You wouldn't survive doing math with longer variable names. Imagine yourself writing "time" every time you need to write it in a formula in the course of a working on a problem. Just expand the following expression (time + 2)(2time - 3)(4time + 5) by hand, writing "time" every time. Or imagine studying vector calculus and writing out the formulas with the long names like "grad", "curl", etc. That kind of notation was replaces with the nabla symbol and overloaded notation for a very good reason.
Also, most derivations, for simple formulas even, go through larger complexities before they converge to something slick. Take a look at the derivation of the Navier-Stokes equations [1] and see if you could have done the same thing with longer variable, function and operator names.
So yea, it all boils down to repetition and quantity.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivation_of_the_Navier%E2%80...
Also, long variable names would greatly obscure the overall structure of many formulas, which could be an even bigger problem.
All it would probably take would be for someone to start a math journal that required a minimum of three letter variable names and everyone would switch over.
You have to remember that math is written for the sake of mathematicians' brains, not for the sake of dumb machines which accept only linear strings of a limited character set through a teletype. A mathematician can look at a formula and subconsciously break it down into constituent parts based on its shape. Multi-letter (word? phrase?) variable names would only serve to add unnecessary clutter and obscure the shape of the formula. Meaningfulness of names is a secondary concern, if it is a concern at all; meaning can be established in the text surrounding the formulas or equations; and if things indeed get too complex for a set of a few formulas, the option is always there to switch representations -- to computer code or pseudocode.
The nabla symbol is almost-exclusively used for vector-calculus operations. The letters t, s, u, v are almost-always used for parametrizations. The letters i, j, k, n, m are usually used as indices of summations. We can go on.
I have decided to try a warm up exercises a couple of times before applying but the way they word the questions is so unmeaningful: 'n' lines with y variables, plus spending 20 minutes trying to work out how to read their input. No debugger and not easy way to cut and paste, as its all in a web form.
Fuck that, I am a software engineer, I usually read data from databases and name my variables properly and use tools to help me understand the problem, not hinder myself.
Jesus, please send me back to XXth century.
You want me to do something in a rush give me the tools I am used to. Should I code in C rather than python just to prove I can?
Can't really think of one that could be improved by writing it as pseudo code.
Even every proof can be expressed as a program, see Curry–Howard correspondence [1].
> and most variables don't have a fixed meaning.
I think this is kind of the point of the original comment. For a physicist PV=nRT is concise and clear but for everyone else? The letters P, V, n, R, T can have many meanings but in the context of this formula their meaning is fixed. Why not write:
pressure * volume = AVOGADRO * BOLTZMAN * temperature
> Can't really think of one that could be improved by writing it as pseudo code.See example above, but I think it strongly depends on what one is familiar with.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curry%E2%80%93Howard_correspon...
Well, that is true, but that's still pretty far removed from any common programming language. And readability doesn't usually improve.
>For a physicist PV=nRT is concise and clear but for everyone else?
You've somewhat got a point there, physics would be a lot easier if all formulas and variables were actually defined when needed. But symbolic notation is still a necessity, simply because symbolic manipulation is really powerful, and it's a pain to have to write 'BOLTZMAN_CONSTANT' every single time, instead of just k_B.
Also, your notation might work for simple equations like the ideal gas equation, but an equation that's only slightly more complicated, the van der Waals equation, would become quite hideous:
(pressure + number_of_particles^2 * attraction / volume^2) * (volume / number_of_particles + excluded_volume) == BOLTZMANN_CONSTANT * number_of_particles * temperature
I really wouldn't want to have to write that out several times just to do some calculations with it.