Whoa there, hold on a second. That's not what's going on at all. The plates are being run to detect if the car's owner has outstanding court fines, which are not akin to a simple debt. These are (probably) justified, punitive fees imposed on an individual for some kind of offense against the law (and by extension, the public). It's not the case that the police are extorting people that are behind on their rent/credit card payments or something.
That said, this behavior is still troubling insofar as it is likely to disproportionately result in the targeting and punishment of the poor, which is in itself a rather problematic issue. And it's certainly troubling that the additional fee being imposed to process payment for the fines collected is far above what seems to be (at a glance, anyway) a reasonable margin for operating costs.
John Oliver did an entertaining segment on bail at one point. It presents some good examples of what can go wrong: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IS5mwymTIJU
> Whoa there, hold on a second. That's not what's going on at all.
We already have de-facto debtors prisons, this is just making it easier to get people into them.
I really doubt it's because those in poverty give fewer fucks about following traffic law.
I doubt it's a matter of education since you're supposed to demonstrate that minimum competence before you get a license anyways, and if you're not, we've found the problem.
What's left?
If you have comfortable amounts of wealth and/or income and get hit with a $500 fine you might be annoyed but you can pay it and go on your way.
But for the poor it's not so simple. First, that $500 represents a much larger burden. Even if they do scrape together the money to actually pay the fine, it might mean other bills would have to go unpaid, for example. And if they don't or can't get the money to pay the fine, those outstanding fines can get additional fees tacked on like Vigilant's 25%.
So it's not about seeking out the poor disproportionately more than the rich; it's about how the same punishment is actually more punishing.
Income based fines would be (rightly) struck down based on the equal protection clause to the constitution. They might even survive introduction to state legislation, but the moment someone with the resources contests it, it'll fall.
Not having the fines is not tenable, seeing as how it's the only way the law has any teeth.
Between a rock and a hard place. And seeing as how these laws are generally to society's benefit, just dropping them isn't valid either.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_constitutional_a...
"...handing Vigilant all of the data they gather on drivers for nearly unlimited commercial use..."
Debt collectors thrive on collecting every scrap of information they can about debtors: where they live, where they work, their cell numbers, and so on. This LPR database could quite easily build up profiles about debtors that collectors in the past could only dream of. One immediate application is watching where a car is driven and parked in order to repo it. That's probably the most acceptable use I can think of.
It gets worse from there: think data mining for alimony and custody battles, use by private investigators in infidelity cases, locating and stalking former lovers, and so on.
Second, even if you grant there is a difference between the debt types, how can he be wrong about it being de facto "debtors prison"? Who cares what the debt type is, it would still be a debtors prison, and there are a myriad of very good reasons we got rid of such things!
Third, the legal system is extremely unfavourable to the middle-class and poor, to the extent that I would also argue with your claim that the fees are "(probably) justified"... Another thing to remember is that fees have become revenue generators, and to look at them as punitive damages to be payed to the public for offenses is a naive take on the ways fees have developed in the legal and justice systems.
For example, I (in Texas btw) who almost never gets tickets, got one last year. Normally I have a paralegal friend do the deferred adjudication, I take a class, and move on. Well this last ticket they missed the deadline, I forgot about it, and the original $160 fee ballooned eventually to $700! Not only that, but technically, until I payed it, there was a warrant out for my arrest!
Do you think that kind of percentage increase is warranted or the warrant for arrest for not paying a fee is justified, because I certainly don't. I managed to pay it off, but for someone earning less would have had a very hard time paying that big of a fee, much less the financial impact of being fucking arrested...
" It's not the case that the police are extorting people that are behind on their rent/credit card payments or something."
Please explain how this is correct now, because it seems obviously false. (aka, they are extorting people because they are behind on payments (just because you made the false distinction of credit cards/rent and court fines does not make that fact magically go away...), and the police are even doing it for a third party!)
That's not even getting into the privacy and other issues the eff raises. For example, my paralegal friend has access to the TLO system and can look up plates and their geo/time data. While she wouldn't abuse it, the barriers to entry for paralegals can be pretty low in some firms...
The penalty for civil infractions is a fine and/or jail time. We've become so use to just payig fines we think it's a debtors prison if the law breaker doesn't pay the fine so we opt to penalize then with jail time. Perhaps we should just great everyone fairly and use jail time penalties only. That could lead to some reforms read quickly. The bigger offense and issue I have is when the state then charges the inmates for room and board. That's wrong.
The law already does. In the former case, we're talking about debts established in the course of various financial transactions between private parties. In the latter case, we're talking about fees (or more specifically in this case, what would colloquially be known as fines) that are imposed by the state for punitive and administrative reasons. Skipping out on the former will (generally) result in ruined credit scores and civil suits; skipping out on the latter is an civil or criminal offense against the state.
>even if you grant there is a difference between the debt types, how can he be wrong about it being de facto "debtors prison"? Who cares what the debt type is, it would still be a debtors prison, and there are a myriad of very good reasons we got rid of such things!
The term 'debtor's prison' is a loaded term, perjoratively describing historical cases of imprisonment of persons for failing to pay private debts. Barring edge cases (i.e., fraud), this has largely been eliminated in the USA. Imprisonment for failing to pay fines imposed for offenses against the law, on the other hand, is not a practice that has ever been (nor is likely to be) eliminated. And I don't buy that there are 'good reasons to get rid of such things', but that's a different discussion than the one at hand.
>Another thing to remember is that fees have become revenue generators, and to look at them as punitive damages to be payed to the public for offenses is a naive take on the ways fees have developed in the legal and justice systems.
Be that as it may, it's not germane to whether or not it's okay for the state to use creative ways to collect on previous assessed fines.
>I (in Texas btw) who almost never gets tickets, got one last year. Normally I have a paralegal friend do the deferred adjudication, I take a class, and move on. Well this last ticket they missed the deadline, I forgot about it, and the original $160 fee ballooned eventually to $700! Not only that, but technically, until I payed it, there was a warrant out for my arrest! Do you think that kind of percentage increase is warranted or the warrant for arrest for not paying a fee is justified, because I certainly don't.
Actually, I do think it's justified. Dealing with low level tickets is hardly difficult or burdensome, and the state has excellent reasons to create strong disincentives for dodging punishment. Further, paying a steep premium for irresponsible handling of your incident seems far preferable to serving actual jail time, or facing some other less dignified form of corporal punishment (as you might receive in a less westernized nations).
> they are extorting people because they are behind on payments
There's no extortion going on. It's implicit that the state's agents possess the means to impose compliance with the law; in cases where the law dictates that individuals pay a fine, it's reasonable for the state's agents to collect that fine or initiate further punishment for noncompliance with the law. Given the choice between jail + the courts and paying a high fee (some of which is to cover the costs associated with payment collection), a 25% premium hardly seems unreasonable.
If you don't pay a probation fine in time, you can quickly go right back to jail to serve the remainder of your sentence.
it's way too effective to not be done on purpose.
In this case, imagine a registrar of convenience (as I believe South Dakota is often used for Ruins Views), that issues eink-based license plates that generate a new identifier every few miles. Only the registrar could decode those nonces into the long-term vehicle record, with an accompanying legal process and technical audit trail.
(Of course such technical workarounds do nothing to fix the ultimate problem of corruption, it only releases the pressure a bit. Unfortunately the logical foundation of this country is based on outrunning tyranny, and in the age of abundance complexity knows no bounds. So to avoid collapse we really need every approach we can fathom)
The state closest to what you're looking for, I suspect, is New Hampshire. I don't know how much of it is due to their Free Stater influence or what, but among other things, they have relatively low burdens for living a legal life. There are some stupid laws (namely, not being able to pull backward into certain types of parking spots), but for the most part, they take their "Live Free or Die" motto pretty seriously.
If they could only fix the weather...
I'd obviously welcome any pushback against USG or private surveillance, it just feels more likely they'll destroy more municipal services. While everyone having a generator is self-reliant and robust, it's also indicative of infrastructure collapse.
Meanwhile, on infrastructure, New Hampshire has a better rating than the national average. On top of that, there's no sales tax, no income tax (though a higher than average property tax probably makes up some of the difference), has the highest overall quality of living, is the second healthiest state in the union, the most livable, the safest, and has the lowest poverty rate in America.
Certainly, everywhere has its perks and pitfalls, but if totalitarianism is what you're looking to escape, New Hampshire considers mandatory seat belt laws too authoritarian to pass.
The general response to these points is the root of my objection to the NH ethos. The few times I've heard about the FSP from the locals, it was not positive. Of course the mostly-accountable local government is easily gutted! Meanwhile the larger and more resource-draining tyranny remains intact, and perhaps even more supported due to less immediate intrusion. This seems less like actual freedom, and more like a sandbox for pretending to escape.
This would allow most of the good uses, while preventing drive-by surveillance.
The entropy required by nonce plates might also be prohibitive (a witness will have a hard time memorizing 20 digits), but a clever encoding should make the start or end of the number be significant enough when combined with the date.
The only place I've heard of people actually having issues with longer-term out-of-state registration is Mordor^wDC.
If we want to prevent the collapse of our broken society, we must create institutions that usurp the existing broken ones. License plate tracking cannot be solved by private organization (/local "exit") alone, as the problem stems from the government mandated tracking placards.
[0] The name used by the EFF is accurate but somewhat incomplete; these would be capias pro fine, which is a specific subset related to failing to comply with judgements.
[1] I won't indulge the EFF's language of Monopoly-style "go to jail" here, as that's a pretty loose interpretation. You will be detained to appear before a judge in order to plead your case.
Let's do a root cause analysis of the problem, since it goes much deeper than mere small fines.
First, the leveraging of state fines, backed by government force, disproportionally affects the poor. The poor are damaged most, because they do not have the money to pay the fines.
Second, unable to pay their fines, many members of the poorest segment of the population are incarcerated for their inability to pay.
Third, this results in a system where those that are incarcerated for debt lose employment, and are driven deeper into poverty.
Finally, the most important part of this piece is that the state of Texas has set up a massive dragnet surveillance operation at the state level.
Their goal is not national security. It is domestic surveillance.
This technology should never be deployed on American soil, at this scale, and especially not for collecting debt.
As a Texan with family in law enforcement, I get to watch this unfold daily. But here's a question for you, why is law enforcement levy and collect so many fines? The individual officer does not directly benefit from giving out so many tickets (other than keeping his job).
One of the large issues we have now is the court system financed via these fines. There have been many attempts to collect more tax dollars to directly fund the court but that is almost always shot down by groups such as the grassroots movement. This is a direct failure of not the poor people, but the middle class taxpayer that has now put the burden on the poor. The middle and upper class want (I'd say even demand) effective law enforcement, and this is how they've figured out to keep it running without causing to much political strife.
Right now the blowback is in the form of a total and utter lack of faith in the political elites by the majority of the population. The military has overwhelmingly more approval, and 23% of the population says that they would support a military coup.
If people don't feel that their votes actually matter... Well, I don't want to think about what happens if the world's largest democracy becomes a non-rational actor.
You're right, this is an upper class attempt to clamp down on the lower classes and keep the societal wheels turning. I don't understand the desire to give tickets, but it probably comes from the warrior mindset in law enforcement culture. It's about personal dominance.
Note that I also have relatives in law enforcement. This isn't an indictment of all police. There are many good people in law enforcement. But in aggregate there certainly has been a lurch toward aggressiveness.
Oh, hey, don't forget that we have 300M privately-owned guns distributed throughout the country, and have plenty of veterans around with combat experience.
If America snaps, it isn't going to voluntarily commit itself for psychiatric evaluation. It'll be a full-on schizophrenic break, with lots of bloody bodies.
I humbly suggest that a congressional approval rating of 11% and a congressional re-election rate of 95% are not the sort of incompatible numbers that promote continued sanity.
There is actually a logical explanation for that.
The people in corn country want ethanol subsidies. The people in Hollywood want draconian copyright laws. The people in coal mining districts don't want clean air laws.
So the Congressman from Iowa votes for draconian copyright laws in exchange for the Congresswoman from California voting for ethanol subsidies and every terrible thing which is bad for the whole country nevertheless comes to pass, causing the approval rate for Congress to fall below that of Vogon poetry and dirty latrines. Yet everyone is satisfied with their own member of Congress because they got that thing the district cared most about getting.
Fixing that is probably going to require some kind of structural change (like proportional representation in the House of Representatives).
Can you define what you mean here? I was under the impression that the House is proportional to population, and that the Senate is not. Unless, do you mean direct populace voting on Congressional acts, as opposed to the indirect representation we have now?
This is proportional representation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation
As a nation, we have had it very good for a very long time. Economic growth is considered a given, there is a social safety net, and major conventional war is widely thought to be an impossibility. We would not fare well if there was a societal breakdown.
I would predict the military and national guard would step in to stop domestic unrest if the national societal fabric unravelled. But what we really need is to convene a new Constitutional Convention, which will never happen unless there is blood in the streets, at which point things will already be very far out of hand.
I'm actually convinced that this is already happening, and the first eruptions of populist anger (Occupy, Black Lives Matter, the Tea Party) are being stamped out. For example, the National Guard was mobilized not long ago in Maryland to quell the population.
Ignoring entirely the Chicken Little bleating from the professional rabble-rousers and conspiracy theorists that say stuff like "ZOMG why do Post Office and Agriculture needs all teh ammos?!", the mistrust-of-government businesses are booming, and many of the fnords in the mainstream media point to a coordinated propaganda campaign against not just people who defy government, but also against those who merely question it too deeply.
When I take off the foil hat, everything is still okay. It isn't good, but it isn't irretrievably broken, either.
I used to believe more easily that I wasn't really living in the real world when I had the foil hat on. But lately...
I was thinking that Martin O'Malley struck a deal with the Democratic Party to be the hand that Hillary Clinton claps against through the primary season, in exchange for a high level executive position in her government. Bernie Sanders is running for the Democratic Party nomination only because running for PotUS as an independent is futile. He was never given any benefit from the party large enough to convince him to give Clinton her the title shot with only token resistance. And he's so unexpectedly popular that they can't squeeze him out of the media coverage quietly enough to make him drop out.
And then I go to take off my foil hat, and find that I thought that stupid conspiracy theory up bareheaded. When I actually put the foil hat on, it just gets ridiculous.
Something is very wrong when my rational mind notices "there should be more people up on that stage contesting the nomination now, months before the early states start to pick," and comes up with a completely plausible explanation that is rather blatantly anti-democratic. I can't tell if my BS detector needs to be recalibrated, or whether US politicians have just stopped putting forth reasonable efforts toward passing it off.
You don't even want to hear my theories about the Republican Party nomination races.
Whether from pressures from within or without, states inevitably degrade or even collapse. One of the typical patterns of collapse for a democracy is regression to dictatorship. It's not implausible.
Now, when looking at the nation as it is, rather than as it could be, I'm rather comforted. By all appearances the government continues to provide basic services, the military has unwavering loyalty to the civilian government, and the government is run by politicians chosen by popular election.
But government deficits are exploding, the sovereignties of the world are gobbling up private debt to prop up large financial firms, and the financial sector is so disconnected from the real economy that it has become one giant martingale that is due for a 25% downward correction.
What worries me most is that previously, there could be no permanent dictatorship. The United States has both the power and the infrastructure to become one. A few legal judgements here, a few electoral tweaks there, and our democracy becomes mere government theater, advertising that distracts us from the actual sovereigns and their interests.
I believe the current pattern of creeping statism from the left and steady erosion of Constitutional protections from the right are a lethal combination for a democracy.
There's some paranoia here, sure. But I find that when dealing with political matters recently, a healthy dose of skepticism is warranted.
How is offering a previously non-existent option extortion, again? Now, if the officers are not stating it as an option, then that is of course a complaint to be made. But nothing in the EFF article indicates this as a problem, so I don't know where this language is coming from. The subject (for lack of a better word here) is perfectly welcome to not take the roadside payment option, be detained, and pay after detainment without any additional fee. Which is exactly what would have happened without any of this.
> First, the leveraging of state fines, backed by government force, disproportionally affects the poor. The poor are damaged most, because they do not have the money to pay the fines.
The fines being discussed are only those related to copias pro fine, which means that a judgement was already delivered through a court and that judgement was not satisfied. If you want to argue for inequality against the poor in judgements, that's fine, but it's at best a tangentially related point and one I'm not interested in arguing. This system is purely in the realm of after all that has happened, and has no effect there.
> Finally, the most important part of this piece is that the state of Texas has set up a massive dragnet surveillance operation at the state level.
The data sharing is of course an issue, and I support the EFF in fighting against that. But that is also a separate issue than the option being provided to extinguish these warrants without being detained.
Say I go to a third world country and find some orphan who has been left to fend for themself. I make them an offer to effectively become a slave in return for being given basic care. Say I do this in which ever country gives me the most power to in-debt them to me. They can refuse and continue what ever life they were living.
Is this extortion or exploitation?
> extortion - the practice of obtaining something, especially money, through force or threats.
> exploitation - the action or fact of treating someone unfairly in order to benefit from their work.
Well, since you're not threatening the person nor forcing them to enter into this arrangement, I don't really see how you can call it extortion. Unless you want to call leaving them in their current situation a threat, which would be kind of stretching the intent, as that would imply that I am performing violence (the execution of a threat) against every person in need that I am not helping.
You could certainly call it exploitation, with the reasoning that providing only basic care in exchange for the services they render is unfair treatment. This would along the same lines as the justification for minimum wage and other employee protections -- that there is some standard minimum that must be met for these relationships.
Of course, there are plenty of flaws with this analogy. I can gloss over most of them, except for the nuance that there is a reason as a matter of law that this person is in their original situation to begin with. I think a better parallel would be an exile, perhaps?
* Definitions derived from Google. Feel free to provide your own if you feel they are inaccurate and I will reevaluate.
>As opposed to associations of that word to terribly abusive situations, because abuse is never OK.
Even if it was as bad as the association you are making, it is merely a choice.
>Unless you want to call leaving them in their current situation a threat
Here is where most people's moral systems break down. If their current situation involves death, then any deal where you benefit is seen as exploitation unless they think the exchange is fair. But doing absolutely nothing, offering nothing and taking nothing, is seen as a neutral choice. But only to an extent. If you turn away a starving child at your doorstep, the action is seen as abhorrent. But if don't donate money to help feed a starving child elsewhere, even though such an action is easier than helping the child at the doorstep, that is just normal.
There almost seems to be some moral corollary to the bystander effect.
I detailed my reasoning in the response. Specifically, that the exchange of basic care for the services rendered may not be considered a "fair" exchange [0], and thus being unfair treatment, and thus being exploitation.
In regards to morality, I agree with your sentiments. Bystander effect isn't the right word for it, but it feels very similar. More of an out-of-sight-out-of-mind, willful-ignorance thing. You can't claim ignorance when the child is at your doorstep asking you for help, but you can when they're somewhere else. There could also be an angle there with protection of one's own social / familial group over others, even if it means preventable harm to the other group.
Also, I'd like to thank you for this reasonable and engaging exchange.
[0] This would, of course, be a culturally sensitive judgement.
It shouldn't come as a shock that the poorest citizens are the least likely to show up to a hearing where they will be forced to pay money.
Even from a strictly legal perspective, detainment for a civil judgement based upon evidence from a massive domestic surveillance dragnet is very Constitutionally suspect.
But to be totally honest, I don't care what legal mechanisms allow this.
It is simply wrong.
I'll reiterate: If you want to engage someone about unfair judgements against certain classes, I'm not that person. It's only relation to the situation at hand is that it is a source of copias pro fine warrants.
> Even from a strictly legal perspective, detainment for a civil judgement based upon evidence from a massive domestic surveillance dragnet is very Constitutionally suspect.
The enabling part of this on the officer's side is not a "massive domestic surveillance dragnet". It's OCR tied to a database query. It's automation of a search the officer could already perform, if he could type fast enough.
As I've already stated, I agree with the EFF's position about the sharing of data back to Vigilant Solutions. Especially because sharing this data back is not necessary for the technology as used by the officers.
The enabling part of this on the officer's side is not a "massive domestic surveillance dragnet".
How else would you describe a state wide system that automatically records the movement of the population and stores it in a database other than dragnet surveillance? And Texas is bigger than many nations. So yes, I would count that as massive.
It's OCR tied to a database query. It's automation of a search the officer could already perform, if he could type fast enough.
Yes, and that is a tremendously important difference. A computer can log and store every license plate in real time. A single officer cannot do that at scale.
The courts have not caught up to this implication of computing technology. This is due to a failure to recognize that a change in quantity can be a change in quality.
For example, the occasional overflight to check for drug operations is qualitatively different from surveilling a whole city with areostats and drones. Both involve observation of public areas and are thus currently Constitutional. But one is far more invasive.
Your reductionist approach fails to consider any of the factors put forward. There is no conflation of issues. You are simply parroting back obsolete precedent, and refusing to acknowledge the implications of your argument.
Take a camera, have it run OCR, do a database lookup, alert on a positive result. None of those steps requires logging. Therefore the use of this technology to execute copias pro fine warrants is perpendicular to the data collection use of this technology.
I don't agree that the use of the technology to service outstanding warrants is a bad thing. I do agree that the data collection portion of this technology is a bad thing. Not agreeing with you is not equivalent to refusal of anything, other than the refusal of agreeing with you.
You're going to be detained to appear in front of a judge who is going to say 'you have outstanding unpaid court fines - you can pay them now or be subject to imprisonment'.
All that is happening in that case is changing the location of the credit card swipe.
And the amount. +25% to pay it by the side of the road.
When I was very young and stupid, I had a car impounded for unpaid parking tickets after being pulled over for a burnt out tail light. I would have gladly accepted a 25% fee for the option to pay right then and there to avoid the impound procedure. It would've cost less than what the court and impound yard charged me for letting it escalate that far.
And not being able to pay the 25% fee, what would have normally happened, would have happened.
You see, the modern police state has learned from the mistakes of Stazi, and technology has made the police-state surveillance very seamless. Most citizens don't even realize what's going on, and when told, they have too much to worry about.
That their's no external force working against the interests of our system makes it all the more hopeless.
Seat back, folks, and enjoy whatever freedom you have now.
The collapse occurs because of the resulting top-down groupthink. There are plenty of external forces working against our system, just on the time scale of several generations.
Wishful thinking. Just keep dreaming.
If by "first approximation" you're referring to voting, then, yes, majority gets to vote their favored lawmaker into office. However, because of political lobbying, the laws that are passed will not necessarily be in the interest of the majority.
To ban this kind of surveillance you need to take the extremely authoritarian step of telling me I am legally obligated to forget what I saw, to not record it, to not speak of it. You have claimed ownership for the state of he photons landing near my camera, and are now trying to hold me to a license agreement on their use. This is an unconstitutional violation of my freedom.
ANPR comes from an abundance of freedom, not a shortage.
Lets please not attack the other states because of Texan shenanigans. The fifty states are each semi-autonomous and as such can implement programs like this. This is an exception, not the norm.
>blowback happens through the democratic process
Why should it? Maybe Texans who work hard and pay their fines want the scofflaws to be caught like this? Democracy doesn't mean "things I like." It often means "things the average voter likes." Maybe this is "ill will" to you, but to a red state with a strong law and order culture to it, it may not be very controversial at all. You can't clamor for states rights in Texas, but also expect liberal soft-on-crime values. All politics is local.
Also, these people have capias warrants out for them at the time of this collection. Deadbeats who don't pay child support, ignore a civil judgements, ignore fines, etc get these. I don't really see a problem with this. If there's abuse here, it lies with how capias warrants are given out, not the technology used to enforce them. Why aren't we addressing the root issue here? Is there really an issue here other than SJW wankering?
You and I disagree on the root of the issue. The ease of enforcement is going to encourage the already despicable behavior of imposing fines that people aren't able to pay. This technology isn't going to effect middle class people that get the occasional speeding ticket. This is going to ensure that people who couldn't afford the fine are caught and fined again, then thrown in jail.
What should happen is that suspects should not be forced to pay the court costs associated with trying them. This eliminates the perverse incentives associated with this technology.
That seems like a misrepresentation of the post. jrandomh didn't say "this is undemocratic", but rather (paraphrasing) "this generates ill will". Hoping that mass ill will will (not a typo …) lead to change is not anti-democratic; it is exactly the idea of democracy.
So, they're planning to turn the Texas prison system into de facto debtors' prisons, and the Texas police system into de facto highwaymen. One more factor to add to the giant pile of reasons for ill-will that the US state and Federal governments have been collecting. That pile can't get much taller without toppling, and while I do greatly hope the blowback happens through the democratic process, that process is pretty severely damaged and this looks less and less likely every year.