Re:Marvin Minsky dies at 88
by azinman2 on Monday January 25, 2016 @10:24PM
(#10971654)
I don't think bolt could say that. He'll be in the very top (for certain kinds of metrics), but to say #1? That presumes you know your rank compared to 8B+ people.
I would have preferred Asimov to say something like "Sagan and minsky are the brightest minds I've encountered in my life." And if you think Asimov is super smart, then you'll respect Sagan and Minsky that much more. And you'll respect Asimov too for not being so egotistical. It doesn't even matter if it's actually true or not.
Minsky, in my experience, demonstrated humility when talking with or listening to him. For that I gain admiration beyond the talent.
Re:Marvin Minsky dies at 88
by jaksdhkj on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @12:39AM
(#10971990)
It's a quotation, taken out of context, without any additional side channel information. Might be a good idea to not form a strong opinion of a very smart man from this.
I would have preferred Asimov to say something like "Sagan and minsky are the brightest minds I've encountered in my life." And if you think Asimov is super smart, then you'll respect Sagan and Minsky that much more. And you'll respect Asimov too for not being so egotistical. It doesn't even matter if it's actually true or not.
Minsky, in my experience, demonstrated humility when talking with or listening to him. For that I gain admiration beyond the talent.