News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:52PM (#10969853)
Back in the day I worked for financial traders on early automated trading systems, and I think your summary is fantastically poor.

First, people have long had questions about the societal effects and costs of trading, even when humans did it. Second, the automation of trading isn't merely replicating what humans do at a lower cost. I'd call it a fundamentally different activity. Third, one of the things that has become more and more attenuated is any sense of moral responsibility. Traders were never known for attacks of the warm fuzzies, but algorithms not only don't give a shit about how the affect humans, they can't. And fourth, instead of saving everybody money, finance eats up an ever-increasing share of the economy, and I think automation is part of that.

Automation isn't universally good. Sometimes it makes things better, sometimes worse. As technologists our job isn't just to automate everything. It's to use our professional skills and experience to improve the world, to improve human lives.

Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by dtornabene on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:08PM (#10971028)
I feel like you're side stepping the point of his argument. Maybe I'm misreading you both. It read (to me at least) more of a "why isn't hn this hard on other automation stories" and less of an indictment of the (fashionable) distaste for HFT.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Tuesday January 26, 2016 @01:56AM (#10972217)
I suppose one could read it either way. But a) most engineers are pro-automation, b) he works for a financial company, and c) computers haven't really replaced people in finance, so absent other evidence, I am going to stick with my reading of his comment for now.
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by oldmanjay on Monday January 25, 2016 @03:58PM (#10969886)
How does one eat a share of the economy? Do I have to assume it to be zero sum for the concept to be clear?
Re:Michael Lewis: The Scourge of Wall Street by wpietri on Monday January 25, 2016 @04:25PM (#10970056)
You don't have to assume zero sum in general. Just that some interactions can be zero or negative sum. The simple example is monopoly rents: monopolists can increase their share of total profits without increasing value delivered.

By a lot of measures, the financial industry captures a lot more money than they did in previous decades. But it's far from clear that they're delivering a lot more value, and given that computers have drastically reduced their costs, it's reasonable to expect them to be smaller, not larger. As a start, this has some good graphs:

http://esoltas.blogspot.com/2013/02/5-more-graphs-on-finance...

And here are a couple more general-audience articles:

http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2011/03/30/chart-of-th...

http://blogs.wsj.com/economics/2011/12/10/number-of-the-week...