If somebody broke into my house and was caught I supposed I could overreact and go into massive debt fortifying it with castle walls, a moat, and alligators.
But I don't think the legal system should side with parties doing damage to themselves just because they don't understand computer networks.
Where did you get the information that the entirety of JSTOR was shut down, even temporarily?
The second statement doesn't in any way follow from the first. There are call kinds of reasons why JSTOR might have decided not to pursue civil litigation. Swartz quite possibly didn't have enough money to make it worthwhile, and it would have been bad publicity. On top of that, given that Swartz was already facing criminal prosecution, there was no need to pursue civil litigation as a deterrent to others.
>Where did you get the information that the entirety of JSTOR was shut down, even temporarily?
http://swartz-report.mit.edu/faq.html ("This activity was in violation of MIT's licensing agreement with JSTOR, and its scale threatened JSTOR's network so profoundly that JSTOR blocked all MIT access for three days in October 2010.") My original post was open to the interpretation that JSTOR shut down everywhere for everyone, which is not the case. But anyway, it's clear that Swartz's activities were significantly disruptive.
What you seem to be missing is that Swartz's actions were a direct challenge to JSTOR's entire business model. The only way that JSTOR can make money out of scanning old journal articles is to charge fees to someone or other for access to those articles. If the entire JSTOR database becomes freely available, then this income stream is cut off. It's worth considering what the effects would have been if Swartz had succeeded in doing what he intended to do, i.e. release JSTOR's entire database of articles. This wasn't merely a prank or a protest. It was something that had the potential to destroy JSTOR entirely. (And JSTOR isn't even evil -- it's a non-profit that does a lot of great work.)
http://about.jstor.org/news/jstor-statement-misuse-incident-...
"The criminal investigation and today’s indictment of Mr. Swartz has been directed by the United States Attorney’s Office. It was the government’s decision whether to prosecute, not JSTOR’s. As noted previously, our interest was in securing the content. Once this was achieved, we had no interest in this becoming an ongoing legal matter."
They genuinely weren't interested in making him an example.
More generally, that fact that JSTOR did not pursue civil action is totally unsurprising given that Swartz was already facing a criminal prosecution, and it tells us very little about what JSTOR did or didn't think about what Swartz did. It's like saying "you must not think that the burglar harmed you by burgling your house because you're not pursuing civil action against him" -- in an instance where the burglar was already facing a criminal prosecution.
If JSTOR had believed Swartz's actions not to be harmful, they clearly would not have blocked JSTOR access from the MIT network. And indeed, Swartz didn't actually succeed in doing JSTOR much harm becuase they successfully stopped him. What you're effectively saying is that being caught before you've succeeded in completing a crime ought to count as a good defense. In other words, if I try to burgle your house and you catch me before I succeed in making off with your stuff, then you can't complain, because after all, I didn't actually get hold of any of your stuff!