Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by anon4 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @10:56AM
(#10974014)
I'm not sure how you would define the Fourier Transform geometrically without needing 4 spatial dimensions, at which point intuitive geometric reasoning is impossible.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by lordCarbonFiber on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:09AM
(#10974099)
Far from impossible, it's even reasonably intutitive. Wikipedia has an excellent graphic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Fourier_transform_time_an....
Then for people for which that's too abstract, I find this graphic helps a lot in explaining. http://static.nautil.us/1635_42a3964579017f3cb42b26605b9ae8e...
You picked a really bad example for the unintutiveness of mathematics.
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by BurritoAlPastor on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @12:30PM
(#10974563)
Speaking in my capacity as a person who doesn't understand Fourier transforms, I'm afraid I have to say that your "intuitive" graphics are anything but. I can't even make sense of your second graphic.
Just a data point for you.
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by lordCarbonFiber on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @02:52PM
(#10975511)
Fair enough, it works a lot better as a gif. Out of curiosity, does this clear things up, or just as confusing?
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1a/Fourier_...
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by BurritoAlPastor on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @03:17PM
(#10975695)
Oooh. Yes, actually; I think I have an idea about what's going on (and why they're so damn useful) now.
Thank you!
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by occamrazor on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @12:19PM
(#10974489)
I'd suggest most of homological algebra as an example. It's called "abstract nonsense" for a reason.
Personally, my intuition gives up at spectral sequences.
Re:Marvin Minsky: What makes mathematics hard to learn? (2008)
by echo_oddly on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @11:25AM
(#10974174)
Doing a Fourier transform is simply applying a set of inner products from the function, f, onto a set of orthonormal basis functions. Put a post in the ground, measure the length of the shadow cast by the sun. That's how to do an inner product. So you can at least describe the process using few dimensions. Then you can scale it up to higher dimensions from there.