also I took the above quote to mean that epxs wasn't implying that those assertions were to be applied in this case. Nothing in the post implies epxs was referring to this specific example.
My past experience grounded in using HN since it was founded is that with certain hot-button topics (racism, sexism, IQ tests, codes of conduct, &c.) devolve very quickly into threads that are indistinguishable from one another, with people staking out entrenched positions and virtually cutting and pasting their comments from one discussion into another.
The only way to keep a high signal-to-noise ratio is to either kill all posts that touch on hot-button topics, or to be disciplined about staying on-topic about the post being discussed.
The degree to which my, yours, or anybody else’s knee-jerk reactions are based in reality or fantasy is orthogonal to the problem of hot-button topics producing “generic" discussions.
Summary: My opinion is that it’s bad for HN if discussions about posts devolve into generic discussions that are indistinguishable from each other.
A better way to keep a high signal-to-noise ratio is chasing off poor arguments - banning certain topics or tangents from the OP is clumsy moderation.
> The degree to which my, yours, or anybody else’s knee-jerk reactions
exp's post is "a knee jerk reaction", but you aren't judging it invalid? It certainly sounds like you are...
And neither of us would be talking about this one specific company and one specific employee at that company who had one specific problem, and has chosen to accuse the company of discrimination.
This is how “linkbait” works: People are already heavily biased to believe something-or-other, and they charge in and read the post through the lens of whatever they want to believe, and to argue whatever they wanted to argue.
If we don’t actually judge this case and this post by the specific merits of a specific claim by a specific person about a specific circumstance in a specific company, we might as well just spin a wheel every morning, read off whatever hot-button topic comes up, and just start commenting.