News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Art of Tidying Up by tonyedgecombe on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:24AM (#10966769)
Rather than spending their time clearing out their rubbish I think most people would be better off learning to be more discerning about what they allow into their lives in the first place.
Re:The Art of Tidying Up by throwaway09048 on Monday January 25, 2016 @07:38AM (#10966820)
Yes. But clearing out your rubbish and learning what it's like to live with your not-rubbish is one good way to do that. This is one of the reasons she says you only need to go through the major tidying process once, ever.

One thing I like about the book is that she didn't write it until after years of experience helping people solve the way-too-much-junk problem, so it's based on what actually worked for a variety people who were failing to solve the problem on their own, unlike many self help books that are written only based on the author's experience of being naturally good at something.

Re:The Art of Tidying Up by nlawalker on Monday January 25, 2016 @08:55AM (#10967142)
It's important to put her focus on getting rid of stuff into context: Ms. Kondo is a "tidying consultant" whose clients are mostly affluent people that can't even get started on tidying up in any meaningful way because they simply have more stuff than storage. She tells stories of people throwing out 20, 30, 50 bulging full-size garbage bags of excess stuff - these are people with a lot of money and a lot of accumulated clothes and possessions, and who live in homes large enough to contain it but not organize it. They are also affluent enough to be able to err on the side of getting rid of too much stuff during an enthusiastic round of cleaning. Ms. Kondo exhorts her readers not to buy in bulk in order to avoid clutter - it's not like you need to be super-wealthy to pass up the cost benefits of buying in bulk, but her advice is not meant for people who are just scraping by or for whom the tradeoff of space-for-money makes sense.
Re:The Art of Tidying Up by magic_beans on Monday January 25, 2016 @01:53PM (#10969056)
I'm not sure why you've been greyed out. This is a fantastic point. This is by no means a book for every person. This is hardly even a book for every culture (though it's a huge best-seller in Japan).
Re:The Art of Tidying Up by koralatov on Monday January 25, 2016 @08:26AM (#10967015)
I agree with your sentiment, but what do you do with all of the stuff you already have? Almost nobody reading these books is starting from a position of zero stuff; they're starting from a position of X stuff, with X being an amount higher than they'd like. The real appeal of these books and the philosophy they espouse is that they allow you to whittle down the number of things you already have whilst also learning healthy habits to avoid ending up in the same situation later.
Re:The Art of Tidying Up by tonyedgecombe on Monday January 25, 2016 @01:01PM (#10968703)
The trouble is if people don't deal with the root cause then they will just fill their newly empty homes with junk again.