News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by sharkweek on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:27PM (#10969699)
Every Lewis book I've read has been great. He does a fantastic job exposing any number of things that are likely desired to be kept secret. Also does a great job making things understandable, while not dumbing it down too much to the point of inaccurate.

"The Great HFT Debate" is a must-watch, following the release of 'Flashboys' just seeing how defensive the market players got.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RcpmHyPD_PY

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by kasey_junk on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:45PM (#10969812)
I'm a (or at least was) a huge Michael Lewis fan. Until he wrote a book about the industry I was in (HFT). Regardless of where you stand on HFT, Flashboys does a very bad job explaining the technical aspects that are occurring. Further it presents a completely 1 sided look at the industry, without ever quoting someone knowledgeable about the technical aspects.

I don't dislike Flashboys because of its conclusions, I dislike it because of its inaccuracy. It called inot question every other book of his. Which was really disappointing as I had enjoyed them all so much.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by sharkweek on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:54PM (#10969866)
This is super interesting to me - got any resources of people counter-pointing Lewis's writing? Would love to dive in a little deeper.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by kasey_junk on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:00PM (#10969902)
http://kc.my-junk.info/hft-books/

^^ a blog post where I collect this stuff as I answer this question so often.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:08PM (#10969946)
but you don't really give any specific counter points. if Flash Boys is dreadful, i would think you would have specific points to counter it
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by Nimitz14 on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:18PM (#10970015)
https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2014/04/04/michael-lewis-...

Quote:

> I think this is the crux of this story: according to Michael Lewis and Katsuyama, we’re supposed to trust people like Einhorn who have been convicted of insider trading, people who are suspected of insider trading (buy side is by definition rife with this; particularly firms that do merger arb and special events), J.P. Morgan, Goldman and Morgan Stanley: we’re supposed to trust these guys more than we’re supposed to trust a bunch of tiny little market making firms who had been inconveniencing them by taking away some of their flow. Lewis tries to make this seem like a battle between the underdog “good guys” and the evil establishment. To believe this, you’d have to believe that Goldman Sachs and people like Einhorn are underdogs, rather than the actual establishment. To believe this, you’d have to believe the tiny industry of HFT traders actually rules the world and buys off congressmen and the SEC more than … J.P. Morgan and Goldman. [...] Yeah, I might believe that. I might believe that if I were a dribbling retard.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:29PM (#10970080)
Still this is all just Ad-Hominem attack on the characters in Flash Boys and seems a bit over the top "Yeah, I might believe that. I might believe that if I were a dribbling retard."

doesn't really answer why Flash Boys does such a terrible job of explaining HFT

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:37PM (#10970116)
Yes, it does. You didn't read it carefully enough.

The whole premise of the David and Goliath story Lewis wants to tell is that HFT is a device used by the Wall Street establishment to screw over the rest of the market.

But in fact it's more the opposite: HFT firms are upstart prop trading and market making shops that are pissing off giant banks like Goldman and JPMC by making it harder for them to skim profits off block trades for pension and hedge funds.

Also: the use of rhetoric like "dribbling retard" isn't what makes an argument "ad hominem". An ad hominem argument is one whose logic rests on a claim about its opponent and doesn't account for its opponent's argument. The logic behind the quote you're commenting on doesn't do that.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:43PM (#10970162)
i said that comment is a bit over the top. i was talking about "either Lewis is a credulous idiot who is not competent as a journalist, or Katsuyama is an idiot who was not competent as a trader" it seems Locklin's goal is to say Michael Lewis is an idiot, which is ad-hominem attack. The need to call him an idiot, combined with the "retard" comment is really not needed and doesn't add anything.

i do appreciate your explanation for how the goal of Lewis's book is based on a fallacy

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:51PM (#10970226)
You're missing an important piece of context.

The argument being made here is about Katsuyama's complaint that the prices he'd see in his terminal would suddenly move away from him if he tried to trade large blocks of stock at that price.

What makes Katsuyama sound incompetent is his apparent lack of understanding of the price pressure his own large block trades put on the market. Lewis makes Katsuyama out to sound as if he can reasonably expect that if FCOJ is quoted 29.78-29.80, he can sell 100,000 shares at the quoted price. Of course, not only can he not expect to do that, but the influence that large trade has on the market is the whole reason Katsuyama is paid by RBC to trade for its clients.

Hence: either Lewis doesn't understand his subject well enough to report on it, or Katsuyama doesn't understand the basic function of his job.

In any case: not an ad-hominem, sorry. There's a popular Internet fallacy that says any argument that uses insulting language must be an ad-hominem. Insults aren't usually productive, but they don't automatically produce flawed arguments.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:46PM (#10970597)
How about him saying "looking a little scaly, bub" for a caption for lewis. Surely what Lewis looks like has no relevance on the argument. Seems Lacklin has it out for Lewis.

I guess calling him an idiot is not ad-hominem in that he's arguing he doesn't understand what he's talking about.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:48PM (#10970610)
If you're on a mission to spot all the unproductive rhetoric in a substantive criticism of the book, that's fine, but I'm not interested. It takes a couple minutes to think out and write up an explanation of what these criticisms are about, and when you respond to one of those explanations by changing the subject to a snarky caption on a photo, I'm made to feel like I wasted my time.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:58PM (#10970665)
Sorry, didn't mean to waste your time.

A) I agreed with your last comment

B) was just pointing out that the snarkyness comes across strong in the blog post. So it's possible that frame of mind affects the writing and it affects the reader, argument aside.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by kasey_junk on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:35PM (#10970106)
I think that is a fair criticism. You can read my blog post to be "Flash Boys, Not So Fast is the rebuttal I would have written if I had the time and was a good writer".

Maybe I should change the post to be more explicit about that.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @06:06PM (#10970697)
Fair enough
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:12PM (#10969980)
If there was a way you could have worded this comment without implying that Kasey was just making things up, it would have been a better comment. As it stands, I think you can take the time to use the search bar at the bottom of the page to find what he's written about the book on the site before.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by toddmatthews on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:21PM (#10970029)
in no way was i implying he was "making things up" but he has said that Flash Boys did a "bad job of explaining HFT" and on that website he links to it says its "dreadful". He also says he "answers this question so often" he made that site. but the site just lists books, but doesn't really answer any questions. Just pointing to other peoples books is not really answering a question. and i think if Flash Boys is "dreadful" he could point to a few concrete examples
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by airza on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @07:49AM (#10979718)
This is an excellent and fairly short book on the subject:

http://www.amazon.com/Flash-Boys-Insiders-Perspective-High-F...

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by andylei on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:43PM (#10969791)
its weird that in every industry where computers replace people, HN considers it progress, but when its making securities markets, its a scam.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:52PM (#10969853)
Back in the day I worked for financial traders on early automated trading systems, and I think your summary is fantastically poor.

First, people have long had questions about the societal effects and costs of trading, even when humans did it. Second, the automation of trading isn't merely replicating what humans do at a lower cost. I'd call it a fundamentally different activity. Third, one of the things that has become more and more attenuated is any sense of moral responsibility. Traders were never known for attacks of the warm fuzzies, but algorithms not only don't give a shit about how the affect humans, they can't. And fourth, instead of saving everybody money, finance eats up an ever-increasing share of the economy, and I think automation is part of that.

Automation isn't universally good. Sometimes it makes things better, sometimes worse. As technologists our job isn't just to automate everything. It's to use our professional skills and experience to improve the world, to improve human lives.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by dtornabene on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:08PM (#10971028)
I feel like you're side stepping the point of his argument. Maybe I'm misreading you both. It read (to me at least) more of a "why isn't hn this hard on other automation stories" and less of an indictment of the (fashionable) distaste for HFT.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @01:56AM (#10972217)
I suppose one could read it either way. But a) most engineers are pro-automation, b) he works for a financial company, and c) computers haven't really replaced people in finance, so absent other evidence, I am going to stick with my reading of his comment for now.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by oldmanjay on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:58PM (#10969886)
How does one eat a share of the economy? Do I have to assume it to be zero sum for the concept to be clear?
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:25PM (#10970056)
You don't have to assume zero sum in general. Just that some interactions can be zero or negative sum. The simple example is monopoly rents: monopolists can increase their share of total profits without increasing value delivered.

By a lot of measures, the financial industry captures a lot more money than they did in previous decades. But it's far from clear that they're delivering a lot more value, and given that computers have drastically reduced their costs, it's reasonable to expect them to be smaller, not larger. As a start, this has some good graphs:

http://esoltas.blogspot.com/2013/02/5-more-graphs-on-finance...

And here are a couple more general-audience articles:

http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/03/30/chart-of-th...

http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2011/12/10/number-of-the-week...

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by jandrese on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:54PM (#10969864)
Eh, using computers to replace people in front running was really not an improvement to the situation.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:05PM (#10969934)
Yes it was. Even stipulating your use of the term "front running"†, it's not hard to see how. When humans intermediated trades, spreads were denominated in dimes and quarters (and even higher as you go back further in time). Now they're pennies.

Google "odd eighths scandal" for a good starting point.

† "Front running" has a specific technical meaning, which very few people who throw the term around seem to know about: a front-runner violates a fiduciary duty they have to a client, trading against their clients for their own benefit. Market makers and prop trading firms aren't generally brokers for other people and don't have that duty; they can't "front-run" the people they out-trade.

Your real estate agent would "front run" you if they knew you wanted to buy a particular house, knew your maximum price, bought the same house for less than that price and then sold it to you at a profit. Same with your stock broker and, say, IBM stock; they have a duty of best execution to you.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by AjithAntony on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:00PM (#10970282)
I only know as much as I read in Flash Boys, and it sounds like front-running is generally the right name for this, but the difference is that it is not your broker but 3rd parties who are fishing for info on potential trades that are front-running.

By your analogy, the real estate agent knows you want to buy 5 houses, and suddenly after closing the first one, the price of the remaining 4 goes up.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by tptacek on Monday January 25, 2016 @05:06PM (#10970324)
No. Your real estate agent has a duty to you and cannot trade against your interests. A prop trading firm (or "3rd party firm") has no such duty, and thus can't "front-run" you.

If your own real estate agent bought a bunch of houses to resell them to you at a profit, they would be front running you. If another real estate firm noticed that you seemed intent on buying 5 houses and bought a bunch of them to resell to you, that would not be front-running; in fact, that would basically be a description of how the real estate market works.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by AjithAntony on Thursday January 28, 2016 @02:55AM (#10986968)
> how the real estate market works.

I'm not saying it's your own broker or agent that is biding up the remainder of the lots you are intending to buy. It is "observers" who are manipulating the system in a way to make you reveal to them your intentions and price, so they can "front run" you for the next transaction a millisecond later at the next exchange.

And the reason I quoted observers was becuase in my limited understanding (if i had the book in front of me I would re-read this), the HFT traders would put up some token offers up on all the stocks for the purpose of exposing potential activity that they could abuse. A quick google of this suggests that this is called "Pinging".

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by patio11 on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @02:09AM (#10972243)
basically be a description of how the real estate market works.

For example: a commercial real estate developer may be putting together "an assemblage", which takes a bunch of disparate properties and tetris-style assembles them into a contiguous landmass to hold e.g. a larger commercial property with a signed anchor tenant and the plans for more. The developer has important, market-moving knowledge about the near-term prospects for properties composing that assemblage: they are all about to become sharply more valuable precisely because the developer has a use for them. The developer will send out someone who is isomorphic to my dad to discuss with the owners of each property, partially in serial and partially in parallel, to get them to sell to the developer. Their goal is to get the properties as cheap as possible and they are under no obligation to tip their hand as to why they want them.

It is highly, highly in the developer's interest to conclude all purchases before either a) the property owners or b) anyone else realizes what is going on. This is complicated by many factors, including e.g. planning commission approvals required in some places which are public records. A fairly common strategy among savvy local real estate investors is to a) identify assemblages before they are assembled and b) race the people putting them together.

"They bought the corner gas station? It's useless without Milly's house. Have they closed Milly yet? Quick way to check. calls Milly Milly, I was wondering, haven't you considered being closer to your children? Where did they live again, Florida? Yeah, yeah. Interested in selling your house if I give you a fair offer? Well, we can talk it over any time, but $300k cash and I can close immediately. Sure sure, let's chat."

Real estate developers hate, hate, hate when it happens, because sometimes the market maker here has correctly intuited "This deal doesn't happen without the property which was previously occupied by Milly, right? Man, that would be a shame. $700k." "That's an outrage. It's worth $250k." "You were certainly going to tell Milly that,which is why I gave her $300k. But, between businessmen, it's not worth $250k or $300k. It's worth whatever number your client is willing to authorize to get the assemblage done." "$600k you dirty dog." "$650" "DONE." "Pleasure doing business with you."

Now naturally, sometimes the market maker guesses wrong. He now is holding a house. That's the nature of the business.

This maps fairly directly to financial markets, except the "assemblages" are called "block trades", they're composed of fungible units rather than individually distinguishable properties, and this happens much faster and much cheaper because market makers are very, very good at their jobs.

You can imagine that the neighbor next door to Milly might notice the fact of Milly's transaction (e.g. via hearing directly) or the market maker's transaction (e.g. via public records). This is analogous to the tape being painted in a lit exchange. "Ooh spiffy, my property is more valuable than I thought it was!" The real estate developer hates this as much as Brad Katsuyama hates when someone spills the beans that he's putting a 100k trade together by painting the tapes with buy orders.

The real estate developer, and Katsuyama, should learn to deal with their disappointments or get better at executing on their only job.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by jandrese on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:09PM (#10982250)
That's splitting hairs. Do you have a better term for when someone sniffs your trades on the wire and uses their advantaged position to buy up the market and then relist it at a higher price?

Arbitrage doesn't really cover it because people were buying at the original price and may not buy at the marked up price.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by dllthomas on Wednesday January 27, 2016 @02:17PM (#10982299)
As I understand it, "sniffs your trades on the wire" is an inaccurate description of what is going on. HFT is responding to information about trades that have already happened (possibily at a different exchange).

Where it really is wire tapping, I would say the right term might be (high speed) industrial espionage.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by AjithAntony on Thursday January 28, 2016 @03:00AM (#10986981)
> HFT is responding to information about trades that have already happened (possibily at a different exchange).

And that they were likely a party to. They would place small orders on all the stocks so that they could detect activity that they could exploit at the next exchange a millisecond down the wire.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by dllthomas on Thursday January 28, 2016 @11:10AM (#10988977)
Right!
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by L-Logic on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:36PM (#10969754)
Agreed, his books are good. People should also watch the movie "The Big Short."