuscation service (aka "health insurance"). Because "health insurance" is doing a lot of the paying, it encourages other parties (eg medicine and equipment) to rent seek against them, as it is easier to convince one party than every patient. I'll stop here, but can keep going!

Re:The Rent-Seeking Is Too Damn High by bzbarsky on Sunday February 07, 2016 @11:53PM (#11056398)
> So I don't think it's "rent seeking" that's responsible for this.

It totally is.

The AMA get to accredit, or not, medical schools. They also get to set rules for doctors with non-US training to be able to practice in the US.

The result is that the number of medical school slots has historically not remotely kept pace with population growth, while doctors from other countries face a pretty uphill battle unless they go to medical school in the US. The net result is artificial limits on the number of doctors who graduate from medical school.

This has several effects, of which the most important are the insane hours demanded from medical residents (and all the errors they make as a result) and the high pay of doctors. This last provides the incentive for the AMA to not increase the number of available medical school slots and leads to the observed differences in the income doctors get in the US and elsewhere.

Of course, in the wake of new rules to limit the insanity of medical resident hours the number of medical school slots in the US went up by 30% or so in the last 6 years. We'll see what that does to salaries going forward, but I'm pretty sure the effect will be downward salary pressure.