News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by Analemma_ on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:14PM (#10977298)
I don't want to sound like the know-it-all smartass here, but from the moment Firefox OS was announced I gave it a negligible probably of amounting to anything and was really baffled that Mozilla decided to focus their efforts in that direction.

I don't think they appreciated just how brutal and unforgiving the smartphone market is. Apple makes money on it, but they spend billions on R&D and billions more on marketing. Samsung makes money, but a lot less than they used to and only because they own their entire component pipeline and also spend billions on marketing. Google makes money, because they own the operating system that 80% of the phones use and use it to push people to their wide array of services. Everyone else is breaking even at best, and hemorrhaging cash at worst. Think how many billions Sony and Microsoft and Nokia and Palm and Blackberry spent on their smartphone efforts only to get shoved to the sidelines. This is a market where you've gotta pay big in order to play; to be honest it was downright silly of Mozilla to expect that they could get a foot in the door.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by benlower on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:31PM (#10977382)
Everything you say here is 100% true. Mozilla believes in the open web and, I'm speculating, they didn't like the direction of closed mobile ecosystems so they had a go and tried a different approach.

I applaud them for trying.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by nnethercote on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:01PM (#10977504)
That's exactly it. Mobile apps are killing the web. Firefox OS was an attempt to combat that. This was no secret (e.g. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Booting_to_the_Web) but it's something that most people have overlooked. It was always going to be a huge challenge.
Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by aikah on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:16PM (#10978170)
> Mobile apps are killing the web.

It's like saying desktop apps are killing the web which is stupid. You need both. Yes you need strong standards and open technologies but a random mobile game or a contact list on my phone isn't the web.

> Firefox OS was an attempt to combat that

It wasn't going to work anyway given the poor performances of Firefox OS. That's what killed it more than anything else. They chose to go for low end devices with web techs ? we all know how web techs perform in general, badly, compared to solutions based on Java, C , C++, Swift and co ... This true on desktop and even more true on limited devices such as phones.

Firefox OS is open source and it's a good think, but aside from open source developers,most buyers don't care about that.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by hackuser on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:07PM (#10978137)
> from the moment Firefox OS was announced I gave it a negligible probably of amounting to anything

Many said the same about Mozilla building a browser to take on Microsoft, with a desktop monopoly and enormous resources, and Internet Explorer with 95% market share. This same comment is heard by every failed tech venture, which includes most startups: "I told you it wouldn't work."

It's a good thing so many people are willing to ignore that advice, also heard by 100% of entrepreneurs starting new ventures. I'm sure others here find it equally familar.

I'm a little surprised to see it receive so many votes on HN.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:31PM (#10977384)
Isn't this basically the same argument as that Debian can't make any inroad into servers because IBM and Microsoft spend untold sums on R&D and marketing?

What has been killing Firefox OS (and nearly everything else Mozilla does outside of Firefox) is their peculiar abhorrence for anybody else writing anything in native code.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by fabrice_d on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:15PM (#10977552)
No, what is making or killing a mobile OS is whether some key apps are available or not. Many people don't really mind using an OS or the other, but they absolutely need eg. WhatsApp. The unwillingness or WhatsApp to write a mobile web app - or to let a 3rd party do it - made more damages to FirefoxOS than anything else writing in the comments so far.
Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:31PM (#10977611)
But that's true of any platform ever. You need third party developers to either target your platform or a platform your platform is compatible with (like the JVM).

Mozilla wants to use the web as that platform exclusively, which is fine if everybody is already making everything for the web and there is nothing of importance you can do with native code that you can't do from the web. But neither of those is true so their strategy fails.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by pcwalton on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:19PM (#10977788)
> Mozilla wants to use the web as that platform exclusively, which is fine if everybody is already making everything for the web and there is nothing of importance you can do with native code that you can't do from the web. But neither of those is true so their strategy fails.

There are things you can do on iOS that you can't do on Android (e.g. Apple Pay), and vice versa (e.g. Google Now). iOS fails the "there is nothing of importance you can do on Android that you can't do on iOS" test, and Android fails the "there is nothing of importance you can do on iOS that you can't do on Android" test. Yet here we are, with two successful platforms.

I think the truth is a lot more nuanced, and in particular I think the emphasis on "native code" is a convenient red herring. (Android isn't really native code for anything but games, and iOS Objective-C is technically native code, but that Smalltalky object system is not up to C++-level performance, so the distinction doesn't mean much.)

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:45PM (#10977869)
> iOS fails the "there is nothing of importance you can do on Android that you can't do on iOS" test, and Android fails the "there is nothing of importance you can do on iOS that you can't do on Android" test. Yet here we are, with two successful platforms.

At which point you have to ask whether the missing things are actually that important.

> I think the truth is a lot more nuanced, and in particular I think the emphasis on "native code" is a convenient red herring.

"Native code" in this context is as distinguished from aggressively sandboxed javascript received over the network in real-time. It's not only about performance. It's about the app still working where there is no wireless signal, or being able to read or write device-wide settings or files, or make a VPN work, etc.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by pcwalton on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:13PM (#10977953)
> At which point you have to ask whether the missing things are actually that important.

Right. And the choice of programming language isn't.

> "Native code" in this context is as distinguished from aggressively sandboxed javascript received over the network in real-time... It's about the app still working where there is no wireless signal, or being able to read or write device-wide settings or files, or make a VPN work, etc.

Firefox OS had all of those capabilities (maybe excluding VPN depending on your definition--but if your definition of "making a VPN work" excludes Firefox OS it excludes iOS apps too). Firefox OS was based on locally installed apps.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:08PM (#10978143)
> Right. And the choice of programming language isn't.

The platform isn't just the language.

> Firefox OS was based on locally installed apps.

Then I have no idea what we're talking about.

So the point of Firefox OS was supposed to be what, you make the UI using HTML and javascript but then it runs locally and exposes system call wrappers through javascript?

That's not actually so bad of a concept, but then you have the opposite problem. Nothing that does anything you can't do in a traditional web page is portable outside of Firefox OS so you have no user base to attract developers.

It seems like they're trying to compete with Android when they should be trying to compete with Java. Make a runtime that runs the Firefox OS apps on Debian and Android and Windows. That would be interesting.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by pcwalton on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:16PM (#10978173)
> That's not actually so bad of a concept, but then you have the opposite problem. Nothing that does anything you can't do in a traditional web page is portable outside of Firefox OS so you have no user base with which to attract developers.

Yes, I'd agree that is/was much more of a problem than the technology stack itself.

> Make a runtime that runs the Firefox OS apps on Debian and Android and Windows. That would be interesting.

There is such a thing: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/Marketplace/Options/Open...

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by bane on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:04PM (#10977740)
The other problem in my mind is that there simply aren't a bunch of highly standardized smartphones for sale without an OS of some sort already installed on it. It's not like the computer market at all, where you can buy "blank" computers and or really easily wipe some crapware OS install.

Manufacturing hardware is stupid expensive and smartphones are really refined at this point. All the players with the capacity to make high-quality phones are already committed to their OS for all kinds of monetization strategy reasons and Firefox OS wasn't offering anything to them.

Between users, devices, manufacturers and carriers, Firefox OS's only chance was to commit to a 10-20 year plan and fund continuous development until it was so good it was obvious that it needed to start ending up on real mass consumer devices.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by perucoder on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @09:13PM (#10977768)
This is something I never understood about Firefox OS. Why did they not package it up in a way that it could be easily installed on someone's existing smartphone. I was eager to give it a try also but there was nowhere to buy the hardware and I never found a way to install it on a spare smartphone.
Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by wwweston on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:00PM (#10977920)
This.

Not only that, but the number of spare smartphones is steadily increasing. Barring impact damage, the hardware generally lasts longer than the period of time a consumer is satisfied before wanting something newer.

But older devices are also increasingly left out in the cold with software updates. Anything that can't run the latest OS release will miss out on a portion of apps. Anything that's more than one OS release old will miss out on most of the apps. Three OS releases? You'll be able to run what came with the OS and a bare handful of carefully backward compatible (or all but abandoned) apps, maybe.

So... there's an increasing amount of old devices that could really use something else to run on them.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by petecox on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:06PM (#10977935)
Well it is based on a pared-down Android build system complete with adb and fastboot access.

Maybe crowdfunding? Replicate the Cyanogenmod infrastructure and provide automated releases on every CM12.x device for Fx OS and others (Replicant, LuneOS, sailfish)?

I think Ubuntu Touch is slightly different but they run a bastardised Android inside an lxc container, so could possibly benefit from auto-building each 'inner' image too.

Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by toddan on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:21PM (#10977337)
It makes me wonder why canonical is wasting effort on ubuntu mobile.
Re:Why I care about Firefox OS fading away by patrick_99 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:20PM (#10977331)
My thoughts exactly when Amazon decided to build a phone