News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by charlesdm on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:03AM (#10995196)
Debt is a lever, in itself it's neither good nor bad.

If I have a $10m net worth, I might want to lend someone $1m for a year on which they will pay me 5% interest per year. If that person can turn that million into one and a half million, what's the problem?

[deleted]
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:41AM (#10995405)
Also see social credit theory for the idea that the value of goods produced by workers is always less than their wages:

http://www.socred.org/

Plus banks have a monopoly on money creation and can create it with zero cost, ramping up land prices and soaking up all productivity gains into land. All the rentier need do is kick back and wait for the state to add value so they can charge more rent. Henry George knew it but it seems today nobody has the faintest idea how money works:

http://www.henrygeorge.org/pcontents.htm

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by laotzu on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:59AM (#10995534)
I am familiar with the credit-theory of money as opposed to the debt-theory which we currently use. David Graeber explains it in Debt: The First 5,000 Years[1], for anyone interested in further reading.

[1] https://libcom.org/files/__Debt__The_First_5_000_Years.pdf

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:09AM (#10995592)
Yeah I've not read that yet, learning french to pass an exam to get Quebec residency so I can escape the hellish UK rentier paradise. Once I've passed I'm hitting those economics books!
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by charlesdm on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:45AM (#10995444)
Doesn't this all depend on how you use that specific debt?

If you use the above example, if I can generate $500k each year using $1m in debt, how is perpetually serving the interest expense on that debt bad then?

Use it well, you can create additional profits. Use it poorly, you'll end up with nothing (or even lose capital).

Maybe you mean that the lever effect shouldn't exist, so that it's a zero sum game?

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by laotzu on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:53AM (#10995493)
While it is a two-way street (both parties "agree"), what I'm saying is that in an honest, straightforward arrangement people should not be contractually obligated to run in the rat race their whole lives trying to pay off a debt that by design can never be paid off. So yes, a zero sum game sounds quite logical.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by charlesdm on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:10AM (#10995595)
Now you're talking about "consumer" debt. i.e. debt to buy a car / house / student debt / etc. That's bad debt.

If it's not intended to be used for investment, I would personally never use debt.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:24AM (#10995666)
You have no choice other than to enter into the land based debt system. Don't want to borrow for a mortgage? Pay high rent on a place because someone else bought it with a big mortgage.

That is land enclosure.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by roblev on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:00AM (#10995541)
The idea that loans can never be paid back is a myth. I can lend someone money, and have it paid back with interest without more loans being necessary or more money being created.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by laotzu on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:12AM (#10995606)
Yes, some people will be able to pay off the loan + interest but this anecdote ignores the others that by design cannot. As Hörmann explains, the amount of money in existence + the amount of money that is contracted as being owed is a negative sum.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:28AM (#10995315)
Not when it's only issued by a monopoly.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:46AM (#10995445)
I'm with you on this brother. Keep telling people. Think back to 2006, you hardly saw anyone criticise the system in this way, now I see it all the time. It's coming.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:36AM (#10995373)
Who says only banks can make loans?
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:44AM (#10995433)
That's the thing, they don't loan the money, they create it, banks haven't functioned the way they're popularly imagined to function for centuries. And it's so sad that this false image is the moral basis for banks going after borrowers assets.

The bank doesn't lend you someone else's money, it creates the money(no effort) and you have to work and put up real collateral to pay it back.

By G-d we should all be working to expose and undo this madness.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:56AM (#10995510)
> it creates the money(no effort)

Err, there most certainly is an effort assessing credit risk and dealing with the fallout when someone defaults.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:27AM (#10995687)
What exactly is the risk to the Bank in lending out money they just created?
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:33AM (#10995731)
They didn't magic it out of thin air. It's a liability to them. If the loan is paid into another bank they then have to transfer central bank deposits to that other bank. If the loan is never paid back then they've lost money.

Is it genuinely not obvious to you than bank deposits aren't something that banks can create and destroy on a whim?

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @11:17AM (#10996049)
That's actually not quite correct. The loan itself is an asset to the bank. When you sign the promissory note, they then give you a balance at the bank in the amount of the principal of the note, THAT is the liability.

The loan is the asset because that is money coming into the bank. Your deposits are liabilities because that is money you could withdraw from the bank.

So it is both a liability and an asset. They don't create it out of thin air, they create it out of ink and paper. It's a hack of the double-entry bookkeeping system.

I recommend Paul Grignon's Money As Debt: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqvKjsIxT_8

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @11:32AM (#10996190)
The balance in the bank, which is colloquially called a "loan", is a liability to the bank, yes.

And do you agree there is a "risk to the Bank in lending out money they just created" or is that still up for discussion?

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:15PM (#10997152)
No, the balance in the bank is not the loan. You need some understanding of double-entry bookkeeping to understand fractional reserve banking. The loan(promissory note), is on the banks balance sheet as an asset. Your balance which you can withdraw as cash is on the banks balance sheet as a liability.

What is the bank risking when it creates the money and uses the anachronistically titled "loan" contract to distribute it? • They risk only being able to extract so much labor. • They risk taking on collateral which is a REAL asset that someone worked for, like their home if they're unable to generate enough of the assets the banks just write into existence. • They risk passing the buck up the ladder ultimately to the lender of last result if they're "too big to fail" which just creates more money to deal with the problem.

Banks are not lending out other people's money, everyone tacitly knows this, if they were how come when you go to the bank they never say, sorry its out on loan at the moment? This was the case at historically and banks are still riding on the fact that people haven't gotten wise to the way it's worked for centuries now.

There is no lending taking place when bank loans are made.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @01:23PM (#10997230)
Hmm ... are we still on the same page? This is where the discussion started: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10995433

You seemed to be claiming that a bank incurs no cost ("no effort") to issue a loan. Are you sticking to that?

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by Kinnard on Friday January 29, 2016 @03:37PM (#10998299)
Yes, we're still on the same page. The Banking system is rapacious and it should be done away with. Its capital allocative functions have been subverted by extraction. It's an emergent system so that isn't to imply that the people who work at banks are rapacious. That would be the fallacy of division: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_of_division

It is that bad.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:41AM (#10995411)
Only banks can create money. Bank of England official blog:

http://bankunderground.co.uk/2015/06/30/banks-are-not-interm...

Debt is not a lever it's a stick to beat the landless with in order to extract labour as tribute to the elite.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by charlesdm on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:48AM (#10995463)
Anyone can make loans. However, banks borrow newly created money from the ECB or FED at an extremely low rate. If you borrow money at 2% from a bank then they are getting it at 0.1%. The spread - that 1.9% - is their profit.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by tome on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:59AM (#10995535)
> The spread - that 1.9% - is their profit.

No it's not. There are plenty of costs involved in issuing loans that will eat into that 1.9%.

Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by charlesdm on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:05AM (#10995574)
Well, obviously there are running costs / default risks / etc. I was just pointing out how a small bank works in its simplest form.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by branchless on Friday January 29, 2016 @09:19AM (#10995263)
The problem is when people are seeing all their labour disappear as rent / mortgage to people who are adding no value. This is happening way too much.
Re:Rich dad, poor dad – the story that formed my views on ma... by meapix on Friday January 29, 2016 @10:19AM (#10995645)
The problem is ethics, you just made somebody slave for a year. Now if you're happy with that, that's ok.