News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by notliketherest on Thursday February 04, 2016 @06:56PM (#11038269)
Banks are still the gatekeepers of this network. Unless you've negotiated deals with VISA partner banks, these APIs are pretty much useless. Companies like Marqueta on the issuer side and Stripe on the acquirer side have relationships with banks that let them move money from your VISA cards. (And even in ACH land, which is lightyears behind the card companies, SynapsePay for example has a bank partner who provides a license for their charter).

Don't think you're gonna be able to write a script to move money from your credit card to your friend. This is still a tightly controlled network of banks. If you're looking to innovate in the payments space, take a look at Bitcoin and other digital currencies.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by SwellJoe on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:08PM (#11038339)
I don't think I understand. Why would they go to the trouble to launch this API, make claims of being able to process payments, etc. if it is "useless"?
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by spydum on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:28PM (#11038999)
You have no idea of the plethora of CIO/CTO digital transformation initiatives being kicked off at fortune 100s.. Everybody needs an API, even if they serve no purpose. Oh yes, and agile too.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by rezrovs on Friday February 05, 2016 @08:21AM (#11041176)
There are two classes of payments - consumer and business.

This API is designed for business payments. Companies that process tens, if not hundreds of thousands of payments on a monthly basis. Think about the companies that sit behind businesses like Etsy or Uber - they need to take a lot of payments from customers and pay the supplier.

Many of those payment companies are financial institutions themselves who probably already have some kind of connection to programs like Visa.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by us0r on Friday February 05, 2016 @02:27AM (#11040096)
I don't think they launched anything. I think its just shiny new pages. CyberSource has been around since 1994.

It's not useless if you have a merchant account.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by Everhusk on Thursday February 04, 2016 @08:08PM (#11038662)
Bitcoin has major scaling problems and is very likely going to fail to deliver on your last sentence. As much as I don't want it to be true, it's more likely that banks will control the blockchain with something like R3.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by bduerst on Thursday February 04, 2016 @08:46PM (#11038821)
Or how something deflationary that can't handle refunds is supposed to innovate payments.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by belovedeagle on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:09PM (#11038918)
> that can't handle refunds

Please stop spreading this idiotic nonsense. Bitcoin, for all its faults, can handle refunds just fine. It just requires a different model than CCs do. You might as well say "cash can't handle refunds"...

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by abalone on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:43PM (#11039057)
They mean Bitcoin can't guarantee refunds if you are ripped off by the seller. Which, of course, neither can cash. Which is why Visa's generally a better way to pay when you don't completely trust the seller (or even when you do).
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by WatchDog on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:57PM (#11039103)
You can utilize bitcoin escrow services.

Taking a look at the first service I found [1], the fees, the friction and the short period you can claim a refund within, make it seem like quite an inferior experience to using a credit card.

[1] http://safepaybtc.com/

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by abalone on Friday February 05, 2016 @03:07AM (#11040214)
Exactly. Escrow charges you 1.5%. Many credit cards pay you 1.5%. And they protect you for upwards of 90 days post-purchase, for free.

It's free because it's built around agreements with a central authority that can delegate the power to police and reverse transactions. The whole point of Bitcoin is there's no central authority. So you have to layer on top of that much more expensive protection services, as you would with cash transactions.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by rajacombinator on Friday February 05, 2016 @05:12AM (#11040557)
If it exists, you pay for it one way or another. In the case of credit cards the cost is just obfuscated in the form of higher final prices.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by abalone on Friday February 05, 2016 @05:52PM (#11045282)
No. It is vastly less expensive to have a central authority reverse a transaction by flipping some bits vs. guaranteeing it via escrow or insurance.

Additionally the oft-repeated claim that credit card fees lead to higher prices has two problems:

1. When Australia regulated away CC fees, prices did not decline.

2. In the U.S., which has higher interchange rates, most of that is refunded back to the consumer via reward programs (1-2% cashback).

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by bduerst on Thursday February 04, 2016 @10:10PM (#11039148)
Except when you need to do a charge back because the good is defective after the first day.

Again, multisig escrow isn't new or innovative, and payments have evolved since then. Houses and shipping containers are as good at refunds as Bitcoin because they also use escrow - except their physical nature makes it harder to do infernational scams than with Bitcoin.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by bduerst on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:20PM (#11038971)
You're right, it requires a multisig escrow scheme which isn't new, unique to Bitcoin, and not innovative to payments, which is the context of this discussion.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by ChemicalWarfare on Friday February 05, 2016 @01:04AM (#11039824)
Bitcoin handles refunds just fine. There are no chargebacks which is theoretically a selling point for the merchant among with lower tx fees but the refunds are trivial.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by vonklaus on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:35PM (#11039475)
Things evolve in weird ways, bitcoin doesn't have a perfect way to do refunds, but it does have the ability to do escrow and to be built into contracts. It could be interesting to disallow refunds generally but be explicit in how contracts and purchases are structured so that a transaction is binding after both parties agree and confirm as much to a 3rd party escrow agent.

Credit cards, much like HTML, were a good idea built on a preceding ideas looking at the problem they were solving. So while credit cards have evolved, the now appear most similar to the Diner's club implementation popularized in the mid 50s[0]

KAZ NEJATIAN did an interesting interview in a YC podcast about his company Kash. He talks about how credit cards work on an antiquated system that, in 90% of transactions (his words) don't use anymore than the expiration date and numbers to process and compares defending processing to building a really strong door without walls.

He is neccessarily biased of course, but his explanation of the routing and auth system credit card companies used seems insane, and they aren't even value stores like banks.

Point is, things evolve in different ways and in fact, bitcoins lack of refunds (which may or may not even be true), could in fact be a massive innovation. Especially if it could deal with fraud which one could make a case for being the only valid reason for a refund. Not meeting a future obligation, could in fact be settled in the future by escrow or an insurance product one could create. E.g. I buy a laptop with a 5 year warranty and it breaks in year 4. In this contrived example, an issuer could run a system scan and verify this independently and objectively and release a predetermined payment amount, or go to a 3rd party arbitrator who would verify and release the funds.

[0]http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/credit-cards-his...

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by cissou on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:04PM (#11038312)
well I could definitely create a developer account and get an API key, so it looks like it's a very public API.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by notliketherest on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:06PM (#11038324)
A sandbox != the real world.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by cissou on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:15PM (#11038369)
> Your Account " xxxxxx " has been setup and is currently in TEST status. It must "Go Live" before you can process real credit card payments and receive funds. To complete your registration, please create the following two accounts within 24 hours of receipt of this email, before the links expire.

Still going well. I really think they want it to be as open as possible.

Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by sillysaurus3 on Thursday February 04, 2016 @08:58PM (#11038875)
Please post the final results for us. This is very interesting. Thanks!
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by cissou on Thursday February 04, 2016 @09:20PM (#11038970)
I think this is still not a one-stop shop for all their APIs. I had to create a "normal" CyberSource account, and if I want to use Visa Checkout I have to become an accepted Visa Merchant (not sure what the process is — not sure I want to know). And I don't think I can even usa Visa Direct (they recommend to send an email at contact@ to go live, but I don't have an app to distribute yet, so I can't tell you right now).
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by bryanthompson on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:47PM (#11039523)
Did you get any decent action out of the API? I spent 2 hours tonight poking at it... Pretty certain I'm doing everything correctly, but I'm getting 403's and no usable errors.
Re:VISA Api: The Power of Visa Network Delivered as an API by cissou on Friday February 05, 2016 @07:04PM (#11045702)
Nah I spent all my effort trying to see how long it'd take to production vs. Stripe. My conclusion is that Stripe will be just fine for now...