News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by SigmundA on Friday January 29, 2016 @02:45PM (#10997947)
Wild tomatoes are small and unpleasant tasting, doesn't that kinda blow the premise?

The modern tomatoes we eat are genetically modified by humans through breeding which we like to call domestication. This genetic modification caused them to be bigger and taste pleasant.

My understanding was there was push to breed them to be uniformly red when ripe but this also caused a mutation to make them more bland, this occurred in the 1940's before "modern" genetic engineering, which incidentally no tomatoes currently on the market are engineered that I am aware of.

I always think it ironic to blame modern techniques like genetic engineering for all sorts of issues like somehow a cow, chicken, pig, tomato, corn or wheat are somehow "natural", these are all genetically modified organisms that would not exist without human tampering.

We have twisted nature for thousands of years to have higher yields and more desirable characteristics, if tomatoes are bland I would imagine we will twist them some more to make them flavorful again if the market demands it, but their "natural" "wild" cousins have never been tasty.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by noam87 on Friday January 29, 2016 @04:02PM (#10998470)
It's a shame that so many people fall for the trope of the anti-science hippie when it comes to criticism of modern farming.

Believe it or not, most of us who criticize industrialized farming techniques are not tinfoil-hat antivaxers, and understand very well what you describe. Thing is, there's no reason why modern techniques can't be used to produce foods that are more varied, nutritious and flavourful.

Instead we're getting bland produce, all the same two or three varieties, and increasingly devoid of any nutritional value because our backwards practices are destroying the very soil we use (http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/soil-depletion-and...).

It's like in terms of food, we're moving towards an "everybody wears a silver onesie" future... scientific progress doesn't have to mean monotony.

In fact it's not progress. It's laziness on an industrial scale, and it's costing us our health (and one of life's greatest pleasures: food with real friggen flavour). So many of us have never tasted a real vegetable or piece of meat. (Ironically, in poorer, less industrialized countries like in South America, the meat is absolutely delicious -- visited last year with some friends; it was like they had never tasted meat before. Then I realised... they really hadn't!)

For a glimpse into what is possible using modern techniques, while still embracing flavour and variety, I highly recommend the Chef's Table episode on Stone Barns Center for Food & Agriculture.

I believe it's the second episode of the first season (available on NetFlix right now... the whole series is worth watching really).

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by cylinder on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:26PM (#10999367)
Americans have bland palates so the producers get a way with this. In other countries, people wouldn't buy the tasteless tomato.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by maerF0x0 on Friday January 29, 2016 @05:16PM (#10998961)
Its no surprise, most people pay by the lb. If there was some way to price by nutrition maybe people would optimize that way. Eg: 20c per 1000mg Vit C .
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by tiglionabbit on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:35PM (#10999424)
Some words and standards can indicate quality. "Pasture Eggs" for example, are more expensive but also a better product. Also, going to a farmer's market and buying from producers directly instead of a supermarket is one way to shop for quality.

I wouldn't want to use nutritionism as the definition of quality, because so far nutritionism has been too reductionist to capture the full picture. There's a wide variety of micronutrients that turn out to be useful, but are easily depleted from the soil in a monoculture. Are you getting your Vitamin K12? Selenium? Zinc? Copper? Choline? Are the animals you eat getting theirs?

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by maerF0x0 on Monday February 01, 2016 @03:40PM (#11015223)
While I agree with the idea that nutritionism is reductionist of complex systems, I see price per nutrition to be an improved model over price per lb. Maybe once upon a time price per lb made sense because not everyone could get enough lbs. But now we can get plenty of lbs, but not everyone can get enough nutrition.

On the nutritionism note, I also think we'll increasingly improve the model to a point where something like Soylent v315 will actually be superior nutritionally to any complex diet that a human could eat. Right now its so simple that you can do better with a chicken salad, but someday soylent may encompass phytonutrients, chemical supplements, nanorobots, pre/probiotics, factors based on your genetics, medicines prescribed etc etc... IMO the complexity of nutrition will eventually outstrip the typical human's ability (or will) to eat very complex "meals".

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by eli_gottlieb on Saturday January 30, 2016 @09:10AM (#11001842)
In Israel we would mostly get tomatoes or peppers that were considered too misshapen to export, but holy God they were freaking delicious. The heavily vegetable-based diet over there makes perfect sense when you consider how their vegetables contain actual flavor and nutrition.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by jrochkind1 on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:17PM (#10998157)
I don't blame the techniques, I blame how we've chosen to use them.

If we chose to use modern techniques to make tomatoes as delicious and nutricious as possible, I have no doubt we'd have some damn delicious and damn nutritious (both at once!) tomatoes.

But they wouldn't ship or store well and wouldn't have as high a yield, so they'd be more expensive, at least under the current production and distribution economy.

So we've chosen to use those modern techniques to make tomatoes that store well, ship well, have a high yield, taste like crap, and have fewer nutrients.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by semi-extrinsic on Friday January 29, 2016 @04:10PM (#10998525)
One word (well, 5): hermetic, peeled San Marzano tomatoes.

Sure, they aren't fresh tomatoes. But they're super tasty, nutritious, store and ship well, and they're fairly cheap to boot. Try making a proper bolognese (proper, as in, start with frying up sofritto) using cans of San Marzano... O.M.G.

Conserved vegetables are awesome. Conserving even helps increasing the nutrient value by increasing bioavailability.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by tiglionabbit on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:38PM (#10999435)
It's common knowledge among cooks that canned tomatoes are better than fresh ones.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by jschwartzi on Friday January 29, 2016 @05:44PM (#10999127)
The cool thing about these is they don't have calcium chloride in them so they properly fall apart when you cook them.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by sharkjacobs on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:22PM (#10998200)
Tomatoes in the 1950s were already domesticated. Humans have been growing tomatoes since at least 500BC. Comparing them with wild tomatoes is irrelevant.

Industrial agriculture has brought about a radical increase in food yield over the last century, and there seems to be a corresponding, possibly correlated decrease in the nutrition.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by lutorm on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:09PM (#10998096)
We have twisted nature for thousands of years to have higher yields and more desirable characteristics

Undoubtedly. However, those desirable characteristics were about more than just yield. In industrial agriculture, however, you can't quantify "taste". You can, however, quantify "yield". So it becomes a case of ruthlessly optimizing for what you can measure, to the detriment of other, more subtle, characteristics.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:13PM (#10998133)
You can quantify taste. Not precisely, sure, but taste testers are used in commercial food production.
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by dasil003 on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:03PM (#10999242)
Sure, for flavor engineering, but do they do it for raw produce?

A big part of the problem is that produce is seen as a commodity, and all the economic value is added by using cheap commodity ingredients in a highly tuned industrial process to create the most tasty and addictive food. The incentives are just all misaligned.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday January 30, 2016 @08:06AM (#11001670)
> Sure, for flavor engineering, but do they do it for raw produce?

They do it for QC samples of mass produced food. Perhaps it could be done for raw produce, then?

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by SigmundA on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:26PM (#10998229)
I don't disagree, the lag time for the market to respond to flavor is obviously much higher than something easily measurable like yield. However the solutions seem to revolve around going back to "natural" methods which are anything but, rather than simply making more genetic modifications to get the desired trait or perhaps needing more or different fertilizer.

The option is there to utilize the land less efficiently to get the same effect for some characteristics, but we may have to accept at some point feeding people on a modern scale may not be tenable with what is considered more "natural" or "organic" or whatever term is being used to ambiguously describe the techniques that are not natural at all in the dictionary sense.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by SixSigma on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:35PM (#10998290)
If you grow your own tomatoes they taste amazing.

Also, to get the best sugar content, the thing to do is to leave them on the vine once ready and stop watering them, the stress causes the plant to dump its energy into the fruits.

They will taste better but if done commercially it extends the time to market and reduces shelf life.

When you grow your own vegetables you realise how low quality most of the ones in the supermarket are. And what a restricted set of choices there is.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by mirekrusin on Friday January 29, 2016 @04:10PM (#10998528)
This is very true, I remember taste of tomatoes grown by my grandpa 15-20 years ago, it's almost a different veggie. Same with strawberries I remember eating from bushes as a kid, didn't taste or look like the ones in the shop.

Cherries on the other hand are pretty good. Maybe because they grow on trees, which have much longer lifetime and therefore are harder to optimize for yield. Also seeing couple of cherry "farms" made me think it's a good idea - instead of pesticides, genetic modifications, in-house cultivation or whatever - they use gigantic mesh to protect them from unwanted animals and I think that's it. I don't know if it's a common practice or just few exceptions I've seen.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by Nihilartikel on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:30PM (#10999398)
I have to voice disagreement on cherries. I grew up near a park with a ready supply of wild cherry trees, which I gorged myself on many a summer - compared to a big Bing cherry they have a really concentrated flavor and a juicer, less firm meat that would bruise pretty easily in shipment. I at least like them much more
Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by krick on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:11PM (#10999282)
You are mixing terms, resulting in pretty cheap rhetoric. If I tame wolves and chose their mating partners — it's breeding. Same with crops. It's not what people call "genetic modification".

If I cherry-pick genes of one organism, attach them to a virus and infect other organisms with that: now that's what is called genetic modification.

I won't argue which is better, it seems like a hot topic for some people. But I can completely understand how somebody is OK with the first one and not so much with the second. It's like a difference between choosing an engineer to construct your house, and making your own modifications to the final construction project. You have to be completely sure you know what you are doing to do the latter. Some people doubt we actually know what we are doing. Sometimes looking back it's hard to blame them.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by SigmundA on Friday January 29, 2016 @08:18PM (#10999970)
Selective breeding is a form of genetic modification by humans, this is not rhetoric but simple fact. Domestic dogs are not wolves and they would not exist without humans having created them. The same goes for basically all edible tomatoes we eat today.

The term Genetically Modified Organism or GMO is thrown around without much thought to it's meaning. Why is selective breeding "natural" and therefore ok? Targeted gene insertion not? What about marker assisted breeding? What about directed mutagenesis? These all lie on a continuum but all are most definitely modifying genes based on human intervention.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by hibikir on Friday January 29, 2016 @06:51PM (#10999508)
And what happens when you irradiate the tomatoes, hoping for the DNA to change in ways that help? Using today's legislation, if the modification happened like that, the result is not considered GMO. That, along with completely random mutation, leave to novel genetics all the time.

So when we do it ourselves, we don't know what we are doing, but when we let randomness perform larger modifications, then we are 100% ok with it, and you can buy the output as certified organic.

If all the plants we ate had tightly controlled genetics, I'd understand the argument, but in practice, the most genetically consistent vegetables you can buy come from big agribusiness.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by collyw on Friday January 29, 2016 @08:13PM (#10999948)
I personally don't see that much difference which is why I challenge anti GM people with the question: why do you see targeted gene mutation as being more dangerous / worse than random gene mutation?

Still waiting for a decent response to that.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by krick on Saturday January 30, 2016 @12:08AM (#11000611)
Again, I don't want to take sides, as this "anti GM"/"pro GM" seems to be ridiculously religious matter in the USA, but since you asked, I guess I can answer.

The difference is, basically, that random mutations happen all the time since life on Earth has begun, they are relatively subtle, and, last, but not the least — unavoidable whether you like the fact that they happen or not. They are pretty close to definition of "normal", because that's just how carbon-based lifeforms (or, probably, any theoretically possible lifeforms at all) work. The result of any individual mutation might be not pleasant: child might be born defective or ugly, but that's… well, "natural". People tend to avoid unusual, so even though some ugly chicken with two peckers and one eye might be completely healthy food — many will think it's disgusting and won't eat it. And, as I said, random mutations cause relatively subtle changes in phenotype, so it would take many, many generations for such chickens to become normal even if we selectively breed them to have two peckers. Even single such mutation is something pretty unlikely without strong external influence, like high radiation or some chemicals. And if specie changes a lot during multiple generations — it becomes normal. If they survived through so many generations, and we still eat them: it somehow "works", one might think.

Genetic engineering, on the other hand, didn't happen for a couple of billions years until last century, is very much avoidable and immensely powerful. Consider making a pig glow through selective breading. Seems pretty unlikely, yeah? Well, it's simple now, if you tinker some with genome of a pig and a jellyfish. And that's just an illustration: possibilities of what you can produce are nearly unlimited. I don't want to quote Spiderman's uncle here, but I guess you get the point. One might not even actually think glowing pig is dangerous, but it's certainly suspicious. Which is more than sufficient reason to beware of something or to want to avoid it.

The best thing about living nature is that something, that can seem completely safe and uninteresting at first, might be a cause for something much bigger than it seemed. Like, you know, bringing a couple of rabbits to Australia[1].

As a side note, you should probably remember when arguing with those "anti GM" friends of yours, that thinking of something as dangerous isn't the only reason why somebody might not like something. Say, they might happen to not like green wallpapers — it doesn't necessarily mean they think green wallpapers are dangerous. They just don't want them, maybe for religious reasons or whatever. So if everyone suddenly starts producing only green wallpapers because it's simply cheaper, and any other colors become rare, ridiculously overpriced and are treated by sellers as a luxury product — they can become "anti-grean-wallpaper" very easily. In attempt to bring balance to the force, if nothing more. Add to that that not everyone is perfectly rational — which is kinda ok as well — and there can be infinite number of reasons why somebody might be anti-something.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbits_in_Australia

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by collyw on Saturday January 30, 2016 @05:49AM (#11001424)
"Consider making a pig glow through selective breading. Seems pretty unlikely, yeah?"

Given enough iterations I am sure it is possible. A pig evolved from bacteria after all.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by ThomPete on Friday January 29, 2016 @05:37PM (#10999085)
This has nothing to do with techniques. This has to do with what those techniques are used to create.

For instance. The difference in taste between a tomato I get in my already overpriced but well stocked supermarket here in NY and the tomato I pick up from a local farmer nearby is night and day.

One of them can litterally stand on it's own the other is bland and tasteless. They cost around the same.

The problem become when optimization get higher priorities than the result of the optimization.

I am well aware that there are many reasons why we don't want 100% organic farming unless we can do it at scale like conventional farming, but currently the difference in taste is night and day and if you care about that then it's a big deal and techniques can be used to fix it.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by fnordfnordfnord on Friday January 29, 2016 @05:51PM (#10999179)
>caused a mutation to make them more bland, this occurred in the 1940's before

Then why do so many people alive today complain about the taste and texture, since most ought not even know what a pre-1940 tomato tastes like?

>I always think it ironic to blame modern techniques

Blame the abuse of selective breeding and genetic modification.

Re:Tale of Tasteless Tomatoes: Why Vegetables Do Not Taste G... by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:12PM (#10998119)
Yeah, we can make plants do whatever we want, we just have had the wrong priorities.