News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @02:44PM (#1104584)
> Apple didn't set out to create a tablet as other companies had in the past, the same way they didn't set out to create a phone the same way every other company had in the past. They set out to fundamentally change the way we interact with our computers.

Most 'smartphone' prior to the iPhone did much the same thing, they just failed at it. Please don't act like Apple is the lone-wolf when it comes to 'trying new things.' They are just good at creating successful new things.

> Apple didn't set out to create a tablet as other companies had in the past

This part irks me most. Apple just created a larger iPhone. That's it. Sure they added features like iWork, but things like iWork just didn't make sense on the smaller form-factor of the iPhone. That's it. Sure they had a different approach to the problem (making a larger iPhone rather than making a smaller touchscreen desktop/laptop), but it's not like they created a new experience with the iPad. The iPad is just the iPhone experience with a larger screen and some extra apps.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by masterj on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:29PM (#1104721)
>This part irks me most. Apple just created a larger iPhone. That's it. Sure they added features like iWork, but things like iWork just didn't make sense on the smaller form-factor of the iPhone. That's it. Sure they had a different approach to the problem (making a larger iPhone rather than making a smaller touchscreen desktop/laptop), but it's not like they created a new experience with the iPad. The iPad is just the iPhone experience with a larger screen and some extra apps.

I think you're getting it, but then skipping right over it. The change in form factor is the point. You can do things with the UI using the additional screen size on the iPad that wouldn't make any sense in the iPhone. They want to iPad to be the right form to browse the web, watch videos, consume content, etc.

A netbook is the same as a laptop, just scaled down. But that change in form factor is enough to make them frustrating to use, leading to initiatives like Ubuntu netbook remix, in an attempt to make sense of the change.

Whether scaling the iPhone up makes more sense from the human perspective than scaling the laptop down remains to be seen, but I'm hopeful and interested.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by protomyth on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:00PM (#1104633)
> This part irks me most. Apple just created a larger iPhone.

Actually, this meme is irking me. Look at the interface on the iPad, it is not just a big iPhone interface. It has its own unique elements that allow it to work. There is real thought going into this.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by masterj on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:58PM (#1104831)
>The iPad is just the iPhone experience with a larger screen and some extra apps.

I think this will be important. It's an enrichment of the iPhone experience instead of a denigration of the laptop experience. A user comes to it familiar with an iPhone and finds it faster, more useful, etc. A user comes to a netbook and feels cramped because it's worse than what it's imitating.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @07:50PM (#1105407)
On the other hand, what about someone that goes from a laptop/desktop to an iPad without the iPhone step?
Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by masterj on Friday February 05, 2010 @08:08PM (#1105445)
It's not the step I'm referring to really, so much as the expectations of the form factor. I've never had a smart phone, but I don't think I would sit down and try to do what I do on a laptop with it. However, were I to buy a netbook, that's exactly what I would do.

It's a small point among many, but from the human perspective I think it will significantly impact their reception to the iPad.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by dagw on Friday February 05, 2010 @03:39PM (#1104754)
Apple just created a larger iPhone.

That 'just' bit is where Apple got it right and everybody else got it wrong. Everybody else started with a successful desktop computer and tried to shrink it to a tablet. Apple started with a successful smartphone and tried to grow it to a tablet. It may seen simple in hindsight, but it is a fundamentally different approach, and the approach which may just make the iPad a success.

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by glhaynes on Friday February 05, 2010 @04:50PM (#1105002)
Yes, and many of the iPad haters (OK, OK -- "skeptics") wanted them to just make a smaller Mac.

iPhone has been incredibly successful and its users are by and large delighted. People who can't stand computers love their iPhones. Why again is it a bad thing to reuse iPhone OS (and extend it in ways that make sense for a larger form-factor device)?

Re:Is the iPad for dumb people? by pyre on Friday February 05, 2010 @07:48PM (#1105404)
I'm not saying that it's a bad thing. I'm just saying that it's not like Apple created some whole new experience from the ground up. They had the idea to take the current user experience they had (the iPhone/iPhoneOS) and supplement it (larger screen/iWork), but I feel like people are praising Apple as if they had created something entirely new.

If Apple had created the iPad as something completely orthogonal to both the MacOS and the iPhoneOS yet still managed to make a compelling product, I could see them worthy of heavy praise. Other than that the iPad is maybe a good idea, an innovative idea even, but not some ground-breaking landmark thing. Maybe I'm completely wrong, but that's the way that I feel (i.e. people are giving Apple the same amount of praise for the iPad now as they would have, had Apple done something even more praise-worthy).