News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by tptacek on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:15PM (#11038944)
It bugs me when people suggest I'm "contrarian", because I do not as a rule arrive at positions by trying to think of the opposite of what the prevailing sentiment on HN will be.

In this case, though: the site is positively littered with things I've said about TPP.

Short summary: I'm ambivalent about TPP, dismissive of the notion that it's a secret conspiracy, and irritated by advocacy writing that suggests it is one. That's about it.

I immediately acknowledge that I have a big blind spot about TPP: I'm an American, and TPP has only a marginal impact on US public policy, but a pretty significant impact on countries in Asia that had policies different from those of the US.

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by the_ancient on Friday February 05, 2016 @05:56AM (#11040682)
>>I'm an American, and TPP has only a marginal impact on US public policy,

That is very short sighted, I'm am an American as well and feel TPP will have long and far reaching impact on Public Policy, While it ratification would only marginaly if at all change any policy currently in place, it will make any reforms to public policy impossible

It would forever ratify the terrible copyright and patent system preventing any reforms to them, that alone I believe should be classified as a major impact on public policy

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by pdkl95 on Thursday February 04, 2016 @10:47PM (#11039267)
> it's a secret conspiracy, and irritated by advocacy writing that suggests it is one.

It's important to realize - and this is true for most topics, not just the TPP - that there isn't much practical difference between a "secret conspiracy" and a "loose collection of parties with similar interests". In casual language, it's easier to say something like

    They [it's always 'they'] planned this! The people pushing the TPP are
    trying to scam us!
when what is really intended might be closer to

    The people in a position that has actual decision-making power or influence
    usually got to that position by using large amounts of money. The sources of
    that money vary, but in any case an attitude is cultivated where money ends
    up as the primary indicator when judging success.

    When considering future policies, people with this type of attitude will
    tend to prefer plans that maximize what they see as "success"m which is 
    any plan that maximizes money, regardless of other effects. Hence concepts
    like the ISDS (both as an idea and it's idiotic implementations) are seen as
    absolutely necessary to "protect investors" (maximize money/success), while
    national sovereignty, health-and-safety regulations, and the possibility of
    laws that require exposing source code are all seen as roadblocks to success.

    Therefor, without any need for conspiracy, plans such as the TPP can gain 
    significant support because it aligns with the priorities of the people in power.
or something like that. Obviously, the latter is harder to say and probably impossible to say as a sound-bite. The former statement - which sounds like it requires a conspiracy - is often used as a shorthand, sometimes for brevity, sometimes because the speaker doesn't know how to articulate the longer variation in detail.

Of course, sometimes people actually intend to make an accusation of conspiracy... and sometimes villainous people actually do get together and make harmful plans.

I suggest that it's useful to assume a charitable interpretation when reading this kind of statement for two reasons: 1) Hanlon's Razor, and 2) often the details don't really matter (an international treaty can be just as damaging regardless of it's origin).

Unfortunately, American politics has always had a certain paranoid style[1].

> TPP has only a marginal impact on US public policy

That may be true in the short term, but it's hard to change treaties and the laws they create once they are enacted. If our position in the world changes in the future, we may find the tools the TPP creates being used against us.

The American Empire is rapidly in decline[2]. While it's hard to say what that means for the political and economic future of the world, it's probably safe to say that at least some of the power that America currently holds will move elsewhere.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paranoid_Style_in_American...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ckjY-FW7-dc

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by tptacek on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:22PM (#11039406)
I feel bad about sniping a small part of a thoughtful comment, but this:

it's hard to change treaties and the laws they create once they are enacted

... is not actually at all true. The laws put in place by treaties (ie: ratified by Congress to enable treaties that they approve) are no harder to override than any other law.

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by slavik81 on Friday February 05, 2016 @04:05AM (#11040373)
Wouldn't that break the terms of the treaty? I presume that breaking the treaty either has a direct penalty or you're just kicked out entirely. If you're kicked out entirely, that changes the trade structure that your economy has adapted to over the time the treaty was in place. You'll face serious opposition from businesses that have grown to depend on those new trade arrangements.

Local laws can be adapted piecemeal, but my understanding is that a treaty like this is all or nothing.

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by tptacek on Friday February 05, 2016 @07:41AM (#11040997)
Yes, it might, but Congress can still do it.
Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by pdkl95 on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:40PM (#11039500)
That's kind of what I was intending with the "laws they create" phrase; I should have phrased that better. My point was more that laws are generally not easy to repeal once they are enacted.

Sure, some are repealed, but it's a lot easier to fix a bad policy before it becomes the status quo. After a policy becomes law, fixing it now has the added hurdle of having to argue against an "incumbent" policy.

Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by kobayashi on Friday February 05, 2016 @04:08AM (#11040384)
Thanks for chiming in, I always value your input, and my disposition is usually in sync with your views. I suppose that I don't actually see you as a contrarian - your views just often run counter to the more popular opinions on HN.
Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by kasey_junk on Thursday February 04, 2016 @10:18PM (#11039178)
That's exactly what an NSA stooge would want us to believe...
Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by pekk on Friday February 05, 2016 @02:10AM (#11040056)
Unfortunately, this being HN, I really can't tell if you are being serious or not.
Re:How the TPP Will Affect You and Your Digital Rights (2015) by tptacek on Friday February 05, 2016 @08:47AM (#11041306)
He is 100% serious.