I'd be surprised to find there was no carrier profit built into this.
http://articles.latimes.com/2012/feb/10/business/la-fi-iphon...
This has been the case for T-Mobile and Sprint, at least in the scenarios that I have looked at.
Even back into the turn of the century, if you bought an unlocked phone off eBay, you were paying full whack for your rate plan, even though you didn't use a subsidy. I even had Cingular once try to tell me I was under contract, simply because I had signed up less than 2 years ago -- even though there was no contract (I paid for my own phone).
Then a couple of years ago, they started offering "BYOD" pricing plans, so I paid my $300ish ETF, got my iPhone unlocked, and "saved" $15/mo. It was roughly breakeven.
Now I just pay full price for my phone if and when I want a new one. It helps me recognize the full cost of what I'm buying, and it means I'm not tied to a carrier.
http://www.apple.com/shop/iphone/iphone-upgrade-program
(Oh yeah, with free AppleCare+ insurance)
It sure looks like Apple is planning for a future where everyone is paying $25/mo forever to lease the latest handset that tickles their fancy, with the carrier being a swappable option.
I wouldn't expect a huge number of people to go back to "dumb phones" though. Even if their carrier won't subsidise it or provide a payment plan, people will buy new smart phones, because they're use to having the features. Upgrades will just be less frequent.
No ones going back to dump phones
I dont understand why you would think smart phones would make a comeback.
The biggest reason for this (in the US at least) is the decline of 2-year mobile phone contracts over the last year. Many people are rethinking their upgrade cycle now that cellphones are a direct expense instead of being subsidized by the carrier.