News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:16AM (#11001685)
The world economy is dominated by people in governments who believe that printing money, burying it and paying people to dig it up again will increase the amount of trucks built and goods shipped. No amount of failure of this theory will be enough for it to be abandoned, because it has a certain amount of truthiness to it, and it excuses profligate and wasteful behaviour. Both these things are fun and buy votes.

The Baltic dry should be studied in conjunction with other indicators such as yield curves and indications of credit tightness.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by jjoonathan on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:50AM (#11001955)
I don't buy it.

Boom & bust cycles are driven by the fundamental difficulty of quantifying value. Since there is no true value, people base their opinions on those of others (+delay), leading to "inertia," leading to oscillation. The government might exacerbate the oscillations, but the lion's share of responsibility lies with the market. Complaining that the oscillations happen because the market "just isn't free enough" represents a delusion about the qualities of free markets.

As for make-work, it's a compromise that nobody is happy with, but it is a compromise, and that's its value proposition. Some want to let the market clear without intervention by any means necessary, regardless of the social cost, based on (arguably misplaced) faith that this will ultimately make things better. Others think it's ridiculous that periodically attacking the foundation-tier Maslow needs of large swaths of the population is "a feature not a bug," and demand (arguably unsustainable) social policy to fix it. Make-work lies between the "free-market reckoning" and "re-distributional cash grant" extremes and so once the dust of democratic process has settled it's the thing that actually happens even though both sides see it as a poor alternative to their favored solution.

> The Baltic dry should be studied in conjunction with other indicators such as yield curves and indications of credit tightness.

The Baltic dry should be studied in conjunction with the reliable unreliability of the market in general. Since markets are as inherently unavoidable as physics or politics, we cannot simply wish them away. Instead, we should develop social policy to decouple the markets for well-understood core needs-providing infrastructure from the global economy in order to place bounds on the social cost of market corrections, which could then be allowed to happen (otherwise) unimpeded.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:02AM (#11002013)
What you're describing might explain fluctuations, but it's inadequate and incomplete for the business cycle.

Virtually no one, not even Keynesian or other left-economists support make-work. It's mostly an idea favorable to laymen, or often done for more nationalistic rather than economic reasons. FDR was inspired by William Trufant Foster's and Waddill Catchings' policy advice for instance, who had Keynesian-esque underconsumptionist views but did not derive these from any economic theory per se.

Even ardent Keynesians will advocate a more sophisticated proposal of what amounts to government-owned employment agencies that combine private contract procurement with state investment projects, with the intention of having the unemployed serve as buffer stocks of labor to meet some form of output target. But not quite brute make-work.

(Actually the "quantifying value" problem makes no sense. It's not as if there is some objective essence called "value" that people seek. Value is largely denominated in units of currency. I suppose what you're getting at is the importance of monetary policy?)

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by ericd on Saturday January 30, 2016 @12:03PM (#11002606)
My understanding is that FDR's "make-work" policies weren't only that - they were involved in massive infrastructure improvements which paid economic dividends, and building out parks, which provide cheap entertainment for the public. Perhaps there were others that were less useful, though?
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:35PM (#11004329)
FDRs policies included the Hoover dam, a massive productivity boost.

The latest round of stimulus spending included cash for clunkers, lots of money for financial institutions and paybacks to teachers unions and other supporters. That's not a partisan criticism, an administration of the opposite party would have given to their supporters in equal measure.

The rules of startups are about : make something that people want, and don't take money for the sake of it, your better of solving problems out of necessity.

The truth is that, as a theory, the idea works. In practice, it doesn't because it relies on the idea that central planning can work at all, and that lots of productive projects are available but can't get started due to lack of capital and resources. If a dam or bridge makes sense, then build it the moment it makes sense.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by danharaj on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:17AM (#11002081)
> It's not as if there is some objective essence called "value" that people seek.

use-value? you know, people actually using the goods and services they acquire?

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:27AM (#11002133)
But use value cannot be quantified, since utility is not a mathematical scale, but a subjective feeling that varies from person to person and with time as preferences shift or swing. I'm also unaware of how you can explain diverse business cycles throughout history as emanating from it.

Practically every economic theory that has tried to objectively quantify "value", i.e. those of Ricardo, Marx and Sraffa, relies on gigantic and complicated expositions involving leaps of abstraction and mathematical transformation problems that are completely detached from how real-world people actually think about or treat value.

(Indeed, such exercises in value theory aren't so much about determining value as much as trying to work out given theories of income distribution and perceived exploitation.)

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by danharaj on Saturday January 30, 2016 @02:17PM (#11003276)
I don't think our inability to quantify it means it's not objective. It means our mathematics is not advanced enough yet to capture use-value. Use-value is definitely objective as it is determined by nature. A screwdriver is useful because it screws screws.

Use-value is definitely context dependent and agent dependent. This is fine. But we have to acknowledge that the reason why people assign exchange-value to goods is because they have actual use-value: economics describes physical, real world activities.

I can agree that no one has presented a good dynamical theory of use-value. That's sensible: it would require at least a full description of reality, and a deep understanding of nonlinear mathematics. One quibble i have is i don't think Marx tried to establish such a theory: his observations about use-value and exchange-value can be made without a full theory of use-value or a full theory of exchange-value. The relationship between the two can be examined in the abstract and that is Marx's program.

I can still perform calculations with use-value to derive exchange value: why is water worth so little in exchange-value even though it is so vital to life? The marginalist point of view says that the price of water is determined by equilibrium between marginal cost and utility. Why is the marginal utility of water so low?

Well, if we're talking about people drinking water, then it is obvious, isn't it? You only have to drink so much water. When you're not thirsty, water has none of that use-value anymore.

Ignoring the relationship between use-value and exchange-value is... weird. It's replacing the true and difficult reality with a nice fiction amenable to manipulation with our primitive mathematics. Do markets define exchange-value or do they compute exchange-value from the aggregate use-values of everyone participating?

Edit: as for business cycles, i think they are caused by structural flaws in property rights and financial institutions, but if you asked 5 people why the business cycle occurs, you'll get 6 conjectures and 3.5 theories.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @02:44PM (#11003397)
The marginalist conception of value is indeed underwhelming, but it's also a compromise. Determining value through mathematical exercises using hypothetical n-commodity worlds with homogeneous factors and units is at best useful as an exposition for a theory of income distribution (as Sraffa tried to do) in that by assuming a labor or commodity theory of value you can attempt to argue for a rate of exploitation.

Marxian economics has a whole lot of categories that are awkward, like "constant capital" being homogeneous and "variable capital" referencing wages of labor in producing commodities. There's barely any room for disequilibrium effects, complementarity, reserves and so forth. In turn, the organic composition of capital is held to be c/s+v, but empirical evidence on relation between OCC and crisis is scant and the concept of OCC is again completely foreign to uncertainty, disequilibrium and capital structure. It's just a ratio between two questionable taxonomies. Marxian economics has many similar failings as neoclassical economics, but because of its origins as a heterodox critique of Smith, Ricardo and Mill from a particular period, its evolution has been even more confusing.

Marginalism is situated in a means-ends framework, which is the most one can really say about value without introspecting into personal intentions and valuations. It should be underlined that neoclassical production theory (MC=MR) is separate from the subjective theory of value proper, however. Menger, Jevons and Walras all had different takes on it.

It's also worth noting that Marxian conceptions of use and exchange value have little to say about contemporary monetary and financial economies. Marxians still focus too much on issues like falling rate of profit, accumulation and OCC and often miss elephants in the room like financial fragility, or downplay them. It strikes me as archaic.

Whether or not markets compute or define exchange value seems to me like a problem of overaggregation where the contemporary social institution of a "market economy" is conflated with a market in the abstract as a system of mutual exchange, as in Proudhon and others.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:49PM (#11004400)
Boom and bust markets are caused by human infallibility and time lags.

Instead of providing government cover for the cycle, the lesson for businesses should be that they need to prepare for boo and bust. Knowing a truckload of government money will splash down the chute only increases moral hazard for reckless investment.

Your last paragraph sounds like a central planning nightmare. We don't need people in government buildings drawing lines around core needs. People faced with scarce resource allocation will make the choices that are right for themselves. Anything else ends up with tractor and leather shoe 5 year plans which don't match what people want.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by crimsonalucard on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:45AM (#11002220)
>Boom & bust cycles are driven by the fundamental difficulty of quantifying value. Since there is no true value

I disagree with this statement. Although I do agree that it is hard to quantify or even estimate value, all things do have a true intrinsic value relative to the utility they can provide human beings.

Entire empires have been built based on the concept of intrinsic value. Berkshire Hathaway is probably the most famous.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by tootie on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:00AM (#11001808)
No economists believe that ridiculous straw man nor is it relevant to this article.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by bcg1 on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:24AM (#11001888)
"If we discovered that, you know, space aliens were planning to attack and we needed a massive buildup to counter the space alien threat and really inflation and budget deficits took secondary place to that, this slump would be over in 18 months," he said. "And then if we discovered, oops, we made a mistake, there aren't any aliens, we'd be better--"

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/08/15/paul-krugman-fake-a...

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by slv77 on Saturday January 30, 2016 @01:44PM (#11003117)
Except that you are left with a fleet of militarized space craft that provide no economic value and a pile of debt that was used to finance the fleet.

At that point somebody has to pay for that malinvestment through reduced future consumption. Make work projects are not a free lunch. They work by pulling demand from the future into the present via issuance of new debt.

How those costs are allocated in the future are delicate social issues with entrenched interests. In many cases these make work projects are themselves politically palatable ways to socialize losses by transferring bad debt from private balance sheets (households and corporations) to public balance sheets (government).

It could be argued that all economic cycles can be explained through malinvestment and then working through allocating losses.

My concern is that with activist central banks and fiscal policies that prefer to kick the day of reckoning into the future we have created a situation where allocating losses may lead to significant social and military confrontation (i.e. Revolutions and war).

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:58PM (#11004432)
Each round of centrally planned malinvestmemt in make work lowers the flexibility to deal with the next one, at the same time increasing the moral hazard for firms to expect the government to make good their losses. It also tends to create people dependent on governments as a source of livelihood, which robs them of economic agency.

All because a guy who actually didn't study economics waved away the long term structural issues by stating 'in the long run, we are all dead'

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by calibraxis on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:16AM (#11001862)
Many do. Not the sectarian economists hired to develop capitalist theology, but the ones you take seriously when you need to run a real capitalist economy. Here's a lucid explanation:

"If you take an economics course, they’ll teach you, correctly, that if the government spends n dollars to stimulate the economy, it doesn’t really matter what it’s spent on: they can build jet planes, they can bury it in the sand and get people to dig for it, they can build roads and houses, they can do all sorts of things—in terms of stimulating the economy, the economic effects are not all that different.² In fact, it’s perfectly likely that military spending is actually a less efficient stimulus than social spending, for all kinds of reasons. But the problem is, spending for civilian purposes has negative side effects. For one thing, it interferes with managerial prerogatives. The money that’s funneled through the Pentagon system is just a straight gift to the corporate manager, it’s like saying, “I’ll buy anything you produce, and I’ll pay for the research and development, and if you can make any profits, fine.” From the point of view of the corporate manager, that’s optimal. But if the government started producing anything that business might be able to sell directly to the commercial market, then it would be interfering with corporate profit-making. Production of waste—of expensive, useless machinery—is not an interference: nobody else is going to produce B-2 bombers, right? So that’s one point."

— Noam Chomsky, "Understanding Power"

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by michaelt on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:35AM (#11001910)

  they’ll teach you, correctly, that if the government
  spends n dollars to stimulate the economy, it doesn’t
  really matter what it’s spent on
Forgive my ignorance on these matters - I know that if the government pays a work crew the work crew ends up with money in their pockets regardless of what specifically they build; but surely if you pay a work crew to build a useful freeway or a bridge (or a rail system if you prefer) you also get the economic benefits of that freeway, bridge or railway; whereas if you pay the same work crew to dig a useless hole you don't get those economic benefits?
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @05:44PM (#11004162)
The issue is that, by having politicians decide where and when to build the bridge, you don't necessarily end up with the right bridges.

What you wrote is correct, the flaw is you put in the word 'useful'.

If it were just about bridges and railways, it wouldn't be so bad. But lately economic stimulus is used as the fig leaf for all types of whole scale wealth destruction like cash for clunkers, amongst countless other examples.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by calibraxis on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:39AM (#11001926)
Very true! Yet another reason why so many economies are absurd; they do not have properties we'd want an economy to fulfill.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by pbhjpbhj on Saturday January 30, 2016 @11:39AM (#11002507)
Most "economies" are financial systems rather than actual economies.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:59PM (#11004440)
It's a popular idea but not borne out by the truth. In any decent sized (ie, not tax haven) economy, even the most financially distorted economy still produces a lot more real good and services than finance services.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:28AM (#11001894)
Funnily enough Chomsky is implicitly assuming that government spending has a crowding out effect, which is an idea popular with economists who are "hired to develop capitalist theology," as you label them.

But, probably not. Even "social spending" opens up lots of procurement opportunities for the corporate manager. There might be some crowding out in real terms (government having political authority to exclude activity it deems to be an interference), but it'll be offset by the likely benefits of ensuing expansion, corporate welfare grants and workforce mobilization.

The problem with Chomsky here and many others is that they have the causality backwards. They see corporations as evil entities that spontaneously emerged from the ground to usurp the state, when in fact they were explicitly cultivated by states looking for economic growth.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by calibraxis on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:50AM (#11001959)
> "They see corporations as evil entities that spontaneously emerged from the ground to usurp the state"

This is the problem in an HN culture where commenters don't support claims with cites. Chomsky frequently explains that corporations are creations of the state, and they share the same interests to a first approximation. You can find it in the book I referenced, or google for sources.

This comment seems to paint him as a liberal who favors the state (blaming everything on corporations), when of course he's an anarchist who sees both state & its corporate creations as illegitimate top-down power structures.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:09AM (#11002048)
In an interview, he clearly states that he favors maximization of state power in some narrowly defined "short term," and largely believes that the only alternative to a state is anarcho-syndicalism. He's relying on it withering away. [1]

I know full well he isn't a liberal and never implied that he's one (in the modern Galbraith sense). Nonetheless, most analyses by the revolutionary left are definitely slanted towards a picture of painting the issue as being primarily one of corporate hegemony.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PiqPCRtzOBw

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by tootie on Saturday January 30, 2016 @04:57PM (#11003958)
The effect of burying cash in the sand and hiring teachers are pretty much the same? I get what he's saying but it's glib to the point of being meaningless. Government spending doesn't buy just anything. Outlays are specifies by Congress to be done in the most efficient manner they can agree to (I know they suck at it, but that doesn't mean the theory is wrong). Nor is interfering with profitable business a concern when production and employment are shrinking as they do during a recession.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by SixSigma on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:36AM (#11001913)
But building / updating bridges, roads, rail networks, dams, lead water pipes etc. would have the side effect of being useful to the economy once built / updated.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:45PM (#11004378)
This is a critical point. No they are not.

Where I live billions and billions was spent on water infrastructure. No actual improvements in supply were made- no additional catchments were built, because dams == bad. The money was spent in pipelines and a desalination plant that has never - and I mean never - been switched on. It's 5 years old and has never output water, because the cost is too high compared to dam water.

Now I have a 400% increase in water bills but no actual improvement in what I get. That money goes to paying the interest and running costs for that investment. That money goes out of my local economy. That, in aggregate, prevents and extra shop from opening, or causes an existing one to close. Most businesses run in thin margins and diverting cash away on pointless make work lingers long after the supposed boost happens.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by SixSigma on Monday February 01, 2016 @02:06PM (#11014374)
well, obviously they have to be well planned and wise
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @06:38PM (#11004352)
If only that were true!

Besides, it's not economists that matter here. It's talking heads who provide cover for politicians to create massive amounts of malinvestmemt of scarce resources, diverting from possible productive investments and leaving behind the interest payments as a drag on future investment.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by trevelyan on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:16AM (#11002075)
Yup. Lets go back to gold so that when times get tough people can go to the mines and dig it up instead.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by netcan on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:31AM (#11001713)
I absolutely will not defend Keynes or any other idea in economics, inasmuch as they can possibly be implemented in the political process that decide on economic policies.

That said, I do not think this is a case of a bad economist.

Economics theory is theory... theory that attempts to quantify societal behaviour, various cooperation dynamics, measurable output, etc. None of them know how to deal with various problems like "quality" & "technology" even though all economists admit they are pretty important. These theories usually have money playing a central role in some way). Anyway, they're theories about people acting together in big groups economics calls markets.

Political dynamics is another piece of the puzzle. So is every other meme in society. In some place homosexuals are allowed by society. In some places it is banned. Why now? Why not in 1750 or 2235? There are theories about how to quantify and predict here too, but obviously the ability of theories about such things are not up to the task of making consistent predictions.

Asimov's "psychohistory" is a fictional discipline which is basically economics, historical determinism, political science etc. The fictional twist is that these theories can make consistent predictions within very usable margins of error.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by acjohnson55 on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:02AM (#11001816)
The printing money concept is due to the monetarists, not Keynes. Keynes would recommend deficit spending.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by vezzy-fnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:11AM (#11001847)
Monetarism is just a theory of the transmission mechanism going from money supply->price level->output, with some variations. Their policy proposals have been quite diverse.

Keynes himself had differing policy recommendations, as well, but ultimately settled on what he called "socialization of investment" where the state would fill in certain entrepreneurial activities that the private sector is deemed to be lacking, though the specifics were elusive. Contracyclical fiscal policy was actually popularized by Alvin Hansen IIRC, and the more extreme functional finance favored by Post-Keynesians was formulated by Abba P. Lerner.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by fnordfnordfnord on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:49AM (#11001773)
Have a look at what Keynes wrote in 1930. "Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren." http://www.econ.yale.edu/smith/econ116a/keynes1.pdf
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by sbardle on Saturday January 30, 2016 @10:18AM (#11002085)
Central banks are the problem. They have destabalised the global economy by constantly lowering interest rates and creating asset bubbles to promote the illusion of growth. Central bankers are politically appointed in many cases so they have no interest in cooling an economy. It messes up the business cycle and creates the conditions for even bigger booms and busts. Alternative currencies like Bitcoin will rise in popularity and may hold the key to a less manipulated financial system in the longer term - but I fear we will have another financial crisis before the new alternative currencies have gained traction. We shall see...
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by RobertoG on Saturday January 30, 2016 @12:31PM (#11002758)
Central banks and automatic stabilizers are what have avoided a bigger crisis this time.

That doesn't mean that monetary policy is the right solution. The right solution is fiscal policy (government spending) but this is not happening because politics is dominated by crazy ideas about austerity and fiscal balances.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by sbardle on Sunday January 31, 2016 @07:56AM (#11006245)
I'm not so sure. Central banks helped cause the 08 crisis by lowering interest rates after 9/11 and encouraging a housing bubble. Their response to the 08 crisis (bailing out the banks, ultra-low interest rates, QE) may have laid the ground for an even bigger crisis further down the road. All this is good news for alternative currencies IMO.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by Gravityloss on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:43AM (#11001752)
There's is some government spending that has to be done anyway, but can be shifted in time so it's done when there's a recession. Things like bridge rebuilding or warships.

Of course, if you're in recession for 8 years, you start running out of such things.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by acjohnson55 on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:00AM (#11001806)
Funny thing is, there's plenty of rebuilding we could be doing, which would be quite stimulative, but it's politically unpopular because it would involve some tax and spend upfront, which would put a bit of a pinch on people in the middle and upper classes. Ironically, those same people stand to benefit from the lower classes having more discretionary income.
Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by guessthat on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:51AM (#11001777)
What are you suggesting here? Forgoing the building of civilian infrastructure and military assets until a recession is what?

Also, if you have data supporting your hypothesis, I would be very interested to see it.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by brc on Saturday January 30, 2016 @07:01PM (#11004442)
But if something is worth doing, it's worth doing now.

If you had an idea for a great startup, you wouldn't wait for a few years. You'd do it as soon as it was ready.

Re:The Shipping News Suggests Economic Weakness by Gravityloss on Monday February 01, 2016 @09:18AM (#11011830)
Not necessarily. Hypothetical of two alternatives:

1. Do a small renovation to a bridge and it will stay usable for five more years, or

2. Do something more comprehensive (teardown + rebuild), after which you don't have to do anything for 20 years

If there's a temporary high in building costs, it makes sense to do 1. If there's a temporary low, it makes sense to do 2.