News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:45PM (#10963207)
A space elevator only provides access to geostationary orbit. One can climb up to LEO altitudes along an elevator, but that doesn't mean much. You wouldn't be in orbit, but sitting stationary as if atop a tall building. So we would still need to launch rockets for any space use in LEO (GPS and imaging sats for example). And any such orbiting objects would of course have to be navigated around this obstruction. Many useful orbit types would have to be outlawed to protect the elevator.

I wonder, is easier to launch into a LEO from the ground or from a fixed point at say 300km altitude? If you climbed a space elevator you would still need 8km/s of speed laterally. So you jump off and fire your rocket. You still fall towards the ground, requiring some thrust to keep out of the atmosphere. Without the arcing trajectory of a ground launch you would have to accelerate roughly twice as quickly, requiring larger engines. Is that really any better than starting from the ground as we do today?

Or you could climb to a near-geostationary position, burn retrograde until you touch the atmosphere, then aerobrake down to LEO. That's still a heck of a lot of effort.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by jasonpeacock on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:53PM (#10963242)
Any height is an advantage in achieving orbit. It's an exponential problem - you need fuel to go up, and you need more fuel to lift the fuel you need to go up, etc.

Also, air resistance is much more at the surface than higher up.

So by starting your ascent at a high altitude you need much less fuel both because you need less fuel, and because there is less air resistance (friction).

Space elevators still need to use the same energy to lift something, but they use an external power source so do not need to lift their own fuel, and they lift more slowly and greatly reduce the effect of air resistance.

So no, a space elevator won't get you to "outer space", but it creates a stepping stone which greatly reduces the cost of getting there.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:05PM (#10963295)
Air resistance is a very minor issue for rockets. Long/thin things are very slippery and once at 10-20-30,0000 meters the air is basically gone.

Jumping off the elevator from LEO altitudes would still require one to fight gravity, to avoid dipping back into the atmosphere before getting to orbital velocities. So there are still gravity-related losses to account.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by enraged_camel on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:21PM (#10963373)
This isn't correct. Air resistance increases at the rate of velocity squared. At the speed those rockets achieve, is is a big factor. Elon Musk himself likened the atmosphere to a "thick soup" when it comes to launching rockets to space.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:28PM (#10963397)
My understanding is that atmospheric drag on a standard launch vehicle to leo is on the order of 300-400m/s, a small fraction of the total budget.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by mixedmath on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:51PM (#10963231)
I believe you have a fundamental misunderstanding of the speed of the top of a space elevator. The counterweight at the top of a space elevator would be approximately at geostationary orbit. If you were to be up there and "drop" a baseball, say, it would appear to hang there motionless, as it would also be (approximately) at geostationary orbit.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:13PM (#10963335)
I believe you have misread my post. I see no issue with geostationary orbits. I'm talking about the low earth orbits on which we so depend.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by CapitalistCartr on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:53PM (#10963240)
Neither. For LEO the object is released at well above the desired orbit and as it drops it acquires the needed velocity. Some fuel is still needed but not nearly so much.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:03PM (#10963284)
So it drops, but how does one translate that it into orbital, lateral, velocity?
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by parenthephobia on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:19PM (#10963364)
It doesn't drop vertically back down the elevator cable! It performs a Hohmann transfer from GSO to LEO.

The delta-v to transfer from GSO to an LEO at 400km is 4km/s, whilst to go from ground level is about 7km/s.

That's a significant fuel reduction, _and_ that fuel doesn't have to go up all at once: you can keep fuel tankers at the GSO station and fuel up a rocket from there.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hohmann_transfer_orbit

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by johngalt on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:05PM (#10963548)
I believe you are overestimating the cost of a transfer from GEO to LEO and underestimating the costs from ground to LEO. Specifically you haven't accounted for the earth's atmosphere.

The earths atmosphere adds to the cost of ground launch (drag) and subtracts from the cost of GEO->LEO transfer (aerobrake). Instead of 4km/s transfer vs 7km/s direct, it should be 2km/s vs 9km/s.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:32PM (#10963410)
4k/s is still a huge number. This will still involve a rocket 1/4 to 1/8th the power of a ground launch. AND, pieces or not, that thing has to be hauled up the elevator.

So my point still stands. The space elevator will only provide ready access to geostationary orbit. Journeys to more useful low orbits will benefit marginally at best.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by CapitalistCartr on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:42PM (#10963707)
Only if you release it from GSO, but that's not ideal. Release it from a higher altitude than LEO, but far less than GSO and it takes vastly less fuel.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by parenthephobia on Sunday January 24, 2016 @04:10PM (#10964023)
Ah yes.

There's a lower point on the cable where you're already in an elliptical orbit with the perigee at the altitude you want.

For a target orbit of 400km, that happens at about 23.8Mm, 57% of the way up the cable. At that point you just have to let go of the cable and you'll only need a circularizing burn when you reach 400km: Δv of ~2,137m/s.

This is not taking into account the further savings from aerobraking as I don't know how to calculate that.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by JupiterMoon on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:38PM (#10963437)
LEO is useful for current satellites. But not that useful for moving human influence beyond Earth's surface.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by CapitalistCartr on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:16PM (#10963348)
One doesn't. Its already in orbit, but not travelling fast enough. As it trends downward, it gains velocity until it reaches stable orbit. If the maths were done correctly, that will be the desired orbit. If the maths are in error, an opportunity for experience is gained.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by johngalt on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:38PM (#10963436)
You are right jumping off at LEO altitude would be silly. Which is why you would go to GEO then transfer to LEO. GEO is something like 35,000 km high. You burn your rockets to fall towards low orbit, then pick up all the velocity you need falling towards LEO. Burn again once at perigee (or aerobrake) to steer your orbital path into circular rather than elliptical.

A transfer from GEO to LEO is significantly cheaper than reaching LEO from the ground. Additionally transfer from GEO to anywhere else in the solar system is really cheap. It is hard to overstate just how much of an advantage a space elevator would be in reaching any location in the solar system including LEO.

The only disadvange is travel time. Rockets to 300km get there quickly. Elevators to 35000km get there slowly.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by didgeoridoo on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:49PM (#10963222)
You wouldn't have to contend with gravity loss (energy expended by performing work against gravity) or atmospheric drag, so all else being equal it would be a net energy win. Definitely not a free ride though.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by ceejayoz on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:00PM (#10963275)
> A space elevator only provides access to geostationary orbit.

No, it provides access well above geostationary orbit.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator#/media/File:Spa...

Time things right and you can basically fling off the end like the tip of a whip and head anywhere in the system.

Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by sandworm101 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:04PM (#10963287)
Anywhere up, I cannot see how it is to fling things down to low earth orbits.
Re:People Are Still Trying to Build a Space Elevator by dogma1138 on Sunday January 24, 2016 @01:34PM (#10963426)
Delta-V here's a good map http://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png

The Delta-V required to get from the surface of the earth to leo is 9-10, meaning it requires less energy to launch a payload from the moon to earth's LEO than from the surface of the earth to LEO. This can even be more optimized using aerobraking, anything that will be launched (or flung) from the launch platform of the space elevator will have higher orbital velocities than an object in LEO so what you really need to do is to slow down. Because there is still a pool of gravity the object will be in free fall so it only requires relatively small delta-v to bring it down to a lower orbit and you can use the atmosphere to both slow it down further (which can cut down on fuel) and if you design your delivery vehicle correctly can even get into very interesting orbits cheaply by skipping on top of the atmosphere and using the earth for gravity assist.