News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by andrepd on Sunday February 07, 2016 @12:23AM (#11051744)
Everyone who played MMOs talks with utmost fondness of their unforgettable time in their first MMO. Be it Everquest, Ultima Online, Runescape or WoW, it seems no other genre in video gaming elicits such fondness, or reaches immersion levels so deep as the MMORPG. The immense potential in having a virtual, persistent world inhabited by tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands or even millions of people, with the virtually inexhaustible possibilities of gameplay that arise from people inhabiting a shared, persistent world, make the MMORPG the king in this department: immersion and fan dedication.

Yet it seems that this doesn't happen anymore, that the cosy world of Ultima Online or Runescape 2006ish doesn't exist anymore. MMORPGs have found it more profitable to engage in a variety of design choices that, ultimately, destroyed what MMOs were about. The open endedness of Ultima Online, the thoughtfulness and deep worldbuilding of quests in Everquest, the charming aesthetics that left just the right amount to imagination, just like a book, of Runescape, all that was replaced by high action, cheap thrills, and a lot of shiny particle effects everywhere (and of course microtransactions, because why not). The charming, cosy, vast, deep world people remember from Vanilla WoW doesn't exist anymore. Now you got a conveyor belt to level cap and cheap end-game content.

For anyone interested, this is one of the most insightful videos I've seen lately, and it addresses this issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nvK8fua6O64

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by pvg on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:03AM (#11051873)
I think your first point might be a much more important one than the one argued in the video you link. The first MMORPG experience is about as much fun as you can reasonably have in a video game but a great deal of the fun comes from it being first: the lack of familiarity, the unexpected, the 'emergent gameplay', the interactions with everyone from befuddled strangers to helpful friends.

Once WoW got everyone who was ever likely to try an MMORPG to actually try one, MMORPGs reached 'peak players'. There is (statistically) no-one left for whom any MMORPG is a first one and no amount of 'sandbox' or anything else can change that.

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by kedean on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:39AM (#11051946)
That's not entirely true. The new players who haven't experienced an MMO are children, obviously.

Unfortunately for would-be MMO's, the modern world has Minecraft. Unlike most MMO's, Minecraft fully appeals to the minds of the young children who would one day become new MMO players. Personally, I believe that this prevents those kids from ever having a 'first MMO' kind of experience, because none of it will really be "new" since they grew up with it. It's not novel to anyone anymore.

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by Altay- on Sunday February 07, 2016 @05:15AM (#11052407)
While nothing will compare to the 'first time', the bewilderment need not diminish to zero.

Ultima Online was my first and still favorite MMORPG back in the late 1990s/early 2000s but when I tried EverQuest for the first, the 3D world and depth of races/characters/NPCs blew me away.

Then I tried Dark Age of Camelot. The 1-world-but-3-continents/factions concept amazed me. There was always 'the others' and a sense of citizenship with the group of players I could actually interact with. Everyone in UO/EQ was a potential rival/friend. In DAOC I knew where my loyalty lied and the enemy was always clear.

Then I played Ragnarok Online -- my first Korean MMORPG. Again, blown away for totally different reasons. The music, the colors, the sprites, and GIRLS!! Lots of girls played Ragnarok. I didn't meet any girls on UO/EQ/DAOC -- 95% boys, 5% house wives.

Next up was Star Wars Galaxies. No more 'levels', back to skills ala Ultima Online but in a totally different and more complicated way! 3D persistent housing! Crafting! Dancing at the local cantina as a totally legit profession! Multiple PLANETS!! OMG!

Then came World of Warcraft -- nothing I hadn't seen before this time. But it was presented in the most streamlined manner and was the first MAINSTREAM MMORPG. Everyone my age was playing. I felt like the grizzled veteran of the genre/ I knew the mechanics. I taught my friends how to tank. How to heal. How to lead a raid, etc. Again, amazing for totally different reasons.

Sad to say, I haven't felt anything new since WoW. But I honestly don't think its because the genre is played out. Its just we haven't been shown anything different. That might change this year with plenty of promising games in the pipeline -- Shards Online, Albion Online, Camelot Unchained, etc.

If you still think the genre has hope, check out my ~1yr old website, http://mmos.com I hope to see you on my next adventure.

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by SixSigma on Sunday February 07, 2016 @06:23AM (#11052530)
I went EQ, DAOC, SWG beta, EQ2.

I spent a lot of time soloing in EQ2, good times. But then my in game friends all went to WoW and I didn't like the graphics.

I got out of the MMORPG world after that. Kind of rehab. I still think back to it but glad I'm not still doing 6-8 a day!

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by andrepd on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:20PM (#11053973)
I don't think the genre has been exhausted, much to the contrary, I think it has vast amounts of untapped potential! That's exactly what makes it even more painful that almost no more good MMOs have been released since WoW.
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by jghn on Sunday February 07, 2016 @10:09AM (#11053060)
I met, as in in person, many girls that I "met" playing UO
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by zippoxer on Sunday February 07, 2016 @07:38AM (#11052657)
Hey Omer?

I used to watch your channel (previously MMOHut) a few years back. This was my favorite ;-)

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by Altay- on Sunday February 07, 2016 @11:51AM (#11053512)
This is his brother Erhan, but I'll pass on the kind words! Omer is back making first looks on the new MMOS.com YouTube Channel, check it out!
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by SixSigma on Sunday February 07, 2016 @06:19AM (#11052527)
I still spend time remembering the times I had in Everquest, a few screengrabs I still have [1]. A game where dying had real consequences, sometimes very bad.

We were playing on dial-up, my friend regularly clocked up $500 of call charges a month. We called it Evercrack for a reason.

[1] http://www.proweb.co.uk/~matt/everquest/cmunthen/

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by andrepd on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:24PM (#11053990)
You have no idea how charming those screengrabs are :O
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by SixSigma on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:38PM (#11054061)
It is amusing to thing how real it all seemed when looking at those blocky things.

For a while I played with 3D shutter glasses but the HUD was 2d overlayed so it was only for the enjoyment of the effect.

We played with such wonder, and we were 20 years old. The EQ world was so hostile, a mechanic that I won't think will be repeated.

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by sergiotapia on Sunday February 07, 2016 @11:39AM (#11053439)
Money money money money money.

Everything is about turning 1 cent into 20 cents, these days. Gone are the days where a game was fun first and foremost. Now it's about who can squeeze the most money out of their playerbase.

One game I've been playing that did rekindle that feeling of good ol MMO fun is http://projectgorgon.com/.

Fully skill based, exploration focused and -zero- hand holding.

Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by andrepd on Sunday February 07, 2016 @01:21PM (#11053978)
Exactly. That's what happens when your game isn't being lovingly crafted by (e.g) Richard Garriott and his pals, and is instead a product on a treadmill to maximise profit.
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by pgodzin on Sunday February 07, 2016 @03:57AM (#11052234)
In my generation Runescape and Maple Story were the most popular by far. Anyone know how Maple Story has turned out?
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by douche on Sunday February 07, 2016 @09:17AM (#11052892)
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by golergka on Sunday February 07, 2016 @04:48AM (#11052339)
Eve Online though.
Re:'RuneScape' Can't Escape 2007 by cjslep on Sunday February 07, 2016 @05:28AM (#11052429)
Exactly what I was going to say. My first MMO and an awful experience.