There was eventually an acquisition, and I made a nice sum, but I never planned on them being worth anything. It was my first startup; how are so many convinced that these things are some sort of golden ticket? Where does that narrative come from?
I think the issue is that overly optimistic companies (and probably some unscrupulous ones) estimate the likelihood of such an outcome to be greater than it is. But that doesn't mean that's never true (like it sounds like you found out).
I nodded to a lot of your points (although I have personally done well by 1 of the 3 companies to offer me options), but I've never had a boss actively try to push me like that. It's always been encouragement or constructive criticism, but never (potentially) false promises. That just strikes me as so wrong.
I _have_ been told this, multiple times at startups, from people who probably sincerely believed it.
Luckily, I never agreed to a pay cut in favour of options.
If I had 10 dollars for every set of stock options that I've been granted I'd be a hundred-aire by now.
I've lost count of the number of times I've been told, that if I just work really hard right now, I'll be able to retire soon.
Every time I read an article about some employees making big bucks off their stock options or six figures off an iPhone app, I see that for what it is: propaganda designed to make sure we keep feeding our young bodies into the machine.
That machine will grind you up and spit you out like hamburger on the other side.
Life is short as I said, and it seems to go faster the further along you are.
Work as little as you can, and if you must work, try to work for yourself.