News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Touche on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:01PM (#11030141)
I don't understand why it exists as a popular sport anyways, it's 5 seconds of action followed by 30 seconds of two guys talking about it. The average football game has 11 minutes of action[1]. Everything but the last ~8 minutes of the 4th quarter is boring. Yet Americans love it. I don't get it.

[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527487042812045750028...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by oldmanjay on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:08PM (#11030198)
You know what else is boring? Comments of the form "I don't understand something, and my ignorance should be compelling"
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by toomuchtodo on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:09PM (#11030213)
To be fair, that's a non-insignificant amount of HN comments. People should come here with far more curiosity and far less arrogance than they do.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Touche on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:11PM (#11030229)
I post comments like that to be educated. Some have already offered explanations, so I'm happy to get your downvote if it means learning something.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by toomuchtodo on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:15PM (#11030272)
Think about your question:

"I don't understand why it exists as a popular sport anyways, it's 5 seconds of action followed by 30 seconds of two guys talking about it. The average football game has 11 minutes of action[1]. Everything but the last ~8 minutes of the 4th quarter is boring. Yet Americans love it. I don't get it."

better framed as a question like such:

"I'm not quite sure I understand the American fascination with football. Can someone provide context?"

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by knorby on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:39AM (#11032565)
Except he did provide context as he cited an article with a genuine criticism. Your suggestion is in all ways a loss of information.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by st3v3r on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:26PM (#11030361)
You did not. You posted that comment to make yourself look smugly superior to others.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by samstave on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:54PM (#11030542)
Thats why I am awesome, because I don't ever make smug comments. You should upvote me for it.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by mikeash on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:10PM (#11030665)
There are better ways to get people to educate you than to be a condescending jerk and waiting for angry responses.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jessaustin on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @07:47PM (#11031156)
This might be related to Cunningham's Law?
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by mikeash on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @11:26PM (#11031973)
It's definitely a similar theme. I think the Law isn't quite right, though. Posting the wrong answer might be the easiest way to get the right answer, but I don't think it's the best, even from a purely selfish view. But maybe that's just me being idealistic.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by pauloday on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:31AM (#11032539)
It's a good way to get the right answer but it's not a very good way to get help.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by aolagers on Thursday February 04, 2016 @07:21AM (#11033505)
> The first layer is the literal meaning of the words: I lack the knowledge and understanding to figure this out. But the second, intended meaning is the opposite: I am such a superior moral being that I cannot even imagine the cognitive errors or moral turpitude that could lead someone to such obviously wrong conclusions. And yet, the third, true meaning is actually more like the first: I lack the empathy, moral imagination or analytical skills to attempt even a basic understanding of the people who disagree with me.

http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-08-12/only-stupid...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by mwfunk on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:09PM (#11030216)
It's best understood as a turn-based strategy game with real-time elements during and between moves.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by PeCaN on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:47PM (#11030506)
It's like Total War but with big dudes, a ball, and a time control.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rhino369 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:03PM (#11031492)
Total war has time control. You obviously never tried the "Run your light calvary around the map until the attacker loses because the clock" trick.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by epoch1970 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:28PM (#11030379)
The social aspect can't be ignored.

Football is typically held up as the quintessential American sport in many regions of the country. Those who don't proclaim their interest or love for it do so at the risk of being seen as outsiders and potentially treated as outcasts.

This starts at a very early age for many Americans due to the close ties between the education systems and football programs. Starting while they're children, those who are capable of playing are often expected to play, and those who aren't capable are expected to participate as fans. This continues through to high school, college, and to the NFL.

Even if the fans don't particularly like the game itself, they often like the social aspect of it, or just pretend to like to to avoid being stigmatized.

Association football (soccer) and cricket play a similar role in other countries. They can be seen as a form of religion, in some sense.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by moheeb on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:41PM (#11030465)
I think you nailed it.

"They can be seen as a form of religion, in some sense."

In my family it was Sunday School with mom and then football with Grandpa and Dad.

Football is kind of like drinking...even if you don't like it at some point it is easier to just pretend and fit in.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ansible on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:35PM (#11030816)
It also has something more fundamental than religion... it is tribalism. Us versus them. You get to be part of the accepted in-group, and get to hate the out-groups. That kind of need is wired deep in people's brains.

Ideally, all this effort would be put towards a more productive end, such as rooting for your local FIRST robotics team.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by adamwong246 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @10:42PM (#11031841)
Have you ever heard of Dunbar's Number? http://www.cracked.com/article_14990_what-monkeysphere.html
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ansible on Thursday February 04, 2016 @02:19PM (#11036426)
I have. You'd think that sports team fanbase membership would not work at the scale it does. But I guess it serves as a means of establishing common ground quickly.

Though, since we're all humans, you'd think we have enough common ground with each other anyway, what with death, taxes, relationship problems, etc.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Thirdegree on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:16PM (#11030705)
And if you do it enough, you might end up liking it anyway.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by lumpypua on Thursday February 04, 2016 @12:05AM (#11032112)
Happened to me. I like drinking and (college) football, especially together, even though I can see the negative utility of both.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by danharaj on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:05PM (#11030173)
There's a lot of strategy between plays. Because the action isn't continuous it has a different flavor from a continuously played game like the other football. It's sort of a hybrid between a real-time game and a turn-based game, which is cool. I think it would be much more interesting if there were more time on the field, but i'm sure the NFL and their advertising partners love all that time that can be filled up with ads.

I dislike the game because the players get horribly injured, either immediately, or decades later. The NFL is a company that makes money by encouraging degenerative brain disease in its employees.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Touche on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:10PM (#11030218)
That doesn't explain the popularity, strategy is invisible to the viewer. Chess is not a popular spectator sport.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jtuente on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:25PM (#11030346)
The strategy is far from invisible to an informed viewer; many viewers are very vocal of their opinions of the topic, too. The reason chess isn't a popular spectator sport has more to do with the fact that all of the moves are very clearly defined, bishop moves at angles; knight moves in L's, and has no correlation to feats of extreme athleticism, the knight can't suddenly move into an unexpected direction.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by danharaj on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:24PM (#11030334)
It's not invisible. i'm not a serious sports fan, but when i'm around them they notice a great deal more detail than i do. a seasoned football fan can identify a play rather quickly. they know the styles and predispositions of their favorite players and coaches very well. they understand how field conditions and the state of the game influence the decisions made. it's rather fun to watch with a knowledgeable friend.

having some sort of depth is required for popularity, even if it is not sufficient. chess is not a popular sport for other reasons, probably the lack of money and the sheer marathon that is a high level game. soccer has been gaining ground in the US because moneyed interests have been pushing the sport and trying to build the franchises for years. the level of investment required for a nationally popular sport is steep. no one's going to put that money into chess any time soon. like all things in our world, capital is often the difference between "is" and "isn't", but other ingredients are also required.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by brandonmenc on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:08PM (#11030648)
> explain the popularity

Besides the hits,

1. The short season

You're always left wanting more.

There's an order of magnitude fewer NFL games compared to the NBA, MLB, or NHL. And it's convenient - you can follow pro football and have most of the year off and, during the season, most of the week off.

2. The action

Yeah, the ball is only in play for a few minutes, but there are 60-70 plays per game - that's a lot of punctuated action compared to the snail's pace of baseball or the constant back and forth of the other sports. And the plays are more likely to be do-or-die drive or game changers than in the other sports. It's way more edge-of-your-seat.

Those two features are somewhat "drug-like," imo.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by flying_kangaroo on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:41PM (#11030846)
> There's an order of magnitude fewer NFL games compared to the NBA, MLB, or NHL

Strongly agree. I've tried many a time to 'get into' baseball, but every day is just way too much. It also tends to increase the importance of each individual game, which (ignoring the quasi-nihilistic "it's just a sport, man") is another reason for the popularity.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:31PM (#11030392)
There's strategy, and in a broadcast (as opposed to attending a live event), there are commentators to explain it to the average viewer. There are also amazingly spectacular plays, which you can appreciate whether or not you understand the strategy.

That doesn't explain why it's more popular than, say, basketball, though...

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jowiar on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:56PM (#11030562)
The problem with basketball as a spectator sport is that the marginal importance of any particular small piece of the game is small, and predictable. There may be awesome feats of athleticism and skill, but they really don't count for a lot, and by the end of the game, you could remove any one (or more) of them and the result of the game would have been the same.

When you think about what makes, say, movies exciting, it's plot twists. And a basketball game has a very high change of having none -- the better team plays a bit better than the lesser team, and at the end of the game, they have a few more points.

For football, baseball, hockey, and soccer, there are far more plot twists.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:15PM (#11030697)
Basketball gets its popularity from the fact that it is really easy for people to play it themselves (every recess in school has a few hoops in use continuously, and every other driveway has a hoop in it or above the garage).
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jowiar on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:26PM (#11030771)
And every city has plenty of public courts. Soccer in the US has always been more of an organized sport and less of a street/pickup sport. It's more "something you haul the suburban kids to" than "toss a couple objects on the ground, call them a goal, and kick the ball at it". Baseball used to be a street sport here, but really isn't anymore (but it is in the Caribbean).
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jimbokun on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:28PM (#11030780)
I actually think the experience of watching basketball, hockey, and soccer are more similar to each other in having fast paced, flowing action.

Football and baseball are more punctuated, stop-start action.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by Touche on Thursday February 04, 2016 @08:30AM (#11033738)
Yeah, I just don't buy it. I don't buy that the typical football fan recognizes adjustments mid-game. I don't buy that they recognize very many different types of defense (probably the blitz and that's it). This minutiae of a game is things that enthusiasts notice but not the typical fan. I think some of the other explanations given, particular in regards to the social aspect, are more likely it.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by matwood on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:44PM (#11031624)
> Chess is not a popular spectator sport.

ESPN made poker entertaining. I wish they would try with Chess. I would watch something with good commentators explaining the game as it unfolded.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by sampo on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:45PM (#11030493)
As someone who recently moved to the US, should I first try to learn about American football, or about baseball?
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by sehr on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:51PM (#11030527)
Definitely football, it's more popular (unless you're in St. Louis).

Baseball games are really fun to watch in person though, more so than football in my opinion. It's just an excuse to drink and shoot the shit while hearing a bat crack every once in a while, always a great night out

Also checkout basketball, especially if you're in the bay.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:09PM (#11030658)
That's why I hear some people say that Wrigley Field is Chicago's largest bar, and it happens to have a game field in the middle of it.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by mixmastamyk on Thursday February 04, 2016 @12:33PM (#11035559)
They must have reasonable prices? Here on the west coast its probably now $15 per shitty light corporate American beer. It was $13 last time I went about 4 years ago.

So, I couldn't imagine going just to have a few beers, in fact more likely to abstain on principle.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by kelnos on Friday February 05, 2016 @12:37AM (#11039729)
Depends on where, I guess. AT&T Park (SF Giants) serves decent beer (Guinness, among other things) for either $11 or $12 (as of last fall). Still highway robbery, but better than $15 for piss water.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by serge2k on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:57PM (#11031673)
I had a good time at the last baseball I went to (company event).

Didn't even see a minute of baseball.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rconti on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:15PM (#11030694)
Where do you live? First of all, we need to get around the inaccurately named regions of the US.

If you live in the midwest (the middle of the country; from top to bottom) or the south (southwest of the country), football without a doubt.

If you live anywhere else, you can pick and choose. To me, baseball is a lot more intellectually stimulating and has a lot more interesting strategy, but the more I learn about football, the more I see how much goes into it as well. I was a rabid baseball fan as a youth, but these days can't be bothered to spend the time required to watch a game (let alone 160 games a season). As such, I'm more of a football fan now-- frankly, there is more action, and there are fewer games per year so it's easier to follow a team.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jimbokun on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:20PM (#11030738)
"If you live in the midwest..."

Unless you live in St. Louis, then it's baseball.

"...or the south (southwest of the country)"

I think you mean the southeast?

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by eitally on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:28PM (#11031578)
I think that statement requires more clarity. There are parts of the SE, like where I live (NC), where basketball is heavily favored over football. Even with the success of the Panthers this year, when it's ACC basketball season that's what people talk about.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by rconti on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @08:42PM (#11031412)
Doof, correct. Planning a SW roadtrip so that's on the tip of my fingers.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by schwap on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @08:00PM (#11031219)
> I think you mean the southeast?

Texas?

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ZanyProgrammer on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:42PM (#11030850)
Ironically, many former football players will never be intellectually stimulated because of CTE.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by realdlee on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:54PM (#11030546)
Start with baseball. Season starts April 3. Football season ends this Sunday with the Super Bowl. You can pick up football in August.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by pandler on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:08PM (#11030655)
Why not try both? The vibe and culture surrounding the two sports are totally different I find. Baseball teams, for instance, play almost every day as opposed to once a week for football. I think at least partially because of that (each game is less consequential), it's more common to casually watch baseball games as opposed to football where it's a proper event and people get really into every game. Depending on where you are, it's probably easier and cheaper to get tickets for a baseball game.

Two totally different sports, really. Buy some tickets to some games and see what tickles your fancy.

If you do go to a baseball game though, I recommend at least once getting bleacher seats (basically equivalent to general entry). That's where the fun happens!

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by jimbokun on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:18PM (#11030718)
Probably football if you're interested in contemporary culture, baseball if you're more interested in U.S. history. Baseball has more history and tradition associated with it, football is currently much more popular.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by adventured on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:52PM (#11031650)
To be fair, the MLB is wildly popular.

73.7 million attendance last year, by far the world's most attended league. There isn't a close second. To pull 30,517 fans per game to 2,417 games is truly astounding.

To put it into context, the MLB is almost as popular as the NBA and NHL combined.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by douche on Thursday February 04, 2016 @05:16AM (#11033022)
NCAA March Madness is coming up - it's probably the most exciting event in basketball, possibly all of US sports. There's always surprises, some team that comes out of nowhere to make a big run, some heavy favorite that goes down in flames, buzzer beaters, human-interest stories, the minor gambling aspect of filling out a bracket in the office pool.

College basketball can also be some of the most entertaining basketball to watch. There's a lot more variation in style and strategy than you typically see in NBA or international ball. As long as you don't get stuck seeing too many Big Ten style grind-it-out defensive slugfests.

It's kind of like the World Cup, with less flopping.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by bavcyc on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:23PM (#11030752)
If you are in a town with soccer (football) then you might follow the local team rather than learn about the other sports.

College sports are also fun to follow.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by uremog on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:02PM (#11030604)
Football. But only if you like sports. If not, just forget it and tell people you don't watch.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by tamana on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @06:23PM (#11030754)
How about neither? Pursue what you enjoy and find meaningful.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by matwood on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:39PM (#11031612)
Football is great for tailgating and then watching on TV. Baseball is fun to go to in the summer and maybe watch on TV when the playoffs are on.
Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by ArkyBeagle on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @08:34PM (#11031377)
Sorry - not gonna stop liking things you don't like :)

Football and baseball are things to which people are inoculated when young. I suppose the same is true of basketball but I'm just not familiar with it beyond attempting to play it in a pickup fashion while in school.

You'd think curling would be boring, but I've watched it a few times and there's a lot going on.

And never mind golf, which I love to watch. It's been compared to watching grass grow. I can't argue.

At least in the college game, there's the issue of "tempo", which has a tactical as well as (I'm sure) a desire to reduce that time between plays. "Tactical" because it puts pressure on the defense to assemble more quickly.

It gets even worse - I like college ball, but the pros look to me like they just run their pattern and stop, where you might find a college quarterback that will improve most of a game.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by serge2k on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @09:55PM (#11031668)
I don't watch normally but I left the seahawks playoff games on in the background while I did other stuff. It's okay.

Watching with other people is pretty good. You chat while the commentators are going on about whatever or they are playing yet another incessant commercial then you watch the play and go back to talking.

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by logfromblammo on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:28PM (#11030376)
Football is what usually happens between the three sets of the marching band concert. It keeps the crowd occupied, even if it is an inferior form of entertainment.~

I also never understood the appeal of professional football games, with no band playing there at all. It feels like the "spectacle" type of gladiatorial games--the re-enactments of the Battle of Wherever, with condemned criminals portraying the Foovians on one side, and slaves portraying the Barrites on the other. But instead of getting killed outright, the participants just get a very mild case of severe brain damage. And instead of non-stop action, they stand around planning their next stratagem, as though it were not essentially "push the other guy away, so our guy can run past him".

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by sehr on Wednesday February 03, 2016 @05:48PM (#11030508)
Marching bands are by far the worst aspect of college & hs football in my opinion, almost more annoying then the music/fake forced chants they play during NBA games.

Some people just enjoy the sport without all the ridiculous fanfare!

Re:Why a city should not build a stadium for an NFL team by logfromblammo on Thursday February 04, 2016 @11:55AM (#11035250)
"De gustibus non est disputandum." ("Everybody has their own opinions." / "There's no accounting for taste.")

Some people enjoy the game. Those who do not enjoy it should not be forced to pay for the stadium. I would even oppose using eminent domain to acquire a contiguous area of land large enough to build one, with the sole possible exception of Green Bay, Wisconsin, where the Packers are very nearly a municipal corporation due to their "ownership" structure (non-voting, non-dividend-paying, restricted-resale stocks don't count as ownership, in my opinion).

Selling the naming rights to the stadium to the highest bidder is just twisting the knife in the back, really.

This article is similar in character to economic retrospectives of cities that hosted Olympics competitions. The IOC always promises an instant boost to prosperity, but that never seems to materialize. I have been to Turner Field (formerly the primary 1996 Olympic stadium), and the surrounding area does not look very boosted (although other parts of Atlanta are admittedly much worse). The stadium is coming down in 2017, as a 20-year-old building is apparently no longer good enough for the Braves to play baseball in it. Their previous home at Atlanta-Fulton Cty Stadium only lasted 30 years.

For reference purposes, Fenway Park and Wrigley Field are both more than 100 years old and still in use. Stadiums in Kansas City, LA, and Anaheim are pentagenarians. Milwaukee County Stadium made it to 50 before the Brewers traded up. Yankee Stadium retired at 85. Tiger Stadium lasted 87 years. Candlestick Park retired at 53. Memorial Stadium (Baltimore, 2nd) lasted 53 years.

From a cursory examination of history, a city is much better off building its own smaller stadium, sized for basketball, hockey, and rock concerts, than one that can only reasonably be filled by MLB baseball, NFL football, Olympic track and field, club soccer (in Europe), and musical superstars. Offering public subsidy to a privately owned single-sport stadium strikes me as brain-damaged beyond all reasonable measure, especially when the sports franchise seeking to build it is currently leasing a publicly-owned facility.