Re:Why programming is a good medium for expressing poorly un...
by narrator on Sunday January 24, 2016 @12:55AM
(#10961652)
I think that the short variable names in math come from the time when these things had to be written out in long hand on blackboards. You ever see old sci-fi movies, like "The Day The Earth Stood Still" where professors are working out ideas on huge blackboards? Having long variable names wouldn't fit on the blackboard and would be slow and hurt your hands.
Re:Why programming is a good medium for expressing poorly un...
by wtallis on Sunday January 24, 2016 @02:33AM
(#10961836)
The lack of an efficient IME for verbose math input on a computer certainly accounts for why math is still terse when done in real-time such as when extemporaneous lectures or when working something out. But I don't think it fully explains why the convention persists even in published works that took months or years to prepare; there's got to be a significant effect for the readers and not just the writers. If a longhand style of presentation were as clearly superior for mathematics as for software source code, one probably would have caught on by now.
Re:Why programming is a good medium for expressing poorly un...
by narrator on Sunday January 24, 2016 @03:06AM
(#10961899)
It's probably just the weight of tradition from the longhand days that leads people to use the short variable names, not that it's somehow better, even on a computer.
All it would probably take would be for someone to start a math journal that required a minimum of three letter variable names and everyone would switch over.
Re:Why programming is a good medium for expressing poorly un...
by GFK_of_xmaspast on Sunday January 24, 2016 @11:02AM
(#10962850)
Who would want to submit to such a journal?
Also, long variable names would greatly obscure the overall structure of many formulas, which could be an even bigger problem.