News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @03:47PM (#10975926)
Yes, your additional option is to be extorted into paying a 25% fee.

Let's do a root cause analysis of the problem, since it goes much deeper than mere small fines.

First, the leveraging of state fines, backed by government force, disproportionally affects the poor. The poor are damaged most, because they do not have the money to pay the fines.

Second, unable to pay their fines, many members of the poorest segment of the population are incarcerated for their inability to pay.

Third, this results in a system where those that are incarcerated for debt lose employment, and are driven deeper into poverty.

Finally, the most important part of this piece is that the state of Texas has set up a massive dragnet surveillance operation at the state level.

Their goal is not national security. It is domestic surveillance.

This technology should never be deployed on American soil, at this scale, and especially not for collecting debt.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by pixl97 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:15PM (#10976137)
>First, the leveraging of state fines, backed by government force, disproportionally affects the poor.

As a Texan with family in law enforcement, I get to watch this unfold daily. But here's a question for you, why is law enforcement levy and collect so many fines? The individual officer does not directly benefit from giving out so many tickets (other than keeping his job).

One of the large issues we have now is the court system financed via these fines. There have been many attempts to collect more tax dollars to directly fund the court but that is almost always shot down by groups such as the grassroots movement. This is a direct failure of not the poor people, but the middle class taxpayer that has now put the burden on the poor. The middle and upper class want (I'd say even demand) effective law enforcement, and this is how they've figured out to keep it running without causing to much political strife.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:20PM (#10976656)
There is blowback from these actions. Much like the blowback from intelligence operations it often manifests in unusual ways. For example, deposing the elected leader of Iran through Operation Ajax led to the coup by religious extremists, and funding the Mujahideen in Afghanistan led to the rise of the Taliban and Al Qaeda.

Right now the blowback is in the form of a total and utter lack of faith in the political elites by the majority of the population. The military has overwhelmingly more approval, and 23% of the population says that they would support a military coup.

If people don't feel that their votes actually matter... Well, I don't want to think about what happens if the world's largest democracy becomes a non-rational actor.

You're right, this is an upper class attempt to clamp down on the lower classes and keep the societal wheels turning. I don't understand the desire to give tickets, but it probably comes from the warrior mindset in law enforcement culture. It's about personal dominance.

Note that I also have relatives in law enforcement. This isn't an indictment of all police. There are many good people in law enforcement. But in aggregate there certainly has been a lurch toward aggressiveness.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by logfromblammo on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:51PM (#10976874)
Well, I don't want to think about what happens if the world's largest democracy becomes irrational.

Oh, hey, don't forget that we have 300M privately-owned guns distributed throughout the country, and have plenty of veterans around with combat experience.

If America snaps, it isn't going to voluntarily commit itself for psychiatric evaluation. It'll be a full-on schizophrenic break, with lots of bloody bodies.

I humbly suggest that a congressional approval rating of 11% and a congressional re-election rate of 95% are not the sort of incompatible numbers that promote continued sanity.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @06:57PM (#10977212)
> I humbly suggest that a congressional approval rating of 11% and a congressional re-election rate of 95% are not the sort of incompatible numbers that promote continued sanity.

There is actually a logical explanation for that.

The people in corn country want ethanol subsidies. The people in Hollywood want draconian copyright laws. The people in coal mining districts don't want clean air laws.

So the Congressman from Iowa votes for draconian copyright laws in exchange for the Congresswoman from California voting for ethanol subsidies and every terrible thing which is bad for the whole country nevertheless comes to pass, causing the approval rate for Congress to fall below that of Vogon poetry and dirty latrines. Yet everyone is satisfied with their own member of Congress because they got that thing the district cared most about getting.

Fixing that is probably going to require some kind of structural change (like proportional representation in the House of Representatives).

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @07:20PM (#10977328)
> Fixing that is probably going to require some kind of structural change (like proportional representation in the House of Representatives).

Can you define what you mean here? I was under the impression that the House is proportional to population, and that the Senate is not. Unless, do you mean direct populace voting on Congressional acts, as opposed to the indirect representation we have now?

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:01PM (#10977505)
The number of seats in the House is proportional to the population (or it was, until there would have been "too many" seats and they... look it up, it's crazy), but the seats each have a "district" where the people in that district elect one specific representative.

This is proportional representation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_representation

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @08:31PM (#10977612)
Ah, I see. I wasn't thinking about the district level. Thanks.
Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @06:06PM (#10976962)
That's what I fear.

As a nation, we have had it very good for a very long time. Economic growth is considered a given, there is a social safety net, and major conventional war is widely thought to be an impossibility. We would not fare well if there was a societal breakdown.

I would predict the military and national guard would step in to stop domestic unrest if the national societal fabric unravelled. But what we really need is to convene a new Constitutional Convention, which will never happen unless there is blood in the streets, at which point things will already be very far out of hand.

I'm actually convinced that this is already happening, and the first eruptions of populist anger (Occupy, Black Lives Matter, the Tea Party) are being stamped out. For example, the National Guard was mobilized not long ago in Maryland to quell the population.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by logfromblammo on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @11:58AM (#10981142)
If your foil hat is made of the correct metals (and mine probably is), you may have noticed that government agencies and paranoid citizens alike have been quietly preparing for armed rebellion for at least a decade.

Ignoring entirely the Chicken Little bleating from the professional rabble-rousers and conspiracy theorists that say stuff like "ZOMG why do Post Office and Agriculture needs all teh ammos?!", the mistrust-of-government businesses are booming, and many of the fnords in the mainstream media point to a coordinated propaganda campaign against not just people who defy government, but also against those who merely question it too deeply.

When I take off the foil hat, everything is still okay. It isn't good, but it isn't irretrievably broken, either.

I used to believe more easily that I wasn't really living in the real world when I had the foil hat on. But lately...

I was thinking that Martin O'Malley struck a deal with the Democratic Party to be the hand that Hillary Clinton claps against through the primary season, in exchange for a high level executive position in her government. Bernie Sanders is running for the Democratic Party nomination only because running for PotUS as an independent is futile. He was never given any benefit from the party large enough to convince him to give Clinton her the title shot with only token resistance. And he's so unexpectedly popular that they can't squeeze him out of the media coverage quietly enough to make him drop out.

And then I go to take off my foil hat, and find that I thought that stupid conspiracy theory up bareheaded. When I actually put the foil hat on, it just gets ridiculous.

Something is very wrong when my rational mind notices "there should be more people up on that stage contesting the nomination now, months before the early states start to pick," and comes up with a completely plausible explanation that is rather blatantly anti-democratic. I can't tell if my BS detector needs to be recalibrated, or whether US politicians have just stopped putting forth reasonable efforts toward passing it off.

You don't even want to hear my theories about the Republican Party nomination races.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @12:34PM (#10981439)
I'm not convinced a foil hat is necessary. The rise and fall of both nations and civilizations isn't the exception. It's the rule.

Whether from pressures from within or without, states inevitably degrade or even collapse. One of the typical patterns of collapse for a democracy is regression to dictatorship. It's not implausible.

Now, when looking at the nation as it is, rather than as it could be, I'm rather comforted. By all appearances the government continues to provide basic services, the military has unwavering loyalty to the civilian government, and the government is run by politicians chosen by popular election.

But government deficits are exploding, the sovereignties of the world are gobbling up private debt to prop up large financial firms, and the financial sector is so disconnected from the real economy that it has become one giant martingale that is due for a 25% downward correction.

What worries me most is that previously, there could be no permanent dictatorship. The United States has both the power and the infrastructure to become one. A few legal judgements here, a few electoral tweaks there, and our democracy becomes mere government theater, advertising that distracts us from the actual sovereigns and their interests.

I believe the current pattern of creeping statism from the left and steady erosion of Constitutional protections from the right are a lethal combination for a democracy.

There's some paranoia here, sure. But I find that when dealing with political matters recently, a healthy dose of skepticism is warranted.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#10976112)
> Yes, your additional option is to be extorted into paying a 25% fee.

How is offering a previously non-existent option extortion, again? Now, if the officers are not stating it as an option, then that is of course a complaint to be made. But nothing in the EFF article indicates this as a problem, so I don't know where this language is coming from. The subject (for lack of a better word here) is perfectly welcome to not take the roadside payment option, be detained, and pay after detainment without any additional fee. Which is exactly what would have happened without any of this.

> First, the leveraging of state fines, backed by government force, disproportionally affects the poor. The poor are damaged most, because they do not have the money to pay the fines.

The fines being discussed are only those related to copias pro fine, which means that a judgement was already delivered through a court and that judgement was not satisfied. If you want to argue for inequality against the poor in judgements, that's fine, but it's at best a tangentially related point and one I'm not interested in arguing. This system is purely in the realm of after all that has happened, and has no effect there.

> Finally, the most important part of this piece is that the state of Texas has set up a massive dragnet surveillance operation at the state level.

The data sharing is of course an issue, and I support the EFF in fighting against that. But that is also a separate issue than the option being provided to extinguish these warrants without being detained.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:22PM (#10976187)
>How is offering a previously non-existent option extortion, again?

Say I go to a third world country and find some orphan who has been left to fend for themself. I make them an offer to effectively become a slave in return for being given basic care. Say I do this in which ever country gives me the most power to in-debt them to me. They can refuse and continue what ever life they were living.

Is this extortion or exploitation?

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:44PM (#10976358)
I'm going to assume a generous use of the word "slave" here, as simply a parallel for the loss of freedom that would be experienced by being detained. As opposed to associations of that word to terribly abusive situations, because abuse is never OK.

> extortion - the practice of obtaining something, especially money, through force or threats.

> exploitation - the action or fact of treating someone unfairly in order to benefit from their work.

Well, since you're not threatening the person nor forcing them to enter into this arrangement, I don't really see how you can call it extortion. Unless you want to call leaving them in their current situation a threat, which would be kind of stretching the intent, as that would imply that I am performing violence (the execution of a threat) against every person in need that I am not helping.

You could certainly call it exploitation, with the reasoning that providing only basic care in exchange for the services they render is unfair treatment. This would along the same lines as the justification for minimum wage and other employee protections -- that there is some standard minimum that must be met for these relationships.

Of course, there are plenty of flaws with this analogy. I can gloss over most of them, except for the nuance that there is a reason as a matter of law that this person is in their original situation to begin with. I think a better parallel would be an exile, perhaps?

* Definitions derived from Google. Feel free to provide your own if you feel they are inaccurate and I will reevaluate.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @04:56PM (#10976441)
How can it be exploitation if they have fully freedom in choosing to forgo the deal?

>As opposed to associations of that word to terribly abusive situations, because abuse is never OK.

Even if it was as bad as the association you are making, it is merely a choice.

>Unless you want to call leaving them in their current situation a threat

Here is where most people's moral systems break down. If their current situation involves death, then any deal where you benefit is seen as exploitation unless they think the exchange is fair. But doing absolutely nothing, offering nothing and taking nothing, is seen as a neutral choice. But only to an extent. If you turn away a starving child at your doorstep, the action is seen as abhorrent. But if don't donate money to help feed a starving child elsewhere, even though such an action is easier than helping the child at the doorstep, that is just normal.

There almost seems to be some moral corollary to the bystander effect.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:11PM (#10976568)
> How can it be exploitation if they have fully freedom in choosing to forgo the deal?

I detailed my reasoning in the response. Specifically, that the exchange of basic care for the services rendered may not be considered a "fair" exchange [0], and thus being unfair treatment, and thus being exploitation.

In regards to morality, I agree with your sentiments. Bystander effect isn't the right word for it, but it feels very similar. More of an out-of-sight-out-of-mind, willful-ignorance thing. You can't claim ignorance when the child is at your doorstep asking you for help, but you can when they're somewhere else. There could also be an angle there with protection of one's own social / familial group over others, even if it means preventable harm to the other group.

Also, I'd like to thank you for this reasonable and engaging exchange.

[0] This would, of course, be a culturally sensitive judgement.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:02PM (#10976486)
Who cares whether a judge issued the judgement? The fact is that most of the poor cannot take time off to travel to a courthouse at an appointed date and time, thus those judgements are entered without any defense.

It shouldn't come as a shock that the poorest citizens are the least likely to show up to a hearing where they will be forced to pay money.

Even from a strictly legal perspective, detainment for a civil judgement based upon evidence from a massive domestic surveillance dragnet is very Constitutionally suspect.

But to be totally honest, I don't care what legal mechanisms allow this.

It is simply wrong.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:24PM (#10976675)
I'm not appreciative of your continued attempt to conflate very separate issues in order to attempt to prove some "this is bad" point.

I'll reiterate: If you want to engage someone about unfair judgements against certain classes, I'm not that person. It's only relation to the situation at hand is that it is a source of copias pro fine warrants.

> Even from a strictly legal perspective, detainment for a civil judgement based upon evidence from a massive domestic surveillance dragnet is very Constitutionally suspect.

The enabling part of this on the officer's side is not a "massive domestic surveillance dragnet". It's OCR tied to a database query. It's automation of a search the officer could already perform, if he could type fast enough.

As I've already stated, I agree with the EFF's position about the sharing of data back to Vigilant Solutions. Especially because sharing this data back is not necessary for the technology as used by the officers.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by s_q_b on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:32PM (#10976740)
I'm not interested in engaging in a legalistic argument without considering the societal implications.

The enabling part of this on the officer's side is not a "massive domestic surveillance dragnet".

How else would you describe a state wide system that automatically records the movement of the population and stores it in a database other than dragnet surveillance? And Texas is bigger than many nations. So yes, I would count that as massive.

It's OCR tied to a database query. It's automation of a search the officer could already perform, if he could type fast enough.

Yes, and that is a tremendously important difference. A computer can log and store every license plate in real time. A single officer cannot do that at scale.

The courts have not caught up to this implication of computing technology. This is due to a failure to recognize that a change in quantity can be a change in quality.

For example, the occasional overflight to check for drug operations is qualitatively different from surveilling a whole city with areostats and drones. Both involve observation of public areas and are thus currently Constitutional. But one is far more invasive.

Your reductionist approach fails to consider any of the factors put forward. There is no conflation of issues. You are simply parroting back obsolete precedent, and refusing to acknowledge the implications of your argument.

Re:“No Cost” License Plate Readers Are Turning Texas Police ... by jdmichal on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @05:54PM (#10976892)
I'll make this simple.

Take a camera, have it run OCR, do a database lookup, alert on a positive result. None of those steps requires logging. Therefore the use of this technology to execute copias pro fine warrants is perpendicular to the data collection use of this technology.

I don't agree that the use of the technology to service outstanding warrants is a bad thing. I do agree that the data collection portion of this technology is a bad thing. Not agreeing with you is not equivalent to refusal of anything, other than the refusal of agreeing with you.